The ignorance of the people on the Sabbath question is not to be wondered at when we consider the ignorance of their teachers. It has been one of the great misfortunes of the world, in respect to the way of divine truth, that so many who are blind have assumed to lead the blind, and so many who would not cease to pervert the right ways of the Lord, have set themselves up as guides of the people. Alas for a community when one who has secured its confidence as a religious teacher, sets before it for truth, a perversion of facts, illogical conclusions, and misapplications of the testimony of the sacred Scriptures!
The claims of the Sabbath of Jehovah are now so asserting themselves in all parts of the land, that it is causing a general stir in the different camps of the opposition; and it is pitiable to see the sophistries with which men try to deceive themselves on this subject, the careless thought and limited research they bring to bear upon it, and the superficial and flippant manner in which they assume to make a final disposition of the whole matter.
The teaching of the Bible on this subject is harmonious and clear and simple. A child can easily understand it. And such should always be the case with truth which affects the soul’s destiny. The first seventh day of time God took as a rest-day. Because he had used the day for this purpose, contemplating his six preceding days’ work, and finding it all very good, he “blessed the seventh day;” that is, he placed upon every succeeding seventh day, in numerical succession, a blessing; and he sanctified, or set apart, all such days, to be used religiously by mankind. “The Sabbath was made for man”—for the whole race, not for the Jews alone. Mark 2:27. Here the week originated. This division of time can be accounted for in no other way. Here the Bible places it; and profane history, as far back as it goes, testifies that all nations have had the week; and it has come down to us in regular succession from the beginning.
At Sinai, the Sabbath law refers the whole Sabbatic institution to the events of the creation week, and bases it upon them. Ex. 20:8–11. The perpetuity of that law Christ affirmed in the most positive manner for the whole gospel dispensation. Matt. 5:17.
Thus the Bible presentation of the case is straightforward, consistent, plain, and direct as can be. There are in it no sharp corners to turn, no chasms to leap, no breaks to be, by some hook or crook, got around.
Now look at the devices of men. Different creeds set up these claims: The Sabbath was made at creation, but was not a universal institution. The Sabbath was not made at creation, but at Sinai. The Lord rested on the seventh day at creation, but did not bless it for 2,500 years, till Moses. The Hebrews were the first to keep it and the only ones to keep it. God’s seventh day was Adam’s first day. The day was changed at the passover. It was changed at the crossing of the Red Sea. It was changed at the falling of the manna. The fourth commandment does not refer to the same day as Gen. 2:3. It only requires a seventh part of time any way. At Christ’s time the day was changed back to the original day. It was changed to another day. It was abolished. It came to an end of itself, and another institution, for another reason, has sprung up in its stead.
Away with all such nonsense! Nothing of the kind is called for. It is contrary to reason. It is contrary to Scripture. It is not according to God’s ways of working. These conflicting positions are not the honest statements of necessary conclusions or candid convictions. They are mere make-shifts, dodges, excuses, sophisms, to avoid the plain law, and the honest practice, of Sabbath-keeping. God isn’t a chameleon nor a weather-vane. Moral principles and moral practices are the same from beginning to end; and in the realm of morals there will be one rule and one judgment for Jew and Greek, male and female, bond and free.
We are led to these remarks by two articles in the Christian Gleaner, on the Sabbath question, which have been sent to us. The Gleaner is devoted, it says, “to the interests of the Church of Christ in Minnesota and the Northwest,” if anybody knows to what church that title belongs. The first article is by L. A. Pier, editor of the Gleaner, in Gleaner of July, 1889, and the second, by E. Thompson, in Gleaner of June, 1890.
