WHAT SHALL WE SING?

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jun 17, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 24.

Read the full edition

WHAT SHALL WE SING?

Several of our correspondents of late seem to be considerably exercised over this subject, under the conviction that we ought not to sing anything, as a part of religious worship, except the Psalms set to meter. To some of these we have replied by mail, but the inquiries are numerous enough to indicate that many others may be interested in the question, and we therefore conclude to say a few words upon it in the REVIEW.
The texts referred to on this subject are these: Eph. 5:19: “Speaking to yourselves in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing and making melody in your heart to the Lord;” and Col. 3:16: “Teaching and admonishing one another in psalms and hymns and spiritual songs, singing with grace in your hearts to the Lord.” Conscientious scruples should be dealt with very considerately, yet the conscience may sometimes labor under wrong impressions, and become more restrictive in its operations than is necessary.
The very texts referred to above, quoted to prove that singing should be confined to the psalms, we should take to prove just the reverse. The variety of words used in the texts, would seem to indicate very clearly the variety of singing that is allowed. If the only word used was “Psalms,” there would be more ground to restrict the meaning to what is known in the Bible as “the psalms,” and confine the singing to them. But when it says “psalms and hymns,” what is meant by the “hymns?” If this, too, means “psalms,” why was not that alone sufficient? And when Paul continues, “and spiritual songs,” are these the same as the “hymns” and the “psalms”? If so, why add this word? To make the apostle guilty of a threefold tautology seems hardly allowable. Rather it would seem that anything drawn from any part of God’s word which contains spiritual “instruction” and “admonition,” which ministers “grace,” and makes “melody in the heart,” would be allowable in the service of song.
Song is as much a part of the service of God in the house of worship as prayers and sermons; but the sermon gathers from every part of the word of God whatever will be for the comfort, encouragement, and instruction of the people—whatever will tend to inspire hope and quicken faith. Why may not these elements, taken from other parts of God’s word as well as the psalms, be properly expressed in song? A preacher may give a glowing description of the world to come, from Revelation 21 and 22, and stir the people to transfer their affections and their treasures to that heavenly land. If the same sentiments were embodied in a hymn, and rapturously sung with the spirit and the understanding also, would there be anything out of the way in the hymn, any more than in the sermon? We cannot see that there would be.
One writer particularly objects to some of the hymns in our hymn book designed for funeral occasions, if they deal largely, as some of them do, with references to the departed, and the loss felt in the bereavement. But we remember that the Lord by the prophet Jeremiah takes special occasion to comfort the Rachels bereaved of their children, by referring to their decease and the hope that they shall come again from the land of the enemy. Suppose that was embodied in a hymn and sung, could there be any more objection to that than for the speaker to dwell upon it in his remarks? The object of a funeral service is to pay proper respect to the memory of the dead, and to comfort those who mourn. Material to this end, both in prayers and addresses, is drawn from all sources. Has not the hymn the same privilege? Suppose Isa. 25:8; 26:19; Hos. 13:14; John 11:25, 26; 1 Thess. 4:14-18; Rev. 21:4; &c., &c., should be thrown into hymns to be presented in song at proper times, would not that comport fully with the object of the occasion?
But it may be said that passages of instruction, admonition, comfort, etc., are found in the psalms. Very true. Yet God has seen fit to multiply and enlarge them in other parts of his word, and to give there many things which are not to be found in the psalms. And to all these the preacher has free access. We must insist that the hymn has as much liberty as the sermon; and if the preacher can draw his truths from the whole field of God’s word, so also can the service of song.