THE FATE OF THE WICKED

10%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Oct 21, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 41.

Read the full edition

THE FATE OF THE WICKED.

[EXTRACT from a letter to a Universalist minister, in reply to one received from him regarding the coming of Christ, the fate of the wicked, the Bible, etc., by Mrs. M. D. Counselman, Baltimore, Md. On account of the length of this communication, we take the liberty to omit a portion relating to personal experience, which, though it would be of interest to those personally acquainted with the writer, would not be of such benefit to the general reader as the examination of the scriptures relative to the question in hand.—Ed.]
Yours of the 14th came duly to hand. You should not fear that anything you wrote would offend me. I do not know as it took any special “grace” to overlook anything. I know you are too tender-hearted, too genuinely good, to intentionally wound or distress, and besides, the truth never can be disturbed by anything that may be said. And while I may grieve over the fact that those whom I care much for (who are my friends) have so far wandered away as to rely more on their own intellects than on the Bible, still that does not offend me, nor cause my faith to be any the less; indeed, it rather strengthens it, and calls to mind the Scripture references as to the condition of the world at this time, and the prophecies of God’s servants as to what would be in the last days. So when I see the pastors referred to in Jeremiah, “misleading my [His] flocks,” or “scattering,” as it is rendered (see chap. 23 entire; also chap. 17:5), and many “leaving the faith because of false teachers and false doctrines,”—while it may grieve me and distress me, it only proves to me that the Bible is true, and the word of God.
I cannot tell you how pained I was to read that you are “no stickler for the infallibility of the Bible”! What can we depend upon for light and comfort if these be not found in that book which is here as God’s word? What right has mortal man to sit in judgment upon a book that, for some reason, is here in the capacity of God’s word? I really think it is because we do not know how to compare scripture with scripture to find how it really harmonizes. Isolated passages, when taken alone, may seem to be unreasonable, but when taken with others, the meaning is clear. Without the Old Testament we have no proof that Christ was the Messiah, and I think one book explains the other. The lives of men in olden times were recorded for an example in some cases, and a warning in others. Those who were professed children of God, and who in moments of weakness fell, call to mind the words of Paul: “Let him that thinketh he standeth take heed lest he fall.” 1 Cor. 10:12. I hope you will pardon me if I suggest anything that may seem presumptuous on my part; but if you have not read “The Philosophy of the Plan of Salvation,” the Chautauqua edition, I beg of you to read it. It is very clear relative to the manner of God’s dealing with the people of the Old Testament. As to the Bible question, you know what the old philosophers, Cicero and Socrates, thought and said of “philosophy”; and all philosophy crumbles before the Bible. Especially is this true concerning the question of the immortality of the soul. Socrates, just before drinking the deadly hemlock, said, “I am going out of the world, and you are to remain in it, but which of us has the better part is a secret to every one but God.” Stuart’s Exegetical Essays on “Several Words Relating to Future Punishment,” pp. 13, 14, says: “Cicero, incomparably the most able defender of the soul’s immortality of which the heathen world can yet boast, very ingenuously confesses that after all his arguments in favor of the doctrine, his mind was only satisfied of it when directly arguing or contemplating his views. At other times he was in profoundest darkness. If there be any satisfactory light then, on the momentous question of a future state, it must be sought from the word of God!” Dobney’s “Future Punishment” says, “Reason cannot prove man to be immortal.” Seneca, reviewing the arguments of the ancients on this subject, says, “Immortality, however desirable, was rather promised than proved, by these great men.” “Logicians tell us that there is an antecedent probability in favor of a divine revelation, arising from the nature of the Deity, and the moral condition of man. On the same ground, then, there must be an equal probability that, if we are immortal, never-dying beings, revelation will plainly tell us so. To the Bible alone we look for correct views of the character of God, the nature of life and death, the resurrection, heaven and hell.” “Prominent upon the pages of inspiration we see pointed out the great distinction which God has put between right and wrong, the rewards he has promised to virtue, and the punishment threatened against sin. The questions, ‘Are all men immortal?’ ‘Are the wicked immortal, and will they be punished?’ are of such weight and importance, that the word of God will not leave us in doubt or perplexity, or deceive us with falsehood.”
