AdventAI

A FALSE CHRIST OR A FALSE PROPHET—WHICH?

By D. T. Bourdeau

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 30., July 29, 1890

BY ELD. D. T. BOURDEAU.

(Battle Creek, Mich.)

Another correspondent presents, in opposition to what we have written on prophecy, what he denominates “the last man mentioned on the pages of Holy Writ that was to do a special work in close connection with the final and everlasting consummation of all things earthly.” The writer claims that this wonderful personage “is now living on the earth,” that he “has finished his labors, and has received a very cold reception.” He claims that said person and his work were prophesied of 2,613 years ago,” and refers to such passages as Isa. 28:1–13; 46:8–13; Ezekiel 9; Mal. 4:5, 6; Rev. 10:1–6, etc., without even quoting them. He adds: “The prophet Isaiah, looking down the stream of time to the very days in which we are now living, says, ‘All ye beasts of the field, come to devour.’ . . . These represent the entire ruling classes of mankind. And why are they all called?—To come and devour the people of God.”

A poor come-out, surely! A wonderful personage, doing a special work, and when he has closed his labors, all the people of God that he has raised are going to be devoured by the wicked! And yet further on he says that God will make these more precious than the golden wedge of Ophir, and quotes Isa. 13:11–13. How unlike the experience of God’s true people as set forth by the unerring word of prophecy, which represents them as shouting the victory over their oppressors, and singing the song ofp. 468 Moses and the Lamb! Rev. 14:1–3; 15:1–3.

A man engaged in this singular movement broke in upon us in a disorderly and ungentlemanly manner at our General Conference at Minneapolis, Minn., and vociferated with the confidence of a Goliath: “The deliverer has come! He is among us; has been born of a woman.” He referred to the man-child spoken of in Revelation 12, whom the dragon sought to devour as soon as he was born, who was caught up to God and to his throne, and who is to govern all nations with a rod of iron. What a miserable, audacious, and sacrilegious perversion of a scripture that so clearly describes the experience of Christ at his first advent, and his kingly, retributive rule over the wicked in the coming day of wrath!

Who is this wonderful personage concerning whom such strange outbursts are made? Does he pretend to be Christ, or a forerunner of that august Being? If he lays claim to the messiahship, and pretends that he is Christ, the anointed One, who has made his second appearance, meet him squarely with the following questions: Was Christ to be born of a woman at his second advent? or was he to come from the courts above, having been a faithful high-priest before the Eternal? Have you not retrograded, gone back, to partly imitate the first advent? If so, what is there that is remarkable, miraculous, about your birth? Recoil, O vain, presumptuous mortal, before the dazzling light of God’s word, exposing your sacrilegious audacity and your consummate folly on every hand.

Where are the effulgent, burning glory, and the myriads of angels that have accompanied you as you have made your appearance in the clouds of heaven? Who has heard the voice of the Eternal pouring forth from the throne above like peals of ten thousand thunders, announcing your coming? Matt. 24:36*; Heb. 12:26; Rev. 16:17, etc.; Jer. 25:30, etc. Has the earth trembled at your coming? Did you come with eyes like flames of fire, with a vesture as red as blood, with feet like shining brass, with many glorious crowns upon your head, and with a vesture labeled, “King of kings and Lord of lords”? Revelation 1:19; Isaiah 63, etc. Did the wicked flee before you at your coming in flames of fire to destroy them by the brightness of your coming? and did they then cry to rocks and mountains to fall on them and hid them from your face? 2 Thess. 1:7–10; 2:8; 1 Thess. 5:2, 3; Rev. 6:14–17; 19:11–21; Isa. 13:9, etc., etc. If so, how is it that there are sinners in every part of the earth? Did you with a trumpet voice, with the voice of the archangel, raise the righteous dead and change the righteous living, bestow upon them the gift of immortality and take them to heaven, at your coming? How does it happen that you and your followers are still on earth? Blush, hide, and smite your breast with feelings of true contrition, and ask God to forgive you your pride and blindness, O vain man, and prepare to meet the King of kings and Lord of lords.

If we have to do with one who simply claims to be a forerunner of Christ, answering to Elijah, we fail to see in him what would be necessary to fill the bill. Men of God, like Elijah, John the Baptist, etc., do not make of themselves a grand center to receive homage; to publish themselves and to be published and extolled, as in the case of impostors; but they turn the minds of the people away from themselves, to the Most High and to Jesus. We regard this as a striking case of man-worship. It is doing worse than did the Israelites in asking a king when God had proposed to be their king. This was, to quite an extent, a political affair. But in the case before us, we have idolatry covered with the garb of religion, lowering Jesus and bringing contempt upon the true doctrine of his coming, before the people.

The work set forth in Revelation 13, one of the passages referred to by our correspondent, is to be extensive, world-wide. The message upon which it is based is to be proclaimed on sea and land. (See also Rev. 14:6, 7; Joel 2:1, etc.) It is not to commence and die out in some part of America, or in Europe, or in any one locality or country of our earth. This fact alone suffices to brand the local movement that we are exposing as spurious. The genuine advent movement will be marked with a true missionary spirit. Its burden will be the conversion and sanctification of men everywhere and in every land, that a people may be found ready to meet the Lord in peace at his coming.

And it is not simply in America that such singular movements are set on foot. A few years ago, while laboring in Geneva, Switzerland, we learned that in that city, the “City of Calvin,” the seat of the French Protestant Reformation in the sixteenth century, there were quite a number of religionists who held that Christ had come. And who was their Christ?—A man in Paris belonging to a renowned family that had produced more devoted and influential Protestant ministers than any other family in France. This man had previously written us a letter, asking us to help forward his movement. He is now upward of eighty years old, and, of course, expects soon to die. “And what will become of Christ?” was the question which we propounded. The reply we received was: “His mantle and his spirit will rest on another man.”

God pity those who become the slaves of such a deception! They must have fearfully back-slidden from God to embrace such palpable errors. They are a living illustration of the power of Satan upon those who walk not in the path of humility and consecration to God. There must have been weak points in their moral characters, which have not been fortified by the power of grace, and which have served as avenues by which Satan has come in and fastened upon them his strong delusions.

We expect that such characters will multiply as we draw near to the end; and they will, at a fearful cost to themselves, furnish us a striking sign that the coming of Jesus is imminent; for Jesus, in enumerating the tokens of his approach, says: “Then if any man shall say unto you, Lo, here is Christ, or there; believe it not. For there shall arise false christs, and false prophets, and shall show great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect.” Matt. 24:23, 24.

We still solicit free criticisms from friends or foes. Be brief and pointed. If we have errors, we do not want them. If we have the truth (which we believe to be the case), we want to retain it, and it is our duty to communicate it to others. In this case, we can afford to be fair. The more intense the heat by which gold is tested, the brighter will the precious metal shine. So of criticism with regard to truth. Though we may be conscious in our inmost souls that the great doctrines we hold are scriptural, yet we may, from the power of habit and education, make incorrect applications of certain scriptures. Any one looking on with a fresh mind, who will point out such errors, will do us a favor. Let us not write through a love for debate or to build up ourselves. That would only result in evil and in injury to the cause of truth and to those who love contention. Let us write with the design of helping one another to arrive at a knowledge of the truth.

Notes

  1. *Here “knoweth” has, by virtue of a Hebrew idiom, etc., the sense of maketh known. God will make known the day and hour of Christ’s coming. ↩