A WARNING TO CHURCHES

4%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Apr 29, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 17.

Read the full edition

"A WARNING TO CHURCHES."

Our Methodist friends appear to be getting considerably alarmed concerning the promulgation of the doctrines held by Seventh-day Adventists. No less than two or three articles and several editorial notes have appeared in the Northwestern Christian Advocate within the last few months, warning the public against “this peculiar people,” and the purchasing and reading of their literature. The latest is “A Warning to Churches,” by Rev. J. M. Cormack, of Rockford, Ill., under date April 16, 1890. This gentleman proceeds to set forth the doctrines taught by this denomination, in the following manner:—
1. Materialism; man is only breath and body, and has no spirit in the sense that others use that word. 2. They alone understand the prophecies. 3. We are now living in the last generation, and people who saw the meteoric shower in 1833 will live to see the end of the world. 4. We are now in the judgment of 1844; the Millerites were only mistaken in the event of 1844. 5. The seventh day of the week, or Saturday, is the Christian Sabbath. 6. Keeping Sunday as the Christian Sabbath is the “mark of the beast” spoken of in Rev. 14:9–12. 7. Mrs. White is inspired as were the writers of the Bible, and therefore the Scriptures must be interpreted according to her writings. 8. The Seventh-day Adventists are now preaching the world’s last warning before the end thereof cometh, as prophesied in Rev. 14:9. 9. The dead are unconscious. 10. The wicked and the dead will be annihilated. 11. The tithing system is generally practiced among them. 12. All the churches, except the Seventh-day Adventists, are “Babylon,” as mentioned in Revelation 18. 13. At the end of the world, which is looked for daily, only 144,000 will be saved, and they will be Seventh-day Adventists.
After giving this enumeration of “doctrines,” he says: “To these might be added many more as inconsistent with the Holy Bible.”
Here, then, is the charge against Seventh-day Adventists, and the ground for “warning” the Methodist “churches” of them. Their doctrines are “inconsistent with the Holy Bible.” If this be so, it would seem strange that the denomination making the claim should continually be putting out “warnings” against this people. We should suppose that it would take the doctrines of Seventh-day Adventists, and, by comparing them with the Scriptures, show wherein they are inconsistent with the Holy Bible. But does it do this?—Not a text does Mr. Cormack quote or even refer to in over a column of comments which follows the above statements. Not one. We should like to know how Methodists or any other people are going to prove that certain doctrines are inconsistent with the Bible, and not compare them with the Bible. Herein lies their weakness. A thorough comparison of this kind would prove the charge false and the doctrines true. We have no fears of the result of such a test.
It seems, however, that in the minds of some, it is sufficient merely to state that a doctrine is held by Seventh-day Adventists, to prove it unscriptural. At least this appears to be the impression some are endeavoring to make upon the minds of the people.
But while many, doubtless, would gladly thus summarily dispose of the question, Adventism will not down in this way. As professed believers in the Bible as the authority in all matters of religious faith and practice, Methodists, with all other Protestants, are bound to bring all questions of doctrine to the Bible for settlement. If they refuse to do this, they reject the word of God as their guide, and virtually repudiate Protestantism. With Luther, we demand that our opponents show us from the Bible wherein we are wrong, before we shall acknowledge we are in error, or cease to preach our present views. These views challenge investigation, and that, too, upon Bible grounds. If they are successfully refuted, they must be refuted by the Scriptures; for they are the foundation upon which they claim to rest. If the claim is false, that must be shown.
Let us briefly examine the views above set forth by Mr. Cormack as a summary of Seventh-day Adventist doctrines:—
1. Materialism. Seventh-day Adventists believe that living, thinking, sentient beings, whether terrestrial or celestial, are beings, and not mere nothings. They believe that man was formed of the dust of the ground; that the breath of life breathed into his nostrils made him a living being; and that when he is deprived of this breath, he dies. Gen. 2:7; Ps. 146:4; James 2:26. They believe that God meant what he said when he told man if he sinned, he should surely die; and they are sorry to see so many who profess faith in God’s word believing the words of the serpent, “Ye shall not surely die.” Why Seventh-day Adventists do not believe that man has a spirit “in the sense that others use that word,” if by that is meant an undying, immortal, thinking entity outside of the body, is because they nowhere in the Bible read that he has such.
2. Seventh-day Adventists have never set up the claim that they alone understand the prophecies. On the contrary, they agree with many noted expositors upon the interpretation of numerous prophecies, and not infrequently refer to this fact. But if, in the interpretation of certain prophecies, they differ from others, and their view proves to be the correct view, how can it be otherwise than that they alone understand those prophecies?