Passion or prejudice cannot understand clearly, and the enemy of man seeks to lead men away from the Bible, because it is the word of God, and they will know how to escape a fearful doom if they read and believe it! As to the “enemy,” who you do not believe exists, I could tell you an experience I had by which I know there is not only a Devil, but many. You say you believe the New Testament. Did not Jesus cast out devils, and tell his followers they should cast them out in his name? You accuse me of having views “saturated with materialism.” Let me ask you a plain question: Do you want your hopes of a future to rest upon thin air, something intangible? I do not want mine thus to rest. I want to be so sure of the future as I read it in God’s revelation, that I may know what awaits me. God is real, his word is real, heaven and eternity are real, death and the destruction of the wicked are real, the coming of Christ (according to the New Testament and Christ’s own words) is to be very real, so thoroughly “material” that men will call on the rocks and mountains to “hide them from the face of him that sitteth on the throne, and from the wrath of the Lamb; for the great day of his wrath is come, and who shall be able to stand?” Rev. 6:16, 17. Christ himself promised to come again, as it is written in John 14:1–3: “I will come again, and receive you unto myself,” etc. If you believe the New Testament, how can you reconcile these references with your expressed views? Christ’s manner of coming is found in Acts 1:9–11. What first takes place on the earth at his coming, is found in 1 Thess. 4:16, 17. What happens to the wicked, is found in 2 Thess. 1:7–9; also Jer. 25:33. Will the Lord come unawares? (See 1 Thess. 5:1–3.) Will he come on all unawares? (See verse 4.) The “signs” preceding his coming, of which he told his disciples, have all come to pass. According to his own words, “When ye shall see all these things, know that it is near, even at the doors.” “But of that day and hour knoweth no man, no, not the angels,” etc. Jesus gave the parable of the fig-tree to show the position of those who would live at the time of his coming. He assures us that “heaven and earth shall pass away, but his words shall not.” For proof that the generation then living was not meant, see Luke 11:29. They were not to have these signs. Paul says that we that “remain” shall be “changed.” Paul did not expect to be on the earth at Christ’s coming (see 2 Thess. 2:1–4); but we who are in Christ, who are of the generation that see the signs, “shall all be changed, in a moment, in the twinkling of an eye.” Will some be looking for him? (See Heb. 9:28; Isa. 25:9.) The Lord promises a blessing on those who look for him. (See Luke 12:37.) Luke 21:34–36, tells us what Jesus exhorts us to do at this time; and Titus 2:11–13, tells us how those who look for this grand event should live. I cannot see how any one believing the words herein found, can disbelieve Christ’s coming. Your description of the faith you represent regarding the resurrection, was intensely interesting, and caused me to search earnestly the word of God, to see if it was recorded there as you have it. I find (and you will pardon me for referring to the Old Testament) in Gen. 2:17; 3:4, that two positive declarations were made to man when he was first placed on probation. I ask, Which of these two is most generally believed at the present time? Job speaks by inspiration of God, in very plain terms concerning this. (See chap. 14:10–12.) Paul speaks of this penalty for sin in Rom. 5:12. Has man any knowledge in death? (See Eccl. 9:5, 6, 10.) Compare the death of man with that of a beast. Eccl. 3:19, 20. (For explanation of next verse, see translation of the word “spirit.” As you know, it is translated from two Hebrew words, “n’ shah-mah” and “roo-agh,” meaning breath, wind, blast, soul, air, mind, etc. (See references.) “Spirit,” in the New Testament, comes from the Greek word “pneuma,” which occurs 385 times, and is rendered ghost, spirit, wind, and life.) When will the heavens be no more? Rev. 6:14. If Christ had not died and arisen again, man would never have had a resurrection. 1 Cor. 15:17. What two things have been brought to light through the gospel? 2 Tim. 1:10. How many will have life through Christ? 1 Cor. 15:22. How many will have eternal life, or immortality, through Christ? Rom. 2:6, 7. Notice it says “those who seek.” The Saviour referred to the fact that men will have life, and may have eternal life. John 10:10. See what some of the prophetic declarations are concerning the resurrection: Isa. 26:19; Eze. 37:12, 13; Hosea 13:14; Job 19:25, 27. How long did death reign supreme? Rom. 5:14. Who brought death into the world, and holds man beneath its power? Heb. 2:14.