The first article by Mr. P. contains some remarkable admissions. Here are some of them, quoted verbatim: “The observance of days by Christians, is not the result of apostolic teaching, but is an inheritance from Judaism.” “The gatherings on the first day of the week are not in observance of the day, but are to worship Christ.” We wonder if Christ couldn’t be worshiped by a gathering on any other day just as well. Referring to the gathering mentioned in Acts 20:7, which is the great stronghold of Sunday-Lord’s-day observers, this writer says: “Their meeting was not to observe the day, or to hear Paul preach, but to break bread.” What a piece of consistency is this! to take the supper which Christ instituted on Thursday, and celebrate it every Sunday, a day on which Christ never ate it, not in honor of the day, which is chosen simply because Christ rose on that day, but in honor of Christ! Would it not be a little more consistent, while endeavoring to honor the founder of an institution by observing the institution which he founded, to place such observance on the day on which it was founded, instead of some other?
This class of people claim that their Sunday observance has nothing to do with the Sabbath. The Lord’s day is a new institution, celebrated with another idea. This claim is, on the face of it, absurd. If it has nothing to do with Sabbatic observance, in the name of reason, why observe it every week? It is impossible to divorce any weekly celebration from the Sabbatic idea. There was absolutely nothing in the resurrection of Christ to suggest a weekly observance any more than there was in the declaration of independence by the United States. The Declaration was signed on Thursday. Now why not celebrate Thursday every week to commemorate our independence, as well as to take Sunday of every week to commemorate the resurrection of Christ, because it happened to come on that day of the week? The simple reason is that the people of the United States do not connect Independence Day with the idea of the Sabbath; but those who brought Sunday into the Church did so connect it; and all those who follow the weekly observance, adopt that idea, disclaim it as much as they please. But the position, either in theory or practice, that the Sabbath itself is set aside, while the Sabbatic idea in a weekly observance is still to be continued, is too absurd to be for a moment entertained.
This writer, like others of his class, endeavors to carry his point by breaking down the distinction between moral and ceremonial laws, and applying the book of Galatians to the ten commandments. But this cannot be done. Moral laws are, from their very nature, immutable and perpetual. Ceremonial laws, ordinances (Eph. 2:15; Col. 2:14), are expressly declared to have been taken out of the way, being nailed to the cross. If this writer and all his school could make such expressions as, “added . . . till the seed should come,” and the “school-master” which we are “no longer under,” (Gal. 3:19, 24, 25) stick to the ten commandments, he would be happy. But this he cannot do. They are not what Paul is talking about. Moral laws and moral institutions are subject to no limitations nor changes of condition.
In the second article, Mr. Thompson contradicts Mr. Pier. Mr. P. says we do not celebrate the day. Mr. Thompson heads his article, “The Day we Celebrate and the Reason Why.” He quotes from McGarvey’s “Lands of the Bible,” the reason given by Mohammedans why they observe Friday as the Sabbath. It is, they say, “because Adam was created on Friday,” etc. Then he remarks: “This I esteem as a valid reason why it was right and proper for them and all God-fearing people from Adam to Moses. I believe that all the nations that preserved the knowledge of God, and accepted his covenants, and hoped for the fulfillment of his promises, kept that day and are still keeping it.”
How shall we account for such a strange declaration as this? Do Mohammedans date from Adam? Did all the people of God from Adam to Moses keep Friday? Everybody who has ever read Genesis 1 and 2, knows it was not the sixth day on which Adam was created which was set apart as the Sabbath, but the day following, the seventh day. And are all who “accept his covenants” “still keeping” that day? It is a marvel that any man in his sober senses should utter such a declaration, or that any paper should ever print it.
Again he says: “But it will be said that Mohammedanism arose in the seventh century after Christ. Yes; but Mohammed conceived it his mission to restore the religion of Adam and Islam, which embraced the Sabbath and circumcision, both of which they perpetuate to this time.”
To “restore the religion of Adam and Islam.” And pray who was Islam? Was he twin to Adam? And when did his religion fall into disuse, that it could be restored by Mohammed? And are we to understand that the Friday Sabbath of the Mohammedans, is the original Edenic Sabbath of Adam? A few more declarations of this kind will force upon us the conclusion that somebody has lost his senses.
