RELIGIOUS LIBERTY IN SWITZERLAND

11%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 5, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 31.

Read the full edition

RELIGIOUS LIBERTY IN SWITZERLAND.

Perhaps nothing could illustrate better what Religious Liberty means in Switzerland, and what it does not mean, than a glimpse into the sanctum of the Swiss law-makers, at a time when the question is up for discussion. Recently the question was to be settled, whether or not the Salvation Army ought to be suffered to carry on their work, in their own peculiar way, in Switzerland. In 1888 the Federal Council had been petitioned, by cantonal societies, to put a stop to the practices of the Salutists throughout Switzerland, since their doings were nothing more than a humbug. Since then a number of other petitions of the same nature have been sent in, and only very few have appeared in favor of any such Religious Liberty as the Salvationists evidently expected. But the Federal Council, after mature consideration of the matter, decided not to issue any laws against any religious body, as long as such body did not violate a certain section of the fifty-first article of the constitution, which is against the Jesuits, as a body, who by vows and oaths on the one side, and interference in politics on the other, become an enemy to the state and the public safety. But such objections could not be raised in any way against the Salvationists. The council then gives its sentiments in these words:—
Religious Liberty, which includes both confessional freedom and the free exercise of the various acts of worship, is one of the grandest attainments of more modern times. In Switzerland this liberty has been able to assert itself only after severe and long conflicts. . . . To be sure it is to be lamented that the religious freedom, as provided by the Federal Constitution, is not recognized by the spirit and customs of our people, as it might be. The people are at any time ready to raise claims in favor of their own views of faith and practice; but when it comes to the respect of the rights and privileges of others, they are only too much inclined to deny them these, more or less. We are sorry that conflicting tendencies of this kind are so common that we did not feel surprised to be petitioned by a society on the matter, which generally stands in the very front among those who raise the cry for the realization of new progress. But in view of such deviations and missteps, we shall always hold fast to the principle of Religious Liberty within the boundaries of the constitution, and shall secure for it throughout Switzerland the proper recognition.
Thereupon they considered all the objections which are raised against the Salvationists on account of their noisy, boisterous ways of doing, their levying money on every possible occasion, disturbing the public peace by frequent broils and even fights, where blood has flowed; but the Federal Council recognizes considerately their reasons, that they must proceed in this way “to arouse the public,” “in order to win those souls that cannot be impressed by the monotonous services of the State Church or the Free Church of Switzerland.” The council then sums up its conclusions in these words:—
It is true that the Salutists have acted in such a way that whole sections of the population, where for a long time already numerous sects had enjoyed the greatest liberties, in view of the exciting “war-cries” of Salutists, have lost their sense of peace; and it is further true that the Salutists themselves, by their stubbornness and tough resistance against every order issued, which they thought they could successfully combat, have forfeited the good-will of the police, and even of some of the cantonal governments. But all this cannot prevent us from recognizing the religious and moral character of the Salutists; just as little would it be in place for us to deviate from the decisions which the Federal Constitution has marked out for us as our guide. The necessity of maintaining public order may compel the local governments to put certain restrictions upon the public actions of the Salvationists, but a complete suppression would not be possible without severing from the escutcheon of our constitution one of its most precious gems—the principle of liberty of worship. We must therefore, from the start, turn away every attempt which aims at interdicting the exercise of their religious worship to the Salutists.
The Federal Council then comes to speak of the proceedings on the part of several cantonal governments against the Salvationists, and says that, on general principles, while Religious Liberty and liberty of conscience should have unrestricted freedom, yet the manner of conducting their worship should be in harmony with decency and order, and wherever this is not the case, legal restrictions may become necessary for the sake of maintaining public order. And such restrictions could only be provisory and temporal. But the council could not resist from censuring several cantonal governments, which censure is couched in these words:—
To be candid, several of the measures against the Salutists have not pleased us at all; for it would seem that the freedom of worship has been altogether too lightly sacrificed to the fastidious demands of public order; in other words, the maintenance of public order might have been achieved through other means. This evil has, however, not seemed to us sufficiently weighty to withdraw from the cantons one of their most essential prerogatives. We have preferred to remain in our normal position, and thus only watch the remedies they apply, and, if necessary, to make use of our influence and right of supervision to gradually bring the cantons to abandon severe measures which are not justified by compelling circumstances. From this point of view we have ever acted, and in the future it shall continue to be our standard.
Even by the most unfavorable construction which might be put upon these words, it cannot be denied that they are neither bigoted nor intolerant; and if words mean anything, the immediate future prospect for Swiss Religious Liberty is at least not one whit less good than it is now. On the contrary, it promises to be better, if the words of the Federal Council mean anything. May God grant that they prove true in the fullest sense of their import.
A. Kunz.