Did Satan willingly release one of his captives? Jude 9. When and how was the reign of death still further broken? Matt. 27:51–53. Why was it necessary that many bodies of saints should come out of their graves when Christ arose? Rom. 8:29, 30. Were they glorified and taken to heaven when Christ ascended? See Eph. 4:8 (margin). “The reign of death will be still further broken just before the second coming of Christ, by some of both wicked and righteous being raised to witness his coming” (Dan. 12:2), thus fulfilling Rev. 1:7. Will there be two resurrections? John 5:28; Acts 24:15. At which one of these resurrections will the righteous receive their reward? Luke 14:14. Which resurrection takes place first? Rev. 20:6. How long a time will intervene between the two resurrections? Rev. 20:5. What other event besides the resurrection of the righteous takes place at the beginning of this thousand years? Rev. 20:1–3. Where will the saints be during the thousand years? Rev. 20:4. What will be the condition of the earth? Isa. 13:9; 24:1, 3, 19. How does the prophet Jeremiah describe the earth during this time? Jer. 4:20, 23–27. (Notice especially verse 23.) When was similar language used in describing the condition of the earth? Gen. 1:1, 2. Where is Satan to be cast when he is bound? Rev. 20:3. “The phrase ‘bottomless pit,’ where Satan is to be cast, and ‘face of the deep’ (Gen. 1:2), are taken from words in the original bearing the same definition, showing that the prison-house of Satan during the 1,000 years will be this earth reduced back to its chaotic state.” What has been Satan’s position and work since his fall? Job 1:6, 7; 1 Pet. 5:8. “Since Satan’s work has ever been to tempt and destroy souls, when all (both righteous and wicked) are placed beyond his power, he will be effectually bound during the 1,000 years, the saints being all in heaven, the wicked not raised, and the earth in a desolate condition.” When will Satan be loosed again? Rev. 20:7. How will he be loosed? Verse 5. How long a time will he be loosed? Verse 3. Against what will the wicked gather together to battle? Rev. 20:9. When, deceived by Satan, the countless millions of the wicked who have been raised from the dead come up around the city, what will take place?—Id. How does Nahum describe this scene? Chap. 1:9, 10. How is it referred to in other scriptures? See 2 Pet. 3:7; Mal. 4:1; Obad. 16. What scripture can then, and only then, be fulfilled? Rev. 5:13. How long have those the promise of living who are counted worthy of the first resurrection? Luke 20:35, 36. In looking up the question of the fate of the wicked, I find some very important testimony in the New Testament, which must be of value to you if you believe that book to be “substantially correct;” and if the wicked are going to be saved anyhow, somehow, the Bible does not say so. The question may be asked, Are the wicked now being punished? (See 2 Pet. 2:9; Job 21:28, 30.) Where are they reserved? Job 21:26, 32, 33. What question is asked in the Bible with reference to the wicked? 1 Pet. 4:17. What is the penalty of sin? Rom. 6:23; James 1:15. “Die,” according to Webster, means “to cease to live,” to “expire,” to “perish.” What death is the penalty of sin? Rev. 20:6. Did God design that man should die the second death? Heb. 9:27. By what means are they to be put to death? Matt. 13:40–42. If God did not design that men should die the second death, for whom was this fire originally prepared? Matt. 25:41. Where is this lake of fire located? Rev. 20:9. Does the Scripture say the earth is reserved for this very purpose? 2 Pet. 3:7. When will the wicked be recompensed? Prov. 11:31. How does Isaiah speak of that day? Isa. 34:8, 9. Will all the wicked be punished at the same time? Isa. 1:28, 31. Who will awake them to receive their punishment? John 5:28, 29. When will he awake the righteous? 1 Thess. 4:16. How long after this will he awake the wicked? Rev. 20:5. When the wicked dead are raised, to what does Satan gather them? Verse 8. What do they try to take in this great battle?—“The beloved city.” How does the battle result? Verse 9. How does this fire affect the wicked? Mal. 4:1, 3. How does the prophet Nahum describe the scene? Nah. 1:1–10. Will the soul of the sinner die? Eze. 18:4. Will the wicked ever recover from their punishment? 2 Thess. 1:9; Isa. 10:18. What, then, may be said of it? Matt. 25:46. Who only will have eternal life? Rom. 2:7. Then will the wicked live forever in hell-fire—will their place of punishment always exist? Ps. 37:10. To what condition are the wicked brought? Obad. 16. To what will the molten earth give place? 2 Pet. 3:12, 13. Who will dwell therein? Matt. 5:5. Where are the wicked at this time? Mal. 4:3. Will Satan share the same fate? Heb. 2:14; Eze. 28:18, 19. What universal song will then be sung? Rev. 5:13.
