AdventAI

CONTRIBUTORS AND PUBLISHERS.

By Editor

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 13., April 1, 1890

An experience probably common to every writer is, to have occasion frequently to wonder what the editor is thinking of that he does not publish his article. Contributors to the REVIEW, we presume, are no exception to the rule. But of general articles it is rarely the case that one is, or can be conveniently, given a place in the paper for which it was designed, in the first issue after its reception.

Unless it is what is called “time matter,” that is, matter the interest in which depends on circumstances then present, and which will lose its value if postponed, there are several considerations which may conspire to delay its appearance. Thus, the subject may have been recently, and for the time being sufficiently, treated upon; more pressing matter may demand the space; the editor may think it would be more timely at some other period; or he may wish more time for its consideration.

The REVIEW some years ago suggested to its correspondents that the delay of articles sent in for publication in its columns, was not always to be taken as a sign that they were not accepted; for, on the principle that sound winter apples will keep, so good articles which will be all right any time, sometimes have to wait.

An entertaining article on the subject of delayed manuscripts appeared in the December (1889) number of The Author, in some paragraphs of which some of our correspondents, at least, we feel quite sure will be interested. It first alludes to an incident mentioned by Puck, namely, that a person contributed an article to a magazine, which was accepted. Twenty years afterward that person became editor of the same magazine, and among its literary resources, found his old accepted article of twenty years before. He then conferred with the publisher as to the value of it, as he felt a little delicate about setting a price upon his own productions! After stating this incident, The Author says:—

“This seems like a gross exaggeration, but in the New York Tribune at almost the same time, the story was told of a distinguished American thinker, who thirty years ago wrote an article on Chrysostom for the theological quarterly of which he is the editor, and yet never in all the thirty years has he felt at liberty to use his own article, because he has had so many other available ones awaiting publication, the authors of which might think he had crowded them out in his own favor.

“A prominent clergyman relates that more than ten years ago, when he was a theological student, he wrote an article at the invitation of the editor of a certain Review, and a few days ago received the proof-sheets for correction. When the article is paid for on acceptance, such delay is of no serious consequence to the author, excepting that he is naturally anxious to see his work in print, hoping that it will add to his reputation; but if the manuscript is to be paid for on publication, a long delay may greatly inconvenience a needy author. A writer who had a sketch accepted by one of the leading magazines, found that he was to receive his pay when it was published. He waited patiently for many months, until at last, needing money, he wrote the editor, a step not taken without much hesitation, as it was the first time he had succeeded with one of the principal monthlies. To his surprise and delight, the editor sent him a check in a few days, and published his article shortly afterward.

“It is a well-known fact that the editors of nearly all the important periodicals have material enough on hand to last them for years, and only special articles on matters of passing interest have much chance of being published within a reasonable time. Thus the Century last spring stopped its presses to crowd in an article by Hon. T. B. Reed on the rules of the House of Representatives, and at another time made room for an article on Samoa, because if these contributions were held till they could be used in the regular course, they would lose their special interest to the public.

“It sometimes happens, also, that the editor is greatly struck by some manuscript, and prints it, while he holds back other work. Mrs. Catherwood’s ‘Romance of Dollard’ is one of these exceptions. The editor of the Century told her frankly that he had stories enough to last for years, and that even if he accepted hers, it might make her heart sick waiting for it to be published. On reading it, however, he was so pleased with it that he not only accepted it at once, but published it very shortly afterward.

“Such instances are rare, indeed, almost phenomenal. Generally, articles even of great merit have to wait till they are available. The editor of a popular periodical told me some two years ago that he had discovered a remarkable story-writer; that he had accepted several of her sketches, and paid for them; and that she would make her mark in the world. Yet, in spite of this editor’s faith in the value of these sketches, he has not found an opportunity to publish a single one of them up to this time.

“Often matter which is accepted and paid for gets to be out of date, or some one else publishes a better article on the same subject, or for certain reasons the editor changes his mind, and does not care to print it. Even solicited articles are not always published. Some years ago a magazine publisher was dining out, and the conversation turned on one of our great statesmen. A gentleman present had known him intimately, and told, in a very happy manner, several stories relating to him. The publisher was so much pleased that he made the narrator a liberal offer to write out his reminiscences of the great man. The offer was accepted, and the article was written and paid for as agreed, but, unfortunately, the writer, while a charming story-teller, was prolix and prosy when he came to use the pen, and the stories which had been applauded at the dining-table lost their interest when placed on paper. The article has never been published, and probably never will be, but its author is doubtless patiently waiting for its appearance, and wondering how long editors keep manuscripts before they publish them.”