FROM CONGREGATIONALISM TO ADVENTISM.
Are They in Error?—Deacon W. M. Lee and Wife Give Their Reasons for Their Change of Views—An Interesting Topic.
The proposed withdrawal of Deacon W. Milton Lee and his wife from the Congregational church in this city to join the Adventists, has, of course, been the subject of much comment among the large circle of friends they possess, and the very full report in the Telegraph, of the prayer-meeting at the Congregational church last week, in which the respected deacon’s course was discussed, naturally aroused more interest. To that report the Telegraph appended a short interview with Mr. Lee, but to-day that gentleman and his estimable wife give more fully their views in the following card:—
“Kalamazoo, April 23, 1890.
“To the Editor of the Telegraph.
“It is with no desire to force ourselves into public notice that the following lines are given to the press. As our cases, however, have been referred to and commented upon publicly, we deem it no more than justice that a few words be said in reply.
“Mrs. Lee and the writer have been professors of Christianity and members of the Congregational Church for a number of years. Ever since starting in this line we have ever tried to keep our minds open to the reception of light and truth, and to cheerfully follow the path of duty wherever it might lead. The severance of church relationship which we were well aware a change of view would occasion, has not been sought nor desired by us; but with the loyalty to convictions of right and duty which Henry Clay had when he said he would rather be right than president, we have felt that we would rather be right than mere nominal members of any church. When we started, we took the Bible as our guide, and to this we still look for our instruction in all matters of faith and practice.
“According to the report of the ‘interesting yet peculiar’ prayer-meeting, held in the First Congregational church last Thursday evening, as given in the Friday evening Telegraph, the pastor, Mr. Waterman, says: ‘Mr. Lee and his wife have fallen into error, and it remains for us to do what may be in our power to bring them back into the church.’ To this we would say that we are as anxious to avoid remaining in error as the church can be for us to do so, and that we are desirous of having the truth whether it leads us into the Congregational church or out of it. But having taken the Bible as our authority for all matters of doctrine, we are forced to demand of those who differ with us and seek to convince us that we are in error, to show us from the Bible wherein we are wrong. We believe that the Scriptures were given by inspiration of God; that they are able to make us wise unto salvation through faith in Christ, and are ‘profitable for doctrine and instruction in righteousness.’ We have recently heard Mr. Waterman preach two discourses upon the Sabbath question, and attempt to give the authority for the change of day. But while showing that Christ is Lord of the Sabbath (Mark 2: 28), and asserting that he therefore had a right to change it, the evidence that he did change it Mr. W. failed to give. The argument fell short at the vital point.
“Furthermore, we see no reason for the change. Man stands in need of the Sabbath the same now as ever. The only foundation for dividing time into periods of seven days is the great facts of creation, and the only reason God gives for setting apart a weekly rest day for man, and commanding him to remember it to keep it holy, is because ‘in six days the Lord made heaven and earth, the sea, and all that in them is, and rested the seventh day.’ Ex. 20: 11.
“And further, from a candid and diligent investigation of the Scriptures, we have been unable to find that the Lord has ever blessed or set apart any other day than the seventh as the weekly Sabbath of rest for man.
“Moreover, we find that there is but one moral law running all through the Bible, which, as Webster says, is summarily contained in the decalogue, or ten commandments, and is thus recognized by nearly all Protestant denominations. This we find was not only the basis of the old covenant, but was also to be an integral part of the new covenant which the Lord promised to make with the houses of Israel and Judah (Jer. 31: 31–33) with this difference, that in the latter it was to be written in the heart.
“It is true that laws are made for the lawless and disobedient, but the only way we know how to learn whether we are lawless or disobedient is to test ourselves by the law. ‘By the law is the knowledge of sin,’ says the apostle, and ‘the strength of sin is the law.’ Rom. 3: 20; 1 Cor. 15: 56.
“While, however, we do not expect to be saved by keeping the law (for no man has ever kept it), but rather by the grace of God through the righteousness of Christ, yet we acknowledge the justice and immutability of the law, and would not dare to go on in open and known violation of it. Instead of adopting the erroneous idea of continuing in sin that grace may abound, Paul says, ‘Let not sin therefore reign in your mortal body.’ Rom. 6: 1–12.
“Whether we or Bro. Waterman and the Congregational Church are in error, we leave for a candid public to decide, reserving only the personal right to follow the dictates of our own conscience.
“MR. AND MRS. W. M. LEE.”