3. Is Mr. Cormack ready to deny that we are living in the last generation? What evidence has he that we are a long way from the end of the world? We call to mind how the Saviour spoke about the evil servant at his coming saying in his heart, “My lord delayeth his coming;” and the argument of Peter’s last-day scoffers, “Where is the promise of his coming? for since the fathers fell asleep, all things continue as they were from the beginning of the creation.” Has Mr. C. better arguments than these to prove that day far distant?
4. If 1844 was not the time for the beginning of the cleansing of the sanctuary, will Mr. C. or some of his Methodist brethren explain the 2,300 days of Dan. 8:14? Upon this passage Adam Clarke remarks: “I think the prophetic day should be understood here, as in other parts of this prophet, and must signify so many years.” This is just what Seventh-day Adventists think. Now, beginning this period when the seventy weeks (which were cut off from the 2,300 days) began,—the going forth of the commandment to restore and build Jerusalem (Dan. 9:24, 25), which was in 457 B. C. (Ezra 7),—where, but in 1844 A. D., can it end? That the work of the great antitypical atonement day is a work of judgment is evident from the nature of the type itself. (See Lev. 16; 23:27–32.)
5. That the seventh day is the Sabbath, Mr. C. enumerates as another doctrine “inconsistent with the Holy Bible.” Well, this is just what the Bible says, “the seventh day is the Sabbath;” and, furthermore, it is just what the “Catechism of the Methodist Episcopal Church,” No. 2, page 39, teaches. As to there being Bible support for another day as sabbath, the M. E. “Theological Compendium,” p. 103, ed. 1865, says: “It is true, there is no positive command for infant baptism, . . . nor is there any for keeping holy the first day of the week.”
6. The power represented by the two-horned beast of Rev. 14:11–18 is not only to make an “image” to the papal beast (verses 1–10), but is to enforce upon all under its jurisdiction “a mark.” Will our Methodist friends tell us what this beast, this image, and this mark is? or has this vision of the apostle John become unto them “as the words of a book that is sealed, which men deliver to one that is learned, saying, Read this, I pray thee; and he saith, I cannot; for it is sealed,” notwithstanding the apostle was instructed to “seal not the sayings of the prophecy of this book”? Seventh-day Adventists are persuaded that the United States Government meets in every particular the specifications of the beast of Rev. 14:11; that the religious-political movement now springing up throughout the country, saying to the people that they should establish Christianity as the religion of this nation, will result in nothing less than a union of Church and State,—a perfect “image to the beast;” and, lastly, that Sunday-keeping, which the American Sabbath Union (the initiatory steps in the organization of which were taken by the Methodist Church), together with other like organizations, is endeavoring to enforce “by fear of law” upon all, irrespective of their belief or unbelief, and by boycotts and Sunday laws prohibit any man from buying or selling save he that keeps this day, answers only too truly to the mark of Rev. 13:16, 17.
7. The remnant of the Christian Church are to “keep the commandments of God, and have the testimony of Jesus.” Rev. 12:17. According to chap. 19:10, the testimony of Jesus is declared to be “the spirit of prophecy.” If the Methodist Church have these characteristics, if they keep the commandments of God and have the spirit of prophecy, then they are the people referred to as the remnant of the woman’s seed with whom the dragon becomes wroth. If, on the other hand, they openly violate any of God’s commandments, despise prophesying, and reject the gifts of the Spirit which God has set in the Church, one of which is “prophets,” then we fear they are not. Seventh-day Adventists are thankful for the help, the encouragement, and the instruction God has seen fit to give them through “the spirit of prophecy.”
8. Some people are going to preach the world’s last warning, if such a warning is ever preached. And, from all accounts, Seventh-day Adventists appear to be about the only people who pretend to be giving the message of the third angel of Revelation 14, or profess to explain the mark, or to be warning the world against receiving it.
9. The Bible says, “The dead know not anything,” and that when man’s breath goeth forth, and he returneth to his earth, “in that very day his thoughts perish.” Eccl. 9:5; Ps. 146:4. If these texts do not prove that the dead are unconscious, then language could not be framed to state the fact.
10. As to the destruction of the wicked, the Scriptures teach that they shall “perish,” be “destroyed,” “burned up” so there shall be left “neither root nor branch;” that they shall “be ashes,” and “into smoke shall they consume away;” and that in a little while they “shall not be.” Mal. 4:1, 3; Ps. 37:10, 20, 38. Of the destruction of the Devil, God says, “I will bring thee to ashes upon the earth in the sight of all them that behold thee, . . . and never shalt thou be any more.” Eze. 28:18, 19. Our Methodist friends may term this annihilation, or what they choose, it is simply what the Bible says.
