AdventAI

“DIFFICULTIES REMOVED.”

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 30., July 29, 1890

Such is the heading to an article by Clark Braden, which appears in the Christian Oracle of June 26, 1890. Mr. Braden appreciates the difficulties liable to be encountered upon claiming too much for Sunday-keeping, and proceeds to instruct his Disciple brethren a little upon the subject. The following are some of his statements:—

At Troas the congregation met Saturday evening. Paul preached till past midnight; then they broke bread. Paul preached after that till day-break. Then he started, at day-break Sunday, for Assos. . . . It shows that Paul did not regard the first day as a sabbath or rest. It was not, and was never so regarded by early Christians. . . . They abstained from work while engaged in such church work, and no further than that. . . . Meeting Saturday evening to break bread was the custom. . . . Paul’s act in traveling all day [Sunday] shows that the day was not a sabbath. The Christians abstained from work when met for worship. We have no evidence that they abstained during any other portion of the day.

Quite admissions indeed! The Troas meeting was held Saturday evening, and Paul pursued his journey on Sunday. This is just what we have held for these many years. And this traveling done by Paul shows that he did not regard Sunday as a sabbath. Just our position exactly. And the early Christians “never so regarded” it. No; we never believed they did either. Neither did they abstain from common labor on that day only while they might chance to be holding a meeting then, and of course no one supposes that they worked while they were attending meeting on any day.

But how does all this correspond with the practice of our Disciple friends, who lay great claim to being “apostolic”? and how are any difficulties thereby removed for them? Do they meet Saturday night to break bread? In this same paper Eld. D. R. Lucas, in an article on the Lord’s Supper, says: “Approved apostolic example is the same as a command.” Why do not these people, then, meet Saturday evening to celebrate the Lord’s Supper? And, to carry the question a little further, why do not they meet and break bread every day, as we find the early Christians doing after the day of Pentecost, under the approval and sanction of all the apostles, who had been told by their Lord to tarry at Jerusalem until they should be endued with power from on high? Acts 2: 46. Why do not they do it, if “approved apostolic example is the same as a command”?

Again, can it be said of these people, who are so tenacious of being called “Christians” instead of Campbellites, as Mr. Braden says of Paul and the early Christians, that they do not regard Sunday as a sabbath, and that they abstain from work on that day only while attending church services?—No, indeed; for that is just the way they do regard the day, “as a sabbath or rest,” because they do sabbatize, or rest, on that day, abstaining from work while not attending church, and regard common labor performed on that day a sin.

As is evident from the statements of Mr. Braden given above, the difficulties in the Sunday question are to be avoided only by abandoning all claims to its sacredness or divine appointment. But his statements remove no difficulties for his people so long as they continue their present practice. The scripturality of their practice of observing a day is at stake, the same as is ours, so long as they have such a practice, and their practice in observing Sunday is that of sabbath-keeping (resting from worldly labor) as surely as is ours in observing the seventh day, no matter what they may call it or what they may refuse to call it; it is sabbath-keeping. And this, says Clark Braden, was not the belief nor practice of the early Christians. Therefore, by their own testimony they condemn their practice as not apostolic. They will find, if they ever find the truth, that there is but one God, one Saviour, one faith, one hope, one baptism, and one weekly Sabbath, and only one, of the Bible. Sunday-keeping is a fraud, an innovation on the Sabbath of God and of the Lord of the Sabbath. W. A. C.