BY LLOYD J. CALDWELL.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
From Eld. J. H. Waggoner’s recent and convincing pamphlet, “The Origin and Growth of Sunday Observance,” pp. 40, 41, comes this pointed extract:—
It is abundantly proved, beyond all chance of denial, that the first law of any kind for resting from worldly labor on the first day of the week, was that of Constantine, who commanded only certain classes to rest upon it as the venerable day of the sun, in conformity with his worship of Apollo, the sun-god. And in less than half a century after that time, a Catholic council enacted a canon which was accepted as orthodox, which not only contained the first formal church laws for the observance of the Sunday, but likewise forbade the observance of the seventh-day Sabbath under penalty of being accursed from Christ! Now, if any one can imagine what would be changing the Sabbath, if this is not, I would be extremely happy to learn what it could be.
The following is Constantine’s decree:—
Let all the judges and towns-people, and the occupation of all trades, rest on the venerable day of the sun; but let those who are situated in the country freely and at full liberty attend to the business of agriculture; because it often happens that no other day is so fit for sowing corn and planting vines; lest the critical moment being let slip, men should lose the commodities granted by Heaven.—Schaff’s Church History, vol. 2., chap. 3 (Plov).
And this is the twenty-ninth canon of the Council of Laodicea (A. D. 364) referred to:—
Christians shall not Judaize, and be idle on Saturday, but shall work on that day. But the Lord’s day they shall especially honor, and as being Christians, shall, if possible, do no work on that day. If, however, they are found Judaizing, let them be shut out from Christ.—Hefele’s Hist. Councils, vol. 2, p. 316.
The Encyclopedia Britannica, art. “Sunday,” says:—
The earliest recognition of the observance of Sunday as a legal duty is a constitution of Constantine in 321 A. D., &c.
Says Chambers’s Encyclopedia, art. “Sabbath”:—
Unquestionably the first law, ecclesiastical or civil, by which the Sabbatical observance of that day [Sunday] is known to have been enjoined, is the edict of Constantine, 321 A. D.
Alexander Campbell said:—
Was the first day set apart by public authority in the apostolic age?—No. By whom was it set apart? and when?—By Constantine, who lived about the beginning of the fourth century.
Who will disprove these by quoting authority for a different statute or date? It never has been done or attempted. The following authorities will speak for themselves concerning the Laodicean Council and canon:—
The Council of Laodicea, about 363, forbids all Judaizing on the Sabbath, but enforces a Christian use of the Lord’s day.—Hessey’s Sunday, lect. 3.
The Council of Laodicea, while condemning the Judaical observance of the day [Sunday], directed that labor should be avoided on it as far as possible.—Ph. Smith’s Hist. Chr. Ch., p. 293. (Harper’s, 1879.)
The Council of Laodicea, near the close of the fourth century, ordains that Christians should not celebrate this day in a Jewish manner, nor feel bound to abstain from labor.—Butler’s Eccl. Hist., chap. 30, p. 277. (Phil. 1868.)
Council of Laodicea allows labor on Sunday if it be necessary, and forbids its Jewish observance.—H. B. Smith’s Tables of Ch. Hist., p. 19.
Petavius . . . particularly takes notice that the Council of Laodicea forbids Christians to esteem the Sabbath a day of rest from labor.—Lardner’s Works, IV., p. 217.
There is evidence of the same tendency in the opposite canon [twenty-ninth] of the Council of Laodicea [about 363] which forbids Christians from Judaizing on the Sabbath day, preferring the Lord’s day, and, as far as possible, resting as Christians.—Encyc. Brit., art. “Sunday.”
Laodicea, Council of, an important council held at Laodicea in Phrygia in the fourth century. . . . Thirty-two bishops were present, . . . and sixty canons were published which were accepted by the other churches. Canon twenty-nine forbids Christians observing the Jewish Sabbath.—McClintock and Strong’s Cyc.
