THE Constitution of the United States secures to all its citizens the right to petition the Government for a redress of grievances. The right of a citizen to offer a petition implies the duty of Congress to receive it; otherwise that provision of the Constitution granting the right, would be worthless. But all the States do not make the same provision for the citizens in their respective localities. Three States—Minnesota, Virginia, and West Virginia—entirely ignore this right, while all the others recognize the right with privileges more or less extended.
Thus it will be seen that while three of the States do not recognize in their bills of rights the privilege of their citizens to petition their legislatures for a redress of grievances, they cannot forbid their subjects from petitioning the general Government. In petitioning Congress last winter not to legislate in religious questions, no one went beyond his national privilege. But that privilege was more than the simple expression of sentiment; it represented the will of the petitioners, and imposed on Congress a duty, not only to receive the petitions presented, but to give them due weight in the consideration of the question to which they related.
And until that question has been fully and finally settled, either under the old form in which it was first introduced, or in its amended phase, those petitions must be available, and be allowed to count in the adjustment of the case. This must be so by the authority of the Constitution, otherwise its provisions are but idle words, which hold out only false hopes. It is the privilege of any interested person to inquire after or to examine these petitions at any time, and if they have been prematurely destroyed, the petitioners have just ground for complaint.
Petitions thus presented to Congress are placed on file for the very purpose of examination, and are held open to inspection until the matter to which they related has been settled. The reason for this is obvious. Those who oppose what the petitions ask for, frequently wish to examine them to find some damaging flaw by which the force of the petitions may be parried. For instance: If upon close scrutiny it should be determined that the same hand made several of the signatures, an argument would be drawn from that to show the whole list a forgery. Or, if a name was found there duplicated in the same hand, this would be called deception, and used in open argument to break the force of the petition.
It is to the interest of the advocates of religious legislation, to let all opposing petitions exist. They have gone into the field determined to win, and will leave no stone unturned to overthrow all opposition. When they find that their public opponents appeal to the individual signatures of a million or more of protesting petitioners, and show that they represent more fairly the voice of the people than the 10,000,000 wholesale petitioners gathered by entire churches, societies, and even denominations, the majority of whom probably do not dream that they are represented on that side at all, then will follow an examination of the protesting petitions to find arguments against them.
It will be easy to copy from the petitions the names of a whole township, and forward them with inquiries to some friend in that town. If the answer to those inquiries shows that some of those names represent persons of questionable character, as drunkards, rumsellers, and the like, that fact will be used to show that those who protest are of the lowest grade of society, and that their signatures should have no weight in the case. Any or all of these cases, though seemingly trivial in themselves, can be made to weigh in heated argument. It is necessary to avoid duplicating names, because those sent in are already counted. It is better for every name obtained to be written by the petitioner, and so avoid the occasion for their crying “fraud.” It is better to solicit the names of those only whose business and character are respectable, as all names do not weigh alike under close scrutiny. Were the controversy of little moment to those who seek to mix religion and politics, and thep. 4 prospect was that they would retire from the contest after firing the first volley, we might then find an excuse for gathering up any and all available names just for the sake of extending the list indefinitely. But we should remember one thing; that the advocates of the Sunday-rest law have set their hearts on gaining what they seek, at all hazards. They are not only in the field to stay, but are ready, when necessary, to resort to desperate means, in order to gain the end they seek.
In all probability, the work of securing counter-petitions will be sharply criticised by the advocates of religious legislation, before the struggle ends. They will be forced to do this, as a last resort, to overthrow the opposition, which they already fear. Every lover of religious liberty should not only lay his plans to remain in the forefront to the end of the battle, but to see that the part he acts shall bear the scrutiny of his opponents, and the approval of Heaven. Now is the most favorable time we shall ever have to work in behalf of truth and righteousness. Let faithful, honest work be done—work which shall be in the widest contrast possible with that done to influence religious legislation. In the meantime let the lists of counter-petitions be swelled to the greatest possible magnitude, consistent with the foregoing suggestions.
J. O. C.