As to the subject of “eternal or unquenchable fire,” Sodom and Gomorrah were examples; and as they were “turned into ashes,” the fire has long since ceased to burn. When all there is to burn has been consumed, there will be no longer anything to burn; but while there is food for flame, the fire will be unquenchable. “Forever and forever”—now what is said about the smoke of the torment of certain wicked persons? Rev. 14:11. In the old dispensation, if a servant refused to leave his master and go free, at the beginning of the seventh year, what ceremony was performed? Ex. 21:2–6. How long was he thus to serve? Verse 6, last clause. Does this mean that in such a case he should never die?—Most certainly not. What, then, do we understand by the expression, “He shall serve him forever.” We understand that he was to serve him continuously, as long as he lived. No other meaning can be derived from the text. Then what do we understand from the saying, “The smoke of their torment ascendeth up forever and ever?”—That it ascends continuously as long as there is anything in existence to cause it to ascend.
May God bless you and me, and all who seek to do his will. I sincerely ask God’s guidance for all who really desire to know and do his will, rather than follow the traditions of men and popular custom, as their guide and pattern. I trust there will be many yet in the churches who will prove their loyalty to the Bible (for it speaks for itself), and will have the courage to defend its teachings; for “faith without works is dead.”
In conclusion, I think one reason why so many wander away from the Bible as God’s word, is due to the fact that because their reason cannot grasp some things therein, they at once cast it off. They forget that faith should be first, and reason afterward. God’s ways are not to be explained by natural laws, or to be comprehended by our finite minds; and why should poor, frail man place his intellect above the words of Jehovah? I was pained most deeply at some portions of your letter, and, while greatly interested, I could not fail to note the “graceful subtleties” you express, indicate a poise of mental balance that is worthy a better cause. I know the two classes of your faith. One is impelled by selfishness to evade responsibility (personally) as to the result of sin and its “wages”; the other with noble philanthropy desires to see all attain happiness hereafter, despite their failings and weaknesses, and yet all this in the face of their denial of Christ and his salvation! Those of your nature cannot allow themselves to see the ultimate to which their postulates must eventually lead them. It is said that it is such minds “the enemy of mankind seeks for his choicest prey, and to whom he presents himself ‘all appareled in celestial light.’” Universalism is one of his dearest deceptions, where he shines brightest and best,—Lucifer, son of the morning. He would, indeed, that none should be lost, and he himself be saved among the rest! But that overruling spirit that first wrought his fall is seen even now in this delusion with which he would fill the minds of men. He would be merciful, while the Lord of the Bible, he would have us think, is only sternly just. Satan is, therefore, God, and God Satan—the conclusion also of Spiritualism. In fact, that is the end, and the intended end, to the course of reasoning in almost every system of religious error, and proves whence they all have their source and who is their author.”
Dear friend, I hope you will have the “grace” to take this, my letter, as I intend it. You meant only to prove the error of my views; I mean only to prove to you from the Bible, the falsity of yours. Of course, one must be governed by the convictions of his conscience, if desiring the real truth, however unsavory. And I really think that if every one believed the Bible and was true to his private convictions, aside from popular theories of men, there would be vastly many more who would be fortunate enough to have part in the first resurrection, and over whom “the second death” would have “no power.” Rev. 20:6. May God help us all to be of that happy throng.