A LETTER TO AN S. D. B. MINISTER

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · May 13, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 19.

Read the full edition

A LETTER TO AN S. D. B. MINISTER.

BY ELD. D. P. CURTIS.
(Hutchinson, Minn.)
MY DEAR BROTHER: Your very interesting and carefully written letter of Jan. 23, came to hand in due time. . . . I was glad to learn of your establishment in your new charge. Inasmuch as your convictions of duty have not yet led you out of that long-established style of labor, which, to my understanding, fails to fully meet the design of our Lord in sending out his messengers, I am glad that you have become settled, and hope that your new field may prove fruitful, and that your relations may not be disturbed in the manner they were at ——. You speak of “living under the shadow of . . . where the young people especially are well posted and well educated,” and of feeling the responsibility which such a position throws upon you in your ministrations. Allow me to express the hope that this feeling will lead you to drink deep at the living fountain, the unadulterated word of the Lord, that you may be able to bring forth out of its store-house things new and old, like a “faithful and wise servant, whom his lord hath made ruler over his household, to give them meat in due season.” That which was meat in due season a hundred years ago, is not so to-day.
In every age there has been a “present truth,” and the servant who would give “meat in due season” will anxiously inquire what is now that “present truth,” and will give it to the household, “whether they will hear, or whether they will forbear.” You say, “I have in the past learned, and to my joy, new truth, which gives me confidence to believe that God may unfold things new and old to me; and cause me to rejoice in the unearthing of rich treasures.” I have the same cause for rejoicing, and I hope that when, if ever, I come to the point where I shall feel that there is no more for me to learn from the word of God, in other words, that I have graduated, it will be the good pleasure of God to lay me away where I shall not be a stumbling-stone to others. I have no apology to make for any S. D. Adventist, if such there be, as you suggest, who thinks that there is nothing more to learn, further than that he is not fully instructed in the faith; for as a people we believe in keeping pace with advancing light, and in accepting light, from whatever source it may come.
But I will say this, that what may appear to others to be light viewed from their stand-point and tried by their standard, may appear to us darkness, viewed from our stand-point, and tried by our standard, which is the Bible, interpreted by itself. It may be true that some accept our views before they have given them as full an examination as some others might need to give them before accepting them; but I feel thankful that we can present a system of Bible truth that is so clear and connected and harmonious, and which will so commend itself to the understanding, that it only needs to be clearly presented to minds of ordinary intelligence to be accepted. If this remark should seem egotistic to you, I could excuse it on the ground of the difference in the stand-point from which we view these things, and can express the hope that in process of time we may come to see eye to eye.
That our people do not give more attention to the reading of literature outside of our own, is, I think, largely due to the fact that we keep them so well supplied with our own publications, which are full of that which is “meat in due season,” that they have little time to devote to other reading. There certainly is no effort to restrain any one from reading any and all good, wholesome literature which he has the means to procure and the time to read. On the other hand, this is encouraged by our leading brethren, and our offices of publication and our State depositories are supplied with the best selections of books from other publishers, and our people are urged to procure and read them, not excepting the writings of those who teach differently from what we believe on many subjects. I think that if you were conversant with our views and practice in regard to these things, you would not look at the matter in the light that you put it in your letter.
It is true, as you say, that “it takes time to find many truths.” I did not come to my present understanding of Bible truth in a month nor in a year, but was long years engaged in the study and investigation of these questions, and I know how to be patient with others who I can see have an honest and earnest desire to “know the truth,” that it may make them free. You say that “the field of prophecy is both profitable and dangerous.” Possibly it is so, though Peter did not seem to see the dangerous side of it when he said: “We have also a more sure word of prophecy; whereunto ye do well that ye take heed, as unto a light that shineth in a dark place, until the day dawn, and the day-star arise in your hearts; knowing this first, that no prophecy of the Scripture is of any private interpretation. For the prophecy came not in old time by the will of man: but holy men of God spake as they were moved by the Holy Ghost.” 2 Pet. 1:19–21. Nor did Christ appear to consider prophecy dangerous when he said to the two disciples, “O fools, and slow of heart to believe all that the prophets have spoken.” (See Luke 24:25–27.) You say, “Even S. D. Adventists have found themselves mistaken in their interpretations, and started anew.” Will you do me the favor to point out in what particular they “have found themselves mistaken in their interpretations” of prophecy, “and started anew”? for I am not aware that such is the case, and would like to be informed of it if so, simply as a matter of fact.