Mr. T. admits that James and the Jewish Christians kept the seventh-day Sabbath, but the councilp. 425 at Jerusalem (Acts 15) did not enforce it upon Gentiles, therefore it is not now binding. Notice what other of the ten commandments were not enforced by that council; are they not therefore now binding? The fact is, that council was not legislating upon the moral law at all. He says again, “I venerate the motto, ‘Where the Bible speaks, we speak.’” Yes; and we doubt if any motto was ever more abused in this world, than is this one by the people who so ostentatiously use it. He adds: “But the Bible has spoken of the first day, and the Fathers have supplemented their testimony as follows.” So the Bible has spoken of the first day. It speaks of it only historically, and only eight times, six of the instances referring to that one day on which the Saviour arose; but it nowhere gives it any sacred title, records no one as resting upon it, gives no precept for its observance, and no example of any day meeting ever held upon it, but sets it forth as a secular working-day, like any other working-day of the week. But up comes this church with the motto, and gives Sunday the title of Lord’s day, which the Bible does not, and elevates it above the other days, which the Bible does not, and makes it the regular day for religious worship, which the Bible does not, and dropping the Lord’s Sabbath, which the Bible does not, makes this first day fulfill all the outward functions, and serve all the outward purposes of the Sabbath, which the Bible does not, and then piously exclaims, “Where the Bible speaks, we speak, and where the Bible is silent, we are silent!” Let them do so or pull down their false colors.
Our writer seems anxious to get behind the Fathers, although if the testimony of the Fathers for Sunday is good for anything, it places it in a different light altogether from that in which the modern Disciple Church profess to regard it. He begins, as usual, with “Barnabas, the companion of Paul,” and quotes, “We celebrate the eighth day, on which Jesus arose from the dead.” The Barnabas of the New Testament never said anything of the kind. Many years ago Justin Edwards, in his “Sabbath Manual,” gathered together a mess of musty old falsehoods respecting the Fathers, and the friends of Sunday have been busy ladling them out to each other ever since. The so-called epistle of Barnabas was not the work of Barnabas the apostle. Those who have read it, know that it is not only silly, but, in some parts, absolutely indecent. Mosheim says that it was the production of some Jew in the second century, of “mean abilities and superstitious attachment to Jewish fables.” In this view concur all respectable authorities and church historians, as Neander, Fisher, Prof. Stewart, Dr. Killen, Prof. Hackett, Milner, Kitto, Eusebius, Sir Wm. Domville, Coleman, and the Encyclopedia of Religious Knowledge. It is laughable to see men claiming to be intelligent, take off their hats and bow down before this transparent old fraud, reverentially mumbling, “Barnabas, the companion of Paul”!
Next, of course, comes Ignatius, who is made to say, “No longer sabbatizing, but living in the observance of the Lord’s day, on which, also, our life sprang up again.” But Ignatius does not say anything of this kind. It cannot be found in his writings. In an old forgery ascribed to Ignatius, there is a passage concerning the Lord’s life, into which some translator fraudulently inserted the word “day” to make it refer to Sunday. Out of such multiplied frauds is testimony for Sunday manufactured.
Our friend strangely omits another falsehood about Pliny and the martyrs, and passes over to Justin Martyr, A. D. 150. He quotes him as saying: “On the Lord’s day, all Christians . . . meet together, because that is the day of our Lord’s resurrection,” etc. Justin does not say so. He says, “And upon the day called Sunday,” etc., which, considering that Sunday was a pagan festival day, and he was writing to a pagan emperor, makes a very different thing of it. The term “Lord’s day” was not applied to Sunday till the time of Tertullian, A. D. 200, more than 100 years after the last of the apostles had gone to his grave.
