THE GOSPELS FROM A LAWYER'S STAND-POINT.
The four Gospels purport to contain a history of our Lord Jesus Christ; the authors are not living; the characters they therein describe are no more. No man living knows by direct personal knowledge that these things were so. But why not apply the same rules of evidence and belief to scriptural history as to profane? Being in existence and a minute narrative of passing events, they must either be genuine and true, or a gross forgery. There is no alternative. They were true when written, or were then an absolute falsehood. If the latter, they must then have been known to be false, and an imposition on the credulity of those then living. These stories began to be published not long after the alleged crucifixion. Many persons were then living who could have refuted the statements of the evangelists, had they been untrue. The enemies of Jesus were still alive and active. The scribe and the Pharisee, the priest and the Levite still smarted under his repeated denunciations. They had the disposition and the means to deny the miraculous birth, the spotless life, the marvelous works, the sublime death, and the astounding resurrection of our Lord, had the published descriptions of these events been totally fabulous. But, so far as we know, no living person ever uttered a protest against them which has been handed down to us. We have at this day in perfection the writings of the heathen philosophers, poets, and historians of that and of a much earlier age, but no intimation by any historian, poet, or philosopher of those times that the published accounts of the evangelists were not reliable; and for nearly 2,000 years they have been received and treated as veritable history. Again, being written, they must have been written by some persons; and they must have been written by either bad men or good men, by liars or by truth-tellers, by forgers or by honest historians. Is there any alternative? Do wicked men write such books as these? Do liars proclaim that they and all other liars shall have their part in the lake that burneth with fire and brimstone? Does the thief denounce dishonesty, or the adulterer proscribe uncleanness? If, then, not penned by wicked men, they must owe their origin to honest men; and if honest and truthful men wrote them, they must be honest and true narratives, and not a tissue of falsehoods. Is not the conclusion irresistible? But, aside from these general considerations, there is another important fact; viz., that each Gospel itself contains internal, indirect, but cogent proof of genuineness. Thus, take the Gospel of Matthew. He, and he alone, records the circumstance of Jesus' paying tribute to the tax-collector of Capernaum. Chap. 17: 24–27. How do we account for this? Why should Matthew be more likely to mention that particular fact than any other evangelist? When we remember that he was himself a tax-gatherer, familiar with their habits, attentive to all that related to that profession, the answer is obvious. Would a man forging the four Gospels remember that he must make Matthew state this fact of paying a tax and the others not? So Matthew alone informs us that, after Jesus' burial, the Jews went and “made the sepulcher sure, sealing the stone, and setting a watch.” How does it happen that Matthew alone mentions this fact? Why should he remember what others did not? The people of Judea were oppressively taxed under the Roman domination, and excessive taxation always leads to evasion, cunning, and fraud on the one hand, and on the other to increased vigilance, caution, and close scrutiny. Accustomed, therefore, to suspicion of fraud and evasion, Matthew would naturally be the most impressed by, and the most likely to record, a fact which tended to show that in the event in question deception was carefully guarded against. So in Mark's Gospel we often find explanations of Jewish terms and phrases, which are not found in corresponding verses of Matthew about the same event. If we remember that Matthew was writing to Jews who understood the terms already, and Mark to Gentile converts, who did not, we have the answer. What a skillful forger must he have been to anticipate all that! Luke also has many indirect proofs of truthfulness. Thus, in the miracle of the leper, Matthew and Mark simply speak of Christ as healing “a leper;” Luke says the man was “full of leprosy.” Again, the first two say Peter's wife's mother lay “sick of a fever;” Luke says that she was “taken with a great fever;” and, while the other evangelists speak of a man who had “a withered hand,” Luke writes “his right hand was withered.” Why this more accurate observation and description by Luke of every circumstance of disease, and of mental or physical suffering, than can be found in any other historian? What was there in his profession which qualified him thus to note and describe diseases more minutely than others? Turn to Col. 4: 14, and you have the answer, where Paul, writing to the Colossians, closes his letter thus: “Luke, the beloved physician, and Demas greet you.” Did these two writers prearrange this roundabout confirmation? John's Gospel also contains internal proof of its ingenuousness. Thus, in chapter 6: 66, soon after the miracles of the loaves and fishes, we read: “From that time many of his disciples went back, and walked no more with him;” and again, in chap. 7: 5, that “neither did his brethren believe on him.” What an admission for a writer who was concocting a stupendous fraud to impose upon the world—to openly proclaim that the impostor whose pretensions he was endeavoring to bolster up, could not even retain the confidence of those who were in daily personal contact with him! And this from a man who was his most devoted admirer! Candor might lead a historian to do that, but disingenuousness never. But still another, more striking characteristic is found in John's Gospel. He omits all reference to many events which the other evangelists record in full. Does not the fact that John's Gospel was written long after the other three had been published to the world, suggest that he thought it unnecessary to repeat what they had described so minutely? Thus, by undesigned coincidences, by indirect confirmations, by unexpected corroborations, scattered throughout these four histories, we may be abundantly satisfied both of the truth and the harmony of the Gospels; so that to the eye of mere reason and intellect the variances in these stories do not detract from their reliability, but rather the opposite. What would be our opinion of a man who denied the real existence of another merely because four photographs, one a front and one a back view, and two others of opposite sides did not present the same features? It is from the four views combined that you get the fullest and truest idea of the person portrayed. So from the combined pictures of the acts and doings of our Lord do we best comprehend the fullness of his life and power. Let not, therefore, the criticisms of the skeptic, the jeers of the scoffer, or the doubts of the agnostic disturb our calm confidence in the existence and attributes of Him whose earthly life, miracles, and doctrines are thus sketched in the Gospels. Nay, let us rather, with that certainty derived from reason, faith, and love combined, confidently proclaim with the inspired apostle, “I know in whom I have believed;” or, with that perfect and upright man of old, “I know that my Redeemer liveth.”—From an address by Judge Edmund H. Bennett, as reported in Zion's Herald.