CHRISTIANITY IN RELATION TO THE CONSTITUTION OF THE UNITED STATES.
[S. A. WHITCOMB, in the Universalist Quarterly, Boston, October, 1890, takes the following sound and logical view of the National Reform movement. Such utterances are worthy of being carefully noted, as we shall have occasion to use them hereafter:—] It is proposed, as it has been at various times, to amend the great instrument which defines the rights, powers, and duties of the citizens of this land, by inserting in the preamble a clause “acknowledging Almighty God as the source of all authority and power in civil government, the Lord Jesus Christ as the ruler among nations, and his revealed will as of supreme authority.” It is frequently assumed that clergymen and other citizens whose spirit and studies dispose them to seek, in every practicable way, the welfare of their countrymen, will indorse the above-mentioned propositions, and unqualifiedly commend the course of those who advocate such views. It seems to us, however, that many capable, true, and earnest men cannot, for the following and other reasons which we have not space to present in detail, conscientiously uphold them. 1. The proposition rests upon an erroneous idea of the relation of man as a worshiper, to man as a subject of civil government. Government is established for secular ends, not for spiritual ones. Some persons think that such a statement is equivalent to saying, that secular affairs are more important than spiritual things. Such a notion involves a great mistake. The objects of civil government are those in which every man, whether Jew or pagan, Christian or infidel, papist or Protestant, deist or atheist, has an interest. Government was not established to teach any portion of any religion, nor to do any other work that can be better done by individuals. 2. Again, the proposal of those who would amend the great law of the land, does not make proper allowance for the peculiar composition of society in the United States. It is urged that the offered amendment ought to be adopted, because many of our foreign-born citizens act badly with regard to religious affairs. They indulge in carousals on Sunday, in drinking excesses and noisy parades, and they ought to be checked. This is right doctrine, but a wrong application of it. Must we not distinguish carefully between a natural, a civil, a political, and a moral or a religious right? All men have certain natural rights or liberty. But when human beings attempt to live together, they find it necessary to give up or abridge certain natural rights, to modify or qualify the use of them, in order to secure the benefits of association; hence arises a new class of rights; viz., civil. The essence of civil or political fairness consists in making arrangements which will, as far as practicable, give all equal advantages. 3. Moreover, to amend the Constitution as proposed, would work injustice to many citizens. The advocates of the amendment put forth the following declaration of articles: 1. “All civil government owes all its authority to God. 2. The Lord Jesus Christ is the ruler among nations. 3. His revealed will, the Bible, is of supreme authority in a Christian government.” There is a sense in which some of these statements are true, but not in the sense meant by those who make them. None of these articles takes into account the fact that the great charter of American liberty belongs to Jew and Christian and infidel alike. Each of these articles contradicts the spirit of the nation, as expressed in the Constitution. 4. To amend the Constitution as proposed, would establish a troublesome precedent. The Constitution is founded, say the agitators, on the law of England, and Blackstone declares that Christianity is a part of it, and this declaration has been sanctioned by decisions of court. Now, if Christianity is thus a part of the great law of our land, where is the sense or fairness of the amendment-makers in saying that it is destitute of a Christian character? That portion of the United States Constitution which, in a sense, may charitably be said to be founded on the law of Albion, was not so founded with a view to asserting or maintaining any portion of Christianity. That purpose was expressly disavowed. 5. The proposed amendment would violate both the letter and the spirit of the Constitution. Article 6, Sec. 3, of that document, declares that no religious test shall ever be required as a qualification to any office or public trust under the United States. The promoters of the proposed amendment may not intend to labor for the union of Church and State, but the tendency of their efforts is in that direction. Besides, the right to put one article of faith into the supreme law of the land implies the right to put in another; and having made such a hole in the great dyke which holds back the sea dashing against popular liberty, how are men to prevent a steady enlargement of peril. 6. Again, the policy recommended to our legislators would defeat itself. It would provoke hostility. The amendment people say, “No, for such a clause is in the respective constitutions of several States; trust the American people.” We are behind no one in our trust of them; but the fact is patent that such clauses do provoke hostility. The sure way to exasperate a man is to tell him that he must be good. The sure way to make a person who does not believe in our Saviour hostile to him, would be to post a notice to the contrary in the Constitution, and say that such a person will be compelled to acknowledge Jesus. The proposed arrangement will not make unbelievers pious, but will produce a plentiful crop of hypocrites, and incense a great body of useful citizens. 7. Lastly, this project of amending the Constitution, with reference to the recognition of Christ as the head of this Government, is opposed to the teachings of the Bible. Our Saviour expressly said to Pilate, “My kingdom is not of this world.” From that day to this the Saviour has refused to proclaim himself as the political head of any government.