BY J. M. STONEMAN.
The Northwestern Christian Advocate, one of the leading organs of the Methodist Church, took particular pains a few weeks ago to warn its readers against the S. D. Adventist people, on account of their methods of doing business, their doctrine, teaching, etc., and in doing so used harsh and unwarrantable language, or, at least, called attention to articles in the papers, using this language, and advised its readers to read and heed.
One of the statements made against the Adventists was, that they were materialists; and this fact was stated as though it was a heinous crime to believe that the Bible means what it says when it declares in Genesis, “For dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return;” and in Ecclesiastes, “The dead know not anything;” and in the language of Job, “All the days of my appointed time will I wait, till my change come;” and in the psalms of David, “I shall be satisfied, when I awake, with thy likeness;” and again, in Job, “His sons come to honor, and he knoweth it not; and they are brought low, but he perceiveth it not of them;” and many more texts showing that “there is no work, nor device, nor knowledge, nor wisdom, in the grave whither thou goest.” Of course, believing these things puts a quietus to the commonly accepted theories of the state of the dead between death and the resurrection, the natural immortality of the soul and eternal punishment; but we notice that the S. D. A. doctrine, or, rather, Bible doctrine, can be used skillfully by our Methodist friends when Adventists are not in sight.
In the Pacific Christian Advocate (Methodist) of July 2, in refuting the claims of the Christian Scientists, Rev. W. B. McMillin made some statements to which I would call attention. I make but few comments, as it is unnecessary.
He says in regard to personality, “It is because you can see, feel, think, and reason; this is what makes your personality and makes the world feel your power.” It requires organs and organization to enable man to do the foregoing acts. “But what do the Scriptures teach regarding God; yea, what does God declare concerning himself?” “I read in the very first chapter [of the Bible] that God said, ‘Let us make man in our image, after our likeness.’ Here I discover that God has the power of speech.” He therefore has the organs of speech. “Again I read, ‘And the Lord formed man of the ground, and breathed into his nostrils the breath of life; and man became a living soul.’ Here we see that God is represented as possessing vitality, life. He breathes, and imparts the breath of life to man.” He has mouth, nose, etc. “I read, ‘I have surely seen the affliction of my people, and have heard their cry by reason of their task-masters.’ ‘And the Lord said, I have heard thy prayer and thy supplications that thou hast made before me.’ Thus we see that God represents himself as possessing the powers of sight and hearing.” He has eyes and ears. And many other Scripture texts are quoted to show that God possesses all that goes to make up individuality or personality. “But what of the affections and reasoning powers? For if God possesses personality, he must possess these attributes, for they belong to persons. I read in Judges 10:16, ‘His soul was grieved for the misery of Israel.’” “And in the first chapter of Isaiah, ‘Come, let us reason together, saith the Lord.’ Thus we see that God has every attribute that goes to make up personality.” And consequently is a person, a tangible being. “It is not necessary to believe that he has a body of flesh and blood in order that he may possess these powers. We believe, as the Scriptures declare, that God is a Spirit, and, as a spirit, he has a spiritual body in which adhere all these spiritual attributes just as truly and really as they adhere in our natural bodies.” So do we; we also believe his next quotation from Paul—“There is a natural body and there is a spiritual body.” But we emphatically deny that the Bible teaches there is a spiritual body within our natural body, co-existing yet separate from it; and also that we shall have a spiritual body until our corruptible bodies are changed into incorruptible, or spiritual bodies.
Mr. McMillin further goes on to show that Christ, angels, and Satan and his devils are personal beings, in which, I am sure, he is in accord with the Bible and in harmony with S. D. Adventists.
In conclusion, I should like to ask my friends of the Northwestern Christian Advocate, if this is Methodism, that God is a person, and Christ, angels, and devils are persons, and have all the attributes of persons,—nose, ears, eyes, mouth, hands, etc.,—are they not organized beings that consist of something? If this is so,—and it is unless the Bible and the Pacific Advocate are false,—I should like to have explained why you feel so bitterly toward the materialism of the Adventists.
Again, if there is a natural body and a spiritual body, and all persons must have one or the other, and the spiritual body goes to heaven before the resurrection, and the flesh and blood, or earthly body, cannot go to heaven, what, in the name of truth and reason, is it resurrected for? or does God have it resurrected and changed so that man may have two spiritual bodies in case of an emergency? (Pardon the seeming irreverence, but the absurdity is too much for my weak mind.) Again, if to be a person we must have the attributes of a person, it is essential to have a body; for it is the different members of the body that perform the different acts and go to make up one's personality. Paul, in 1 Cor. 15:44, in speaking of the resurrection of the body, says, “It is sown a natural body; it is raised a spiritual body.” If it is sown at death a natural body, and raised at the resurrection a spiritual body, what personality does the individual have between these two events without any body, which must be the case if the real, intelligent man goes to paradise, or heaven, at death? Or perhaps he exists as a Christian Scientist's principle during the interim. If my friends can rectify these anomalies, I shall be more than pleased to be instructed.