I come now to the point on which you appear to lay the most stress in your communications, and which seems most objectionable to me; viz., the position which sister White occupies among us. I am aware that this point is one on which our S. D. B. brethren are very sensitive, and that it is perhaps more objectionable to them than any other one point in our whole system. I apprehend, however, that their objections largely grow out of a mistaken application of the language of the angel to John in Rev. 22:18: “If any man shall add unto these things, God shall add into him the plagues that are written in this book.” At least this is generally brought forward by those who object to the work of sister White, in a manner which indicates that in their estimation it furnishes a sufficient and final answer to all claims in that direction. But as you have not intimated anything of this sort, I will not pursue this thought any further. You admit that if what you claim that our people understand her position to be is true, the course which you understand them to pursue would be consistent. But the question is, Does your understanding of our position on that question harmonize with the facts in the case? If I comprehend your language, I think it does not. You say, “She is a dictator of faith and practice,” and no man can have full and hearty fellowship among them, that does not admit her claims, and act accordingly.
That you honestly believe this to be so, I do not doubt; but you have learned long ago that even honest men may be in error, or be mistaken. That she is gifted with “the spirit of prophecy,” we fully believe. But what is “the spirit of prophecy”? Is it that which makes its possessor a “dictator,” or is it that by means of which God points out to his people their errors and sins, and warns them of their dangers, and shows them the path of right? (See Jer. 25:3–7; 35:15; 44:4, 5, and many other scriptures of like import.)
Thus the prophets of old came to the people with the words of the Lord. If the ancient people of God needed such work done for them by “the spirit of prophecy,” do not his people of more modern days need the same? Has human nature changed? Has the Devil changed? But it is said, in reply, that the ancients had not the written word of God as we have. True; but do the moderns pay any better heed to his written word than did the ancients to the spoken word? Do they not need just as much correction, reproof, and instruction in righteousness as the ancients did? Then why object to the work of sister White, which is of this same character, calling the attention of the Church to the word of the Lord? Those who have read her testimonies know that this is her work, to call attention to what the Lord has said, and to direct the mind to, and enforce the claims of, God as set forth in the written word. That some may go to extremes, and make claims for her which she does not make for herself, may be true; but if such will take her own words, they will stand reproved; for she says, “The written testimonies are not to give new light, but to impress vividly upon the heart the truths of inspiration already revealed.” And Paul, to the Thessalonians, says, “Quench not the Spirit. Despise not prophesyings. Prove all things; hold fast that which is good.” And the context shows that this is directly applicable to the Church in the last days. And let me ask, Would it not be better to judge her work from a personal knowledge of her writings, than from what may be gained from the sayings or writings of either friend or foe? You know that infidels base their objections to the Bible largely upon wrong conceptions of what the Bible teaches, gained from the sayings and writings of those who claim to be its exponents, rather than from actual acquaintance with the book itself. So it is in reference to the work of sister White. I have yet to learn of a single person who has given heed to her testimony, whether personal or general, who has been made worse by doing so, or who has lost any love or reverence for the Bible on account of doing so. On the contrary, those who most highly regard her testimonies, are the ones who have the greatest veneration for the Bible. “The tree is known by his fruit.”
In regard to God’s having “set some in the Church, first apostles, secondarily prophets,” &c., you say, “But how can the conclusion follow that the Church now has that precise order?” You cannot deny that this is the order established by Christ in the organization of the Church. Can you show that he has since given any different order? and if not, does not this order remain in full force? What was the object for which this order was established? Paul compares the Church to the human body, and says that the several members were placed as they are, and exercise their respective functions, in order that “there should be no schism [or division, margin] in the body.” 1 Cor. 12:25. And the same idea is more clearly taught, if possible, in Eph. 4:11–16, to which I called your attention in my former letter. But you ask, “Where are the apostles? Do you find any in the nineteenth century?” You will allow me to ask, What is an apostle?—Simply “one sent forth.” Proof.—Paul says (Heb. 3:1): “Consider the Apostle and High-priest of our profession, Christ Jesus.” How was Christ an apostle? Let him answer (John 20:21): “As my Father hath sent me, even so send I you.” Again (John 17:18): “As thou hast sent me into the world, even so have I also sent them into the world.”
