AdventAI

A MODERN INVENTION.

By Roswell F. Cottrell

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 37., September 23, 1890

BY ELD. R. F. COTTRELL.

(Ridgeway, N. Y.)

It is written, “God hath made man upright; but they have sought out many inventions.” One of these inventions of modern date is thus expressed:—

The change of the day is not a change of the decalogue. The fourth commandment bids us keep “the seventh day” after six days of work, not the seventh day of thep. 578 week. The commandment is obeyed just as truly by those who observe Sunday as by those who observe Saturday.

Facts will show that this is a silly evasion of the truth, and that such a thing was never thought of 500 years ago.

1. God gave as the reason why he requires men to keep the seventh day, that “in it he had rested from all his work,” the work of creation. Did he not labor on six days of the week, and rest on the seventh day?—He did; and it is useless to deny it. Then the seventh day of the week, and not any one day in seven, is the Sabbath.

2. It is a fact that the Jews to this day observe the Sabbath because God rested from his work on that day; and it is a fact that the whole Christian world are in harmony with them in numbering the days of the week.

3. It is a fact that the Sabbath throughout the New Testament is invariably the seventh day of the week: and that it is explicitly distinguished therein from the first day of the week, the day of the resurrection of Christ. Mark 16: 1, 2; Luke 23: 56; 24: 1.

4. It is a fact that when the first day began to be observed in the church in honor of Christ’s resurrection, the seventh day was still kept by them as the Sabbath.

5. It is a fact that for many hundreds of years after Christ, the title of Sabbath was invariably given to the seventh day, Saturday, and never to Sunday. Says Heylyn, “Whenever for a thousand years and upward, we meet with Sabbatum in any writer of what name soever, it is to be understood of no other day but Saturday.”

6. It is a fact that for more than a thousand years of the Christian era no one ever claimed that Sunday was kept in obedience to the fourth commandment. The Sabbath and Sunday (which had assumed the title of Lord’s day) were regarded as two distinct days, and were for centuries held in antagonism and rivalry; and the result was that it came to be understood that the observance of Sunday had been “substituted” for the observance of the Sabbath. Sunday was not kept as the Sabbath, but “instead of the Sabbath.” Of the times after the beginning of the third century, Dr. Charles Hase, of Germany, says, “The Roman Church regarded Saturday as a fast-day in direct opposition to those who regard it as a Sabbath. . . . But the original commandment of the decalogue was not then applied to that day.”

7. It is a fact that it was left for Protestants to invent the theory that the keeping of the first day of the week is obedience to that commandment which requires the keeping of the seventh. The first trace of this remarkable discovery is found in history about the year 1595. About this time Nicholas Bound, D. D., an English dissenter, published a book in which he advocated the transfer of the Sabbath to Sunday on the ground of the theory that the seventh part of time devoted to God answers the requirement of the commandment.

“Necessity is the mother of invention.” The necessity which forced this invention was brought about as follows: In the latter part of the sixteenth century, the Presbyterians and Episcopalians of England were engaged in a controversy concerning the authority for the observance of Sunday and the other festivals of the church. “The Episcopalians required men to observe all the festivals of the church; the Presbyterians observed Sunday and rejected all the rest. The Episcopalians showed the inconsistency of this discrimination, inasmuch as the same church authority had ordained them all. As the Presbyterians rejected the authority of the church, they would not keep Sunday upon that ground, especially as it would involve the observance of all the other festivals.” They were thus driven to the necessity of giving up Sunday entirely, or proving its claim from the Bible. Hence the attempt to enforce Sunday-keeping by the fourth commandment.

But it is a fact that the records of the New Testament and those of every civilized nation of the world, are all against the idea that Sunday is the seventh day of the commandment. Yet learned men will contend for this absurd position in the face of all records and all history, to sustain them in the practice of following a tradition which makes void the commandment of God. How weak, as well as wicked, it is to suppose that by this sort of legerdemain they can circumvent the omniscient Jehovah. They may succeed in deceiving themselves, and be like the idolater whom the prophet describes as follows: “He feedeth on ashes: a deceived heart hath turned him aside, that he cannot deliver his soul, nor say, Is there not a lie in my right hand?” Isa. 44:20. But the day will come when they will be undeceived, and will see the enormity of the sin of perverting the words of the Most High. May it be before it is too late to repent and find pardon.