MORE FREE ADVERTISING

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 17, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 24.

Read the full edition

MORE FREE ADVERTISING.

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.
(Ridgeway, N. Y.)
Under the heading, “Bible Readings for the Home Circle,” Rev. George S. Mott, D. D., has an article in the Christian Statesman, taken from the New York Mail and Express, which begins as follows:—
Such is the winning title to a book which is being pushed throughout our country, with all the energy that the book canvassers can exercise. And yet we have never examined a work in which a good title has been employed in a more successful way to inculcate pestiferous doctrines. We should be led to expect a volume of devotional articles, and such presentation of divine truth as is currently accepted by evangelical churches. Instead of this, we have chapters teaching the annihilation of the wicked; a state of complete oblivion between death and the resurrection; fanciful interpretations of the prophetic symbols of Daniel and Revelation; attacks upon the first day of the week as the true Sabbath, and upon all legislation designed to protect the civil side of the Sabbath.
In reference to the foregoing, we ask, Do texts of Scripture quoted precisely as they are found in the Bible, “inculcate pestiferous doctrines”? Pestiferous is defined, “Noxious to peace, to morals, or to society; mischievous; destructive; troublesome; vexatious.” Is the Bible as it reads all this or any part of this? If so, his condemnation of “Bible Readings” may be just. The writer says that from the title of the book we should be led to expect “such presentation of divine truth as is currently accepted by evangelical churches.” Now, I should expect that the Scriptures would tell the truth, whether it is “currently accepted” or not. “Instead of this,” he continues, “we have chapters teaching the annihilation of the wicked.” I have carefully examined all the chapters in the book which treat of future punishment, and neither the term “annihilate,” nor any of its derivatives, is to be found in them. In fact, nothing is given as proof or argument but the exact words of Scripture. Therefore it is Dr. Mott himself that has decided that the Bible teaches “the annihilation of the wicked.”
I knew a parallel case years ago. A man of my acquaintance was called to account in the church to which he belonged, on the charge of believing in the annihilation of the wicked. In reply, he simply quoted three texts of Scripture, namely, those texts which affirm that the wicked “shall be punished with everlasting destruction from the presence of the Lord;” that the day that cometh “shall burn them up . . . that it shall leave them neither root nor branch;” and that they “shall utterly perish in their own corruption;” and, said he, “I believe those texts.” Upon consultation, the church committee decided that it “amounted to annihilation,” and accordingly he was expelled.
Those who charge others of giving “fanciful interpretations of the prophetic symbols of Daniel and Revelation,” should give the true interpretation. Nothing is better to refute error than to place the truth by the side of it, and so show the contrast; and those who have no interpretation of the symbols to give, are illy qualified to decide that the interpretation of those who have one is fanciful. It is easy to assert a thing, but quite another thing to prove it.
Again, Dr. M. says, “There is not a line on the title page nor in the preface to indicate the true character of the work. The preface declares, ‘We let the sacred volume stand as its own witness, massing its testimony on the various subjects presented.’ But the testimonies are selected and combined in violation of all rules of fairness or common sense. A more perverted use of Scripture we have seldom seen.” The readers of a book are generally supposed to have “common sense;” and if the Scripture testimonies are “selected and combined in violation of all rules of fairness and common sense,” the reader will be able to discover it. Again, he says, “These views are presented with a fallacious appendage of Scripture.” What can be the meaning of a “fallacious appendage of Scripture”? Are the Scriptures false? or is there anything false in presenting them as they are? Is not “the civil side of the Sabbath” rather fallacious?
Our reviewer further says, “Because of its name and some of its excellent chapters, it has obtained entrance into families which reject its sentiments. Even the clergy have been misled. The writer of this review came very near being entrapped. His suspicion was aroused only when he happened to notice the name and place of the publishers.” It would seem, then, that the name and the place of its publishers are enough to arouse suspicion against any book they may publish, were it even the Bible itself. To any who ask, Can any good thing come out of Nazareth? we answer, Come and see.