As fair and comprehensive a presentation of what is called the public school question, as we have seen, is from M. D. Shutter, pastor of the Church of the Redeemer in Minneapolis, Minn. It was spoken in his church March 30, and the following condensed report of it we copy from the Minneapolis Tribune of March 31:—
Rev. Marion D. Shutter spoke at the Church of the Redeemer last evening, upon the “Recent Decision of the Wisconsin Supreme Court.” “Nothing is more instructive,” said Mr. Shutter, “than a study of those forces in history which produced the separation of Church and State.” These were stated and briefly discussed. They were, abuse of power on the part of the Church; the consolidation of smaller States, making larger ones, and thus giving greater importance to the office of ruler; the rise of the industrial type of society at the close of the Middle Ages, which emphasized the importance of the individual and broke up the old ascetic notions of life, declaring that this world was good and not evil, and that the business of government was to take care of its interests; the revival of learning, which brought back the old Roman ideas of jurisprudence, founding the State upon man’s natural rights and necessities.
“Finally, the multiplication of sects under Protestantism forced the State more and more into a position of neutrality. It must be fair to all and partial to none. It must not discriminate between Catholic and Protestant, Jew and Gentile. In order to carry out this principle, the State must be thoroughly secular, and this must be the character of all the institutions founded and supported by the State. Here we must stand or abandon the victory of the ages!”
“I shall not set up a defense of the secular State; for this doctrine is now very generally accepted. But there are many who still fail to see its logical outcome, who shrink from following the doctrine into all its applications. They are not entirely free from the lingering remnants of ecclesiasticism. This is shown by the criticisms that have been made upon the recent decisions of the supreme court in Wisconsin.”
“The Catholics complained that the reading of the Bible in the public schools was contrary to the constitution of the State; and the supreme court, when the case was carried up, sustained them. The court held that it was a violation of the rights of conscience, that it was sectarian instruction, and that it compelled parents to aid in the support of a place of public worship against their consent. The Bible, therefore, is not to be read in the public schools of Wisconsin. This decision is sound and just.”
“It is now in order to say two things to our Catholic friends, in view of their agency in this matter: 1. That, having rightfully, as we concede, secured the dropping of the Bible, they do not now turn about, and stigmatize those schools as ‘godless.’ 2. That, having removed the stone of stumbling, they should, at least in the State of Wisconsin, give the public schools their hearty support. These two things consistency and honor demand. The public will await results with interest!”
“On the other hand, it remains for Protestants to say whether they will be satisfied and accept the establishment of the public schools upon this basis. It is not reassuring to listen to the clamor from Protestant pulpits. It is not re-assuring to read in Protestant papers such headlines: ‘A Monstrous Judicial Decision—The Bible Unconstitutional;’ and to read under them: ‘This is to exalt the sectarianism of atheism into the place of the Constitution.’ If the public school system of this country is ever overthrown, its downfall will be due as much to the irrational demands of Protestantism as to the active opposition of Catholics.”
“Underlying the opposition to the decision of the Wisconsin Supreme Court are two false assumptions: 1. That this ruling is against the Bible itself. The State has no controversy with the Bible or any other religious book. It simply says that neither the Bible nor any other book of religion shall be taught at public expense. The State does not try to quench the light of the Bible. So far as the merits of the book are concerned, the State is simply neutral; it is not hostile. 2. The other assumption is that Protestants have some rights as citizens which Catholics do not have,—one of these being the right to have their version of the Bible introduced into the schools, to the exclusion of the Catholic version. In a secular government there can be no favoritism.”
“The arguments which justify the exclusion of the Bible from the public schools are two: 1. It should be done in the interests of justice. There is no difference in principle between taxing a Catholic for the building of a Protestant church, and taxing him for the reading of a Protestant Bible. 2. It should be done as a measure of defense. Let the example of Wisconsin be followed in other States, and it will remove the only just ground upon which the Catholics can ask for a division of the public school fund or exemption from taxation. Anything in our public school system that favors Protestantism as distinguished from Catholicism is such, and ought to be forever abolished. So long as the Catholic is obliged to pay for the reading of a version of the Bible, which he rejects, there is more or less justice in his demand. We have no more right to make the public school a Protestant machine than the Catholics have to make it a Catholic machine. Remove the basis of his objections, and then meet him fairly and squarely. Give him to understand that if the State school does not satisfy him, he must support parochial schools at his own expense. He shall not have one dollar of the public money for any such purpose; nor shall he be relieved from taxation. Let him understand also, that the schools belong to the State, and that the arm of the State is pledged to their protection. Let us stand by the doctrine of the secular State, and let us not shrink from its logic! May the day speedily come when the last rag of ecclesiasticism shall be torn from the flag-staff which floats the national banner!”