Next comes testimony from Irenaeus: “On the Lord’s day every one of us Christians keeps the Sabbath.” Why should a Disciple quote such testimony as this, when he says that he does not keep the Sabbath on the Lord’s day? But the singular part of it is that not a single syllable of all this famous testimony can be found in the writings of Irenaeus. He never said anything of the kind. Come, friends, study up a little on this subject, so as to know what you are talking about; it will save you from the embarrassment of leaning upon such testimony.
Next Eusebius, “the father of ecclesiastical history,” who wrote in the fourth century, is quoted as saying: “From the beginning the Christians assembled on the first day of the week, called by them the Lord’s day, to read the Scriptures, to preach, and to celebrate the Lord’s Supper.” We give italics just as Mr. Thompson has given them. The quotation reads as though it was carefully calculated for the latitude of the Disciple Church. At any rate we can inform the reader that it is manufactured testimony; we do not say by whom. We have a copy of Eusebius’s Ecclesiastical History, and there is no such testimony in it!
Truly, Sunday is in a bad case. With a great flourish it appeals to the New Testament for testimony in its support; but when we search for it, lo, there isn’t any there! It then appeals to the Church Fathers; and, lo, all it gets from them is a fraud! How long will men cling to an institution which is a brazen intruder in the Christian Church, with no better credentials than these!
A Dr. Lamson, whoever he may be, is next quoted as saying: “It would seem that the disciples, from the first or during apostolic times, were accustomed to meet for thanks and praise on the first day of the week.” So it has finally dwindled down to a “seem” so. But it can “seem” so only to those who have such a desire to have it so that they will take as sound testimony, unscrupulous fabrications without looking the matter up for themselves.
Mr. T. finally strikes a statement which can be found, and for the first time gives us volume and page. It is Mosheim’s famous statement, by which he has done more mischief in the Christian world than ever his history can do good, that “all Christians were unanimous in setting apart the first day of the week, on which the triumphant Saviour arose from the dead, for the solemn celebration of religious worship.” This custom, he says, was derived from “the example of the church at Jerusalem,” and “founded on the express appointment of the apostles.” But he failed to produce an instance of that “example,” or to tell us where the “express appointment” can be found. His statement is fully offset by that of Neander, who wrote later, and in a more critical and accurate manner, when he says: “The festival of Sunday, like all other festivals, was always only a human ordinance, and it was far from the intentions of the apostles to establish a divine command in this respect, far from them and from the early apostolic church to transfer the laws of the Sabbath to Sunday.”—Rose’s Neander, p. 186.
A comment by McKnight on Col. 2:16, in favor of Sunday, which is no better than any other man’s opinion and assertion, closes the testimony. But before he lays down his pen, Mr. T. is moved to exhort his readers as follows:—
“Let us stand fast in the liberty wherewith Christ has made us free.”
That is to say, to keep the seventh day which God has commanded, that is bondage; but to keep the first day, which he has not commanded, in substantially the same manner, that is liberty!
“Let us observe with all due reverence and joy the Lord’s day to commemorate the Lord’s resurrection.”
But is not baptism the divinely appointed memorial of Christ’s resurrection? Rom. 6:3–5; Col. 2:12; 3:1. And does God ever pile up two memorials for the same thing?—Never.
“For in so doing we shall be honoring Christ, following apostolic precedent and precept, and obeying the will of God.”
Christ says, “Ye are my friends, if ye do whatsoever I command you.” We cannot honor Christ by setting up a will-worship which he has not commanded. And as to precedent and precept, we challenge every Sunday-keeper on the face of the earth, high or low, rich or poor, humble or proud, modest or puffed up with vain conceit, to show the first scintilla of either apostolic precedent or precept in behalf of Sunday observance. For remember that the editor of the Gleaner himself admits that the meeting of Acts 20:7, was not to honor the first day. And finally, as to obeying the will of God, how is it obeying his will when we do that which he has never made it known to be his will that we should do? All such rhetorical froth is tiresome. For a full examination of the testimony of the Fathers, see Andrews’s Complete “History of the Sabbath.”