BY G. FRED STEVENS.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
(Concluded.)
I am sure all lovers of truth will follow me in what I have said. Now remember, we cannot assume the necessary attitude of mind referred to, which leads to truth. It must involve all the earnestness of which our souls are capable, and a serious preparation of the heart before God in daily, fervent prayer. In this frame of mind, let us for the present take up one argument in favor of Sunday, and see what the Bible says for or against it, remembering the “word is truth,” which the Spirit promises to enable us to see.
The argument embraces the introductory circumstance to the real or supposed change, and is perhaps the first thing to occur to us in defending the change, and that is, “that Jesus appeared to the disciples, when assembled, two successive times on the first day of the week.”
THE FIRST ASSEMBLY.
I followed the common impression, and insisted that the first assembly met on the first Sunday after our Lord’s death, for the purpose of recognizing or celebrating the resurrection. One who yearns for truth above everything else, and is ready to live or die for it, will not find it hard to subject the spirit of prejudice while looking up the matter. If we have not the readiness of mind to search the Scriptures whether these things are so (Acts 17:11), is it not plain that we have not the mind recommended to us by the Spirit of God in this text? And without it, can we be led? And when not led, what power on earth can save the human mind from prejudice?—Certainly and absolutely none. Having a sense of perfect security against prejudice or against error, is itself the most alarming condition of error imaginable, for we put ourselves where we cannot be led, a condition of thought in which we can naturally persuade ourselves that we have the truth when we have it not, although it may stare us in the face. Then humbly realizing our peril, we follow the Spirit to the word. Who composed that first assembly?—“The disciples.” John 20:19. Where did they meet?—In “their own home.” John 20:10; Acts 1:13; also 3:19 with margin. What was the assembly engaged in doing?—Sitting at meat, eating their evening meal (Mark 16:14) of broiled fish and honeycomb. Luke 24:42. When did Christ appear? We answer this by showing what happened after “the day was far spent.” Luke 24:29.
1. The day was so “far spent” that the two disciples, then at Emmaus, seven and a half miles from Jerusalem, invited the Stranger to tarry the night. Id.
2. Supper then eaten. Verse 30.
3. A journey of seven and a half miles to make back to Jerusalem. Verses 13, 33.
All this occurred before they “found the eleven gathered together.” The day must have been at its very close, if not past, by this time, and yet Christ had not yet appeared; for,—
4. The “two” occupied still further time in telling “what things were done in the way.” Luke 24:35.
5. Christ appeared and proved himself.
6. Christ stayed long enough to go over the scriptures concerning himself.
Then does it not appear that he must have been with them much longer after the close of the day than before—longer on the beginning of Monday than on the end of Sunday?
Now compare every text with every other, and it will appear that they met at their common abode as they usually did every evening, the only difference being that “the doors were shut.” And why shut in such a climate at such an hour?—“For fear of the Jews.” John 20:19.
The narrative has explained itself. But what is left to indicate that the assembly commemorated the resurrection?—Nothing; so far from it, as shown upon opening our paper, they emphatically refused to countenance any such idea as that Christ had risen. While there assembled, they never dreamed but that he still remained in the grave. The narrative on its surface is proof, but this makes double proof that the first assembly did not meet for the purpose of recognizing the resurrection.
THE SECOND ASSEMBLY.
Question 1.—Did this meet on Sunday?
We are told that “after eight days again his disciples were within” when Jesus came. John 20:26. “Of course,” says A, “that brings it exactly to Sunday, since the Jews were accustomed to counting parts of days as whole days.” This statement appears very plausible, and might be accepted without question at a glance. But B replies, “Counting even A’s Jewish way proves Sunday to have passed.” Let us try. There can be only two parts, that of the first day (Sunday) from which we count, and that of the last day: (1) Sunday (its part counted whole), (2) Monday, (3) Tuesday, (4) Wednesday, (5) Thursday, (6) Friday, (7) Saturday (ending when Sunday begins)—just one week. Then add Sunday, its part counted whole, and we have eight complete days, including all parts counted as whole days. From midnight between Saturday and Sunday to midnight between Sunday and Monday, or from Friday sunset to Saturday week sunset, will not hold a moment more than eight days. If the last moment of Sunday has gone with eight days, why, any time after that falls on the ninth day, if no later. So that “after eight days” cannot come earlier than Monday. A will not admit this because he claims that “after eight days,” is only another way of saying “eight days after.” B replies to A, “You cannot handle Inspiration as you please, and turn it around in that manner! All Christian scholars will agree that as long as the translation is correct, every word of Scripture is divinely placed, and there is a significant reason why one word occupies the place it does.” If we did not accept B’s statement, we would have the liberty of altering Scripture in many places as we chose, and with the same liberty could ignore the punctuation, arguing that there were no stops in the original, by which means we could make meanings the very opposite of those intended. One hour after ten the clock stands eleven. After one hour (from ten) the clock stands somewhere on the twelfth hour, forp. 260 the “one hour” has departed, as in the case of the “eight days” in our text, bringing us to the ninth day. According to all eminent Greek scholars, the translation is precisely correct. The words “exactly as John wrote them, using English letters in place of Greek letters, are these: ‘Kai meth’ hemeras okto;’ and are, word for word, in English, ‘And after days eight.’” Surely, then, if words mean anything, and if the “word is truth,” “after eight days” cannot bring the meeting of the second assembly earlier than Monday. So Christ appeared to them the second time not before Monday, and so the argument “that he appeared two successive times on the first day of the week,” is without fact, and contrary to the word of God. The whole matter of the two meetings, then, is forever settled.
Question 2.—What if Christ had appeared to the company on Sunday? Let us suppose it to be a fact that he did. This fact, either standing by itself or viewed from all past and subsequent appearances, would not afford even any circumstantial evidence in favor of the change; for,—
1. We have seen why the disciples were assembled at their home. They must have done so every evening.
2. The narratives strongly imply the reason why Christ met them on both occasions. Consider (a) why Christ did not meet them early in the morning, as he did the women, instead of letting all the day pass; (b) the nature of the message he sent by the women, and what he might have said if he wished his resurrection celebrated; (c) the number of proofs given all that first day that he was alive; (d) the proofs he came to give Thomas in the presence of the others a week afterward.
3. We are expressly told why he appeared. Acts 10:40, 41; 2:32; 3:15; Luke 24:48; Acts 1:3.
4. We know absolutely of but one Sunday on which he appeared; and then it was to individuals, and not to a collective assembly of the disciples.
5. We know absolutely of at least two working-days on which he appeared.
6. If the mere act of appearing to the disciples on a day constituted that day a sacred day or a Sabbath day, then working-days are more entitled to these names than Sunday.
7. We have one ordinance provided which answers sufficiently and commemorates fully Christ’s resurrection. Rom. 6:3–5; 1 Pet. 3:21.
8. Two memorials of the resurrection are not needed, and are not given.