AdventAI

A FOOLISH CLAIM.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 22., June 3, 1890

THE editor of the American Baptist is indulging in a series of articles on “Seventh-day Adventism.” There are two encouraging features about such a move: one is that this work has assumed such prominence that preachers and editors begin to feel that something must be done to arrest it; and the other is that it compels its opponents to expose the weakness of their arguments against it.

Speaking of our views that the wicked will all be finally destroyed, he says: “This doctrine removes from great criminals the fear of the wrath to come.” A sentence could not be spoken or written which would betray a more utterly shallow treatment of the subject, nor one which is more absolutely without foundation.

1. The doctrine of eternal hell fire does not deter great criminals from crime, as this would intimate. Who ever saw a person who wished to commit a crime, but acknowledged himself to be deterred from it by the theological assertion of an eternal hell?—No one. Such a case never has been found.

2. The Bible doctrine that God will destroy all the wicked, instead of torturing them in fire forever, never removed a particle of restraint from any criminal, so that he felt more free to do the crime than he did before. Who ever saw a criminal who pleaded as a reason for his commission of the crime that he had been taught that God would only destroy the wicked and not burn them forever?—No one; such a case cannot be found.

3. What, then, becomes of such an assertion?—It is simply a piece of ad captandum nonsense. On the other hand, hundreds can be found who have been rescued from skepticism and lives of sin, by learning that the Bible did not teach the absurd and horrible doctrine of eternal conscious misery for the one short life of probation here. They couldp. 345 not believe such a doctrine as eternal misery. Criminals do not believe it; and it does not deter them from crime. But when a man comes to see that a punishment is threatened which is reasonable, then he begins to fear it; and when he sees that God’s ways are just, he feels like turning to his service.