11. What is the matter with the tithing system? We have frequently noticed from remarks by ministers of other denominations, that they would be very glad if they could get their congregations to practice this system. We know a Presbyterian minister who faithfully pays a tithe of his income, and have heard him uphold the doctrine before his congregation. T. De Witt Talmage says, “God gives us ninety cents out of every dollar. The other ten cents, by command of his Bible, belong to him.” But it seems that when Seventh-day Adventists adopt this Bible system, and put it into actual practice, then, suddenly, it becomes “inconsistent with the Holy Bible”! What the motives can be which actuate such criticisms, whether envy, animosity, or honest convictions, we will not say.
12. Nearly all Protestants are agreed that “Babylon the Great, the Mother of Harlots” is the Romish Church. But, as that acute Methodist preacher, Lorenzo Dow, said, “If she be the mother, who are the daughters? It must be the corrupt, national, established churches that came out of her.” The fact that the professed Protestant churches are, as a body, clamoring for the establishment of religion by law in this country, shows that they are following in the wake of this “mother of harlots,” and are proving themselves to be nothing less than her legitimate daughters. The family resemblance is becoming well marked. This is not saying that there are not honest, sincere Christians in all of these churches, even in the Church of Rome itself.
13. Lastly, Mr. Cormack says, “At the end of the world, which is looked for daily, only 144,000 will be saved, and they will be Seventh-day Adventists.” This, he claims, is another Seventh-day Adventist doctrine. The statement reminds us of the naturalist who had written a brief description of various living creatures, and submitted it to a friend for criticism. His definition of the crab was as follows: “The crab is a small red fish that walks backwards;” upon which his friend remarked, “Your definition is correct with the exception of three particulars; first, the crab is not a fish; second, it isn’t red; and third, it doesn’t walk backwards.” Near the close of his article Mr. C. says Seventh-day Adventists “claim to number about 30,000.” Now, how it is that Seventh-day Adventists believe that at the end there are to be 144,000 saved, and they all Seventh-day Adventists, and yet are looking for the end of the world “daily,” as is twice stated in the article, while as yet they claim to number only 30,000, is not exactly clear. There is a deficiency here of about 114,000, which Mr. C. seems to have overlooked. His statements do not hold together.
We wonder where he got his information. He speaks of having examined a work by one who has written “a complete renunciation of the Seventh-day Adventists.” We presume it was this work upon which he largely relied for his information, which doubtless accounts for his superficial knowledge of this people, and some of the false statements he makes concerning them, such as, “Persons joining them are quickly compelled to accept her [Mrs. White’s] visions.” We remember once after going to a Catholic priest to buy a Catholic catechism, and to ask some questions concerning certain points of Catholic faith, of receiving the commendation of the priest for going to Catholics to learn what Catholics believe. Said he, “If I wished to learn what Seventh-day Adventists believe, I should go to Seventh-day Adventists.” We would recommend this plan to Mr. C., his Methodist friends, and all others. While Seventh-day Adventists are not expecting the end of the world daily, because they see prophecies not yet entirely fulfilled, they do believe that the signs of the time show unmistakably that that event is not far off. While they believe that “as the days of Noah were, so shall also the coming of the Son of man be,”—but few of the generation living will be prepared for his coming; yet, they believe that when he comes, he will send forth his angels to raise the good and blessed of all ages from their dusty beds, and they, with those “which are alive and remain, shall be caught up together with them in the clouds, to meet the Lord in the air,” “a great multitude, which no man could number.” 1 Thess. 4:16, 17; Rev. 7:9.
Mr. C. brings a very serious charge against Seventh-day Adventists by saying: “If their doctrines are made public before they wish to expose them, they are accustomed either to deny them in an indefinite manner or, at least, to infer that they have been misrepresented.” For them to deny belief in their own doctrines would be nothing more nor less than for them to falsify. But that they do this Mr. C. himself refutes, for further along he says, “The members of the Seventh-day Adventists, who claim to number 30,000, are moral, sincere, honest people.” They cannot be honest if they dissemble, equivocate, or falsify in any way. As to the truthfulness of the latter phase of the charge, their claim of being misrepresented, Mr. C. himself affords ample proof.
Before closing, Mr. C. remarks that after reading carefully and digesting thoroughly a work called “Seventh-day Adventism Renounced,” “none but a fool would join this sect.” We have seen those who, after reading Thomas Paine’s “Age of Reason” and Ingersoll’s “Mistakes of Moses,” refused to believe in the Bible. We have heard of Eve, who believed the words of the serpent instead of the words of God. But the Bible still stands, and God’s words are true. “Seventh-day Adventism Renounced” no more refutes Seventh-day Adventism than the “Age of Reason” and the “Mistakes of Moses” upset the Bible, or the Devil’s great lie keeps men from dying. If men prefer to learn what the Bible teaches through men who have renounced it, we cannot help it. They are responsible for their own course. Likewise, if for their chief information in regard to Adventism they choose to rely upon the works of its enemies, they must bear the responsibility if they are deceived and made bodies of darkness instead of channels of light.
W. A. C.