AdventAI

THE SUPPORT OF ERROR.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 45., November 18, 1890

A FEW other points in the article of the Free Methodist, in addition to those examined last week, demand a passing notice. We have seen what assumptions and absurdities the editor of that journal runs into in attempting to show that Acts 20:7-12 sustains the observance of the first day of the week. We will now look at what he claims the text teaches in regard to the disciples’ not observing the seventh day. He says:—

“This verse [verse 7] plainly teaches that the Christians of that early age did not meet together on Saturday, the Jewish Sabbath, the seventh day of the week.”

And the reason which he gives for this wonderful deduction which we suppose must be satisfactory to him, as he soberly proposes it to others, is expressed in these words:—

“For Paul was there seven days (verse 6). He must then have been there on the Jewish Sabbath, but did not preach to the Christians on that day, because that was not their day for worship. No other reason can be given.”

Yes; but who says he did not preach to them? For bald and barefaced assumptions, which are not only uncalled for, but are just exactly the opposite of the truth, this writer must be allowed the premium. Paul was there seven days; but nothing is said about a meeting on any day till we come to the first day of the week. Are we therefore to conclude that Paul, anxious as he was to hasten on his journey as soon as his work for the brethren was done, loafed around there in idleness for a week, and would not hold a meeting till the first day came, but just as soon as he reached that point, started in and preached all night! What nonsense!

But further, verse 5 says that a part of Paul’s company arrived at Troas some time before he did, and waited for him there. They must have been there over one other first-day, at least, and probably more. But the record says nothing about any meeting on the first day, during all the time that elapsed before Paul’s arrival; and after he came, it mentions only the last meeting he held with them, because that was the one remarkable meeting of the occasion.

Let us now bestow a little candid thought on what the text does prove in respect to the Sabbath. The first fact that strikes the careful reader is that Paul and his company would not travel on the Sabbath. This is evident, because they all waited till the Sabbath was past before they made the first move toward continuing their journey; but just as soon as it was ended, they resumed their journey. As the Sabbath ended at sunset, to enter immediately upon their journey would be to travel in the dark. This those who were going by ship could more conveniently do, and did do. But Paul, as noticed last week, could gain time for another meeting with them by stopping till morning and then going on foot across to Assos, where he would meet his companions with the ship. And this he did. So it is very evident that they would not travel on the Sabbath, because that was the divinely appointed rest day, and was still binding. But just as soon as the Sabbath was past, and the first day had come, they entered just as soon as they conveniently could