You ask again, “Does the revelator speak of more than twelve?” and you add, “If all these gifts, . . . ‘stand forth in the remnant’ Church, then shall we eventually find other apostles than the twelve chosen by Christ?” Would you have me to understand that you do not recognize any other as apostles than the twelve chosen by Christ? I hardly think it, and yet what else can I gather from your language? Then how about Paul? (See 1 Tim. 2:7; 2 Tim. 1:1, and other scriptures.)
You suggest that I “believe in the apostolic succession.” I do, in this sense, that when Christ organized his Church, he placed apostles in it, with other officers, or, if you please, workers; and he gave the apostles the leading position, not necessarily the most important, but the first in point of prominence; and he designed that his Church should go through to the end with all the different orders of workers in it (speaking in an accommodated sense) which he placed there; and it was and is simply and only because of the departure of the Church from “the simplicity that is in Christ,” that these have not been seen in every stage of the gospel work. Do you not believe that Eld. Eli S. Bailey, Eld. Wm. B. Maxson, Eld. N. V. Hull, Eld. Thos. B. Brown, and other leading men in the S. D. B. Church were “sent forth” of Christ to their work? I do. And I just as much believe that Eld. Jos. Bates, Eld. Jas. White, and Eld. J. N. Andrews were “sent forth,” as apostles, if you please. It will not do for us, my brother, to ignore the great prominent facts of the organization of the Church, and the reasons for it; nor, again, the fact that there has been a terrible apostasy of the Church; nor, again, the fact that God is going to bring the Church, his Church, up out of that apostasy, and place it on its former basis, so that when Christ shall return for his people, he will find them such as he left them, and “without spot or wrinkle”—“without fault before the throne of God.”
Again you ask, “If not (any apostles in the nineteenth century), may not the next class be lacking also?” I reply by asking, May not the next one, “evangelists,” be lacking also? and the next, “pastors and teachers”? Why not these as well as any? Is there not danger of losing all of them, if we begin to alter the Lord’s arrangement? I think, my brother, it is the better way to leave the matter just as the Lord has arranged it. . . .
There is another point in your letter which I will notice before I close. You ask in regard to our people, “By what authority do they neglect the great work of heralding the gospel to those in heathen darkness? Does their distinctive mission release them from obedience to this command of Christ?” I think that you certainly cannot be informed in regard to the work which our people are doing in spreading the gospel, or you would not have written thus. Perhaps it is from the fact that our missionary work is accomplished in a different manner from that of other denominations, that it may be thought we are not doing anything in that line; but surely those who know of what we are doing, do not think of charging us with inactivity in the missionary work, even though we have no established mission in China, or Japan, or Africa, after the manner of some other people. Probably no people of our age and numerical and financial strength are doing more than, if as much as, we are, to spread the gospel in the different nations of the world. Our publications are going among almost all nations where the leading languages of the earth—the English, French, German, Scandinavian, Italian, etc.—are spoken, and we have missions established in many of those foreign countries and continents, while tons of our publications go out weekly all over the world, and are reaching thousands where the living preacher would probably not reach hundreds. These go ahead and prepare the way for the living teacher to follow. . . .
You say, “The great points of difference between the S. D. Adventists and myself are, the claim of sister White, the question of ‘soul sleep,’ so called, annihilation of the wicked, and the like. Concerning these, I am open for more light.” These are the very points on which I differed with them when they were first brought to my attention, for the simple reason that I had been educated to believe differently without having examined the Scriptures for myself, to learn what their teaching was in regard to them. When I did this, and laid aside my preconceived opinions and prejudices, I was constrained, against every natural desire and instinct, to abandon my former teaching, and accept the freedom which the truth brings. As I said before, I was a long time coming to my present conclusions, and so I know how to be patient with others who are candidly investigating. . . . In regard to “essentials” and “fundamentals,” probably we might not be very far apart when we came to understand how we used the terms. Much of apparent difference in understanding between parties, arises from a failure to define the terms used, at the outset. I will simply say in regard to the subject of man’s nature and destiny, that I regard it as a fundamental question, and one without a proper understanding of which I do not see how a preacher can understandingly present the plan of salvation to the minds of men. In short, I believe that a failure to understand this subject has led to a large proportion of the skepticism and infidelity that is so prevalent both inside and outside of the Church, and is one of the chief hindrances to the progress of Christianity in the earth. . . . I shall be glad to hear from you whenever you can find the leisure to reply.