The Council of Laodicea (A. D. 364), however, enjoined Christians to rest on the Lord’s day. To the same effect is an injunction in the forgery called the Apostolical Constitutions and various other enactments from A. D. 600 to A. D. 1100, though by no means extending to the prohibition of all secular business.—Id., art. “Lord’s Day.”
An important ecclesiastical council, the first Council of Laodicea, was held here in 363, which adopted resolutions concerning the canon of the Old and New Testaments.—People’s Cyc., art. “Laodicea.”
The Council of Laodicea, A. D. 364, first settled the observance of the Lord’s day, and prohibited the keeping of the Jewish Sabbath under an anathema.—Wm. Prynne, in Dissert. on the Lord’s Day, pp. 32–4.
In many districts a punctual Jewish observance of the Sabbath must have doubtless been common. Hence the Council of Laodicea considered it necessary to ordain that Christians should not celebrate this day after the Jewish manner, nor consider themselves bound to abstain from labor.—Torrey’s Neander’s Hist. Chr. Relig. II., p. 334. (Hurd & Houghton, New York.)
The custom of abstaining from secular avocations upon this day, which had been long prevalent in the Church, now became an ecclesiastical enactment by the twenty-ninth canon of the Council of Laodicea (between 360–4). This council also recommended laboring on Saturday.—Shedd’s Guericke’s Ch. Hist., par. 78, p. 297. (Andover, 1860.)
It had been the custom of the Church to observe Sunday by special religious exercises and by an increasing abstinence from the pursuits of secular life. This custom was made a law by the Council of Laodicea (363).—Fisher’s Hist. of the Ch.
The Council of Laodicea, while it condemned all Judaizing in the observance of the [Lord’s] day, directed that labor should be avoided on it as far as possible. The custom of observing the Sabbath in a similar manner to the Lord’s day was now declining. The Laodicean canon which has just been quoted, denounced a cessation from labor on it as Judaical.—Robertson’s History of the Chr. Ch., vol. 2, p. 55. (Young & Co., N. Y., 1874.)
It was the seat of two important general councils of the Christian Church: the first, whose date is variously placed from 363 to 372, enacted sixty canons.—Johnson’s New Univ. Cyc., art. “Laodicea.”
The universal councils through their disciplinary enactments or canons were the main fountain of ecclesiastical law. To their canons were added the decrees of the important provincial councils of the fourth century, at Ancyra and Laodicea between 343 and 381; and in a third series the orders of eminent bishops, popes, and emperors.—Philip Schaff’s Hist. Chr. Ch., pp. 353–4. (N. Y., Scribner’s, 1869.)
Thus the canons of the councils held in the East during the schism, at Antioch A. D. 341, Laodicea about 363, and Gangra between 362 and 370, were still maintained in the East, and at length were adopted even in the West.—Gieseler’s Text Book Eccl. Hist. I., p. 206. (Phil. 1836, Carey.)
Similar decrees [to Constantine’s Sunday decrees] were also passed by various councils, requiring a faithful attendance upon public worship, and a strict observance of the day by solemn suspension of all secular pursuits, and abstinence from amusements and vain recreations. The Council of Laodicea, canon twenty-nine, about the same time forbade the observance of the Jewish Sabbath.—Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., p. 531. (Phil. 1852, Lippincott.)
Says Eld. Waggoner, in the pamphlet mentioned at the beginning of this article, p. 60, referring to the plea that the Laodicean Council was an Eastern one, and not therefore papal:—
The sum of the matter is this: the primacy of Rome was declared in the East; the supremacy of Rome over all the churches was established in the East; all the general councils previous to the twelfth century were held in the East; all the churches East and West were united into one hierarchy by Constantine, and the actual division into Eastern and Western churches was not until the tenth century. Therefore, the councils held in the East were councils of the Catholic Church established by Constantine; they were councils of that church of which the bishop of Rome was primate, his primacy having been established in Asia Minor, in A. D. 325
Concerning the scope of authority given to the canons of council, observe the following:—
He likewise added the sanction of his authority to the decisions of bishops passed at their synods, and forbade the provincial governors to rescind any of their decrees: for he rated the priests of God at a higher value than any judge whatever.—Eusebius’s Life of Constantine, b. 4, ch. 27.
Important principles were established by the Council of Nicea, 325 A. D.
In questions of religious belief, the emperor was to consult the church assembled in general council.
The authority of the emperor made these ecclesiastical enactments a part of the laws of the empire.—Butler’s Eccl. Hist., ch. 24.
Theodosius, who was a zealous adherent of the Council of Nicea, at once declared the doctrines there sanctioned to be the only true faith, and persecuted every other. He called the Council of Constantinople, A. D. 381, which confirmed the Council of Nicea, and added new articles against later heresies.—Gieseler’s Eccl. Hist., vol. 1, p. 204.
The doctrines of the first four [ecumenical councils] were raised by the Emperor Justinian to the level of the Holy Scriptures, and their decrees to the rank of imperial laws.—Stanley’s Eastern Ch., lect. 2.
It was claimed, indeed, for the decrees of councils generally, that they were dictated by the Spirit of God; that they were of equal authority with the word of God; that they contained all that was essential to eternal life; and that to disregard them was to sin against the Holy Ghost.—Coleman’s Anc. Chris. Exemp., p. 489.
In A. D. 380 the three Roman emperors, Theodosius, Gratian, and Valentinian, commanded all their subjects to receive the faith of St. Peter as held by Pope Damasus. They forbade all heresy and apostasy, and here began the State-Church system of persecution. (See “Gibbon’s Rome,” ch. 27; “Ranke’s History Popes,” vol. 1, ch. 1; “Schaff’s Church History,” vol. 2, p. 142; “Sozomen’s Ecclesiastical History,” b. 7; “Gieseler’s Ecclesiastical History,” vol. 1, p. 269; “Butler’s Ecclesiastical History,” ch. 30; “Holland’s Rise of Intel. Liberty,” p. 116; “Waddington’s Church History,” ch. 7; etc., etc.)
Fifteen severe edicts enforced this decree against Paganism, Arianism, and every form of dissent, with every sort of penalty and with such success that Catholicism alone was tolerated till the Peace of Augsburg, 1555. Constantine (306–337), Theodosius I. (379–395), and Justinian (527–565) are the three emperors whose talents and bigotry made Catholicism supreme, and banished religious freedom from the Roman world. No wonder “the Church” has a flattering opinion of them! Justinian gave all men but three months to embrace the Catholic faith or lose all office, property, and right of inheritance. (See Bower’s “History of the Popes,” vol. 1, p. 334.)
The emperors and popes and councils followed uniformly in the wake of the twenty-ninth canon of Laodicea in their sabbath teaching, from thenceforward. Why did not that canon forbid Sunday work entirely?—Because Constantine’s edict of A. D. 321 allowed farm work, and this the Church could not stop. It was left to Charlemagne, A. D. 800, to order Sunday work stopped, and all to come to church on that day. (See Crafts’s Sabbath for Man, p. 556; Sabbath Essays, p. 241; Kingsbury’s, The Sabbath, p. 209.)
Thus was the Sabbath of the Lord trampled underfoot, and the Sunday of the heathen adopted in its stead. What chance was there for the humble few who still honored God’s Sabbath, to withstand the tremendous current of incoming pagans, retaining their sun-day of feasting? Still more, how could they outlive the all-powerful union of Church and State that stamped out public paganism and open Arianism—the most powerful systems of the day? Keeping in mind the fierce prejudice against everything Jewish, or that could be made to seem so, we can easily see that such despots as Theodosius, Justinian, Augustine, the Innocents, and the Leos would make short work of sabbatizing; especially when backed by such unquestioned authority as this twenty-ninth canon of Laodicea.