The Scripture says to the wicked, “Why will ye die?” But when we come in contact with a certain class of opponents of the Sabbath, we have to change that declaration by one letter, and ask, “Why will ye lie?”
Thus, the Free Methodist, endeavoring to make Acts 20 : 7 uphold Sunday-keeping, says: “The Seventh-day Adventists, in endeavoring to break the force of this passage, claim that the meeting was a special one, called on purpose to hear Paul, and that it was not held on the first day of the week at all, but in the evening either preceding or following it. On such perversions do many pin their faith.”
Passing by for a moment the so-called “perversion,” we wonder how many will pin their faith on the falsehood here uttered by the editor of the Free Methodist. For no Seventh-day Adventist has ever claimed that the meeting was not held on the first day of the week. He never heard them say it, nor has he ever seen it in any written or printed document that came from their hands. Yet he boldly declares that they “affirm” it. We brand the statement as a deliberate and inexcusable untruth. It would be very foolish for any one to claim that the meeting was not on the first day of the week; for the record plainly says that it was.
But, to be as charitable as possible, we will suggest that perhaps the F. M. by italicizing the words “first day,” meant to be understood as referring to the day-time of the first day. But if so, we would ask why it tries to dodge the issue, and mislead the reader; for the text says nothing about the day-time in connection with the meeting. The only meeting it speaks of or describes was an evening meeting, when “many lights were burning in the upper chamber” where they were assembled. And the text says that was “on the first day of the week.” The record therefore refers to the evening of that first day, not any evening “preceding or following” it, as we are falsely accused of claiming. The evening of the first day according to the Scriptures, as every commentator of any credit or scholarship admits, was the first part of the day. “The evening and the morning,” in the order of darkness and light here indicated, constituted, and in Bible questions and institutions, still constitute, the day. And on the first, or dark part of the day, the meeting of Acts 20 : 7-14 was held.
But with the desperation of a drowning man, the editor of the F. M. will have it that a meeting was held in the day-time of that first day. We do not blame him; for if there was no day meeting then held, as we shall presently prove that there was not, this text, the sole stay, support, and dependence of Sunday-keeping in its old age, becomes bankrupt to them, and leaves the Sunday institution to the pauper’s fate. So he says:—
“To say that because Paul preached in the evening, they did not meet together in the day-time, is too absurd to need even contradiction. What possible proof can a Sunday evening meeting be that there was no religious service there in the day-time? To such extremities are these mistaken people driven in order to support their absurd, unscriptural notions!”
If our friend would spend less time in hurling epithets at us, and more on his argument, while it would not help his argument any, it would make him appear more respectable. Will he give us a little proof that there was a meeting in the day-time? If there was, the text says not one word about it; there isn’t the first shadow of intimation that there was any such meeting; and to say that there was, is a purely gratuitous assumption prompted by the necessities and desperation of the case.
But we will now prove that there was no day meeting on that occasion. The meeting described was an evening meeting; and the evening, as already noticed, was the first part of the day. An evening meeting on any day could be held only before the daylight part of the same day came. An evening meeting on the first day of the week, would necessarily occur, therefore, before the light part of that first day of the week came. It would correspond, to use the common names, to our Saturday evening, the first day of the week beginning at the going down of the sun on Saturday (the seventh day of the week), and ending at the going down of the sun on Sunday.
Having now located the beginning of that meeting on Saturday evening, the early part of that first day (and any man who disputes this point only makes himself ridiculous), let us follow the record on through the hours of that day. Paul preached till midnight (verse 7), then went down and restored to life Eutychus, who was killed by falling from the window of the third story where the meeting was in progress. He then went back into the hall, broke bread (after midnight), and talked on even till break of day. Verse 11. What day was that?—The light part of that same first day of the week. What did he do then? keep on holding a meeting through the day-time of that first day, as the editor of the Free Methodist asserts?—Not by any means. The record says: “So he departed.” Verse 11. Men may beat their brains out against this record if they choose; but there it stands. Instead of holding a meeting on that day-time, he was off on his journey, going afloat across the base of the peninsula to Assos, a distance of nearly twenty miles. His companions in travel had taken the ship the evening before, to sail the longer distance around the promontory, and meet Paul the next day at Assos. Why did not Paul go with them?—Because he could save a few hours more with the church at Troas, and hold another meeting with them, by tarrying there till morning and then going on foot to Assos. Why did not Luke and the others of Paul’s company wait with Paul till morning?—Because then they would not have had time to take the ship around the longer distance by water, and reach Assos by the following evening. The record of all the movements of the disciples on this occasion, and the reasons therefor, are just as plain as a sunbeam. And the testimony renders it impossible to suppose that Paul and his companions were holding a meeting at Troas in the day-time of that day; for they were all off on their journey to Assos. Shall we believe it? or shall we set it aside as absurd? It is pitiful to see men, wedded to a wretched theory, blindly cling to it though to do so they have to deny at almost every turn the testimony of the Scriptures. As intimated above, Acts 20 : 7 is held, by a certain class, to be the strong proof for Sunday-keeping in the Christian Church; and it is the very strongest there is. But when we take the whole record down to verse 15, a more complete demolition of the Sunday institution, in its modern Protesto-papal habiliments, could scarcely be found. The Sunday gun loaded with Acts 20 : 7-14 is more dangerous at the breech than at the muzzle.
An examination of the other points in this Free Methodist article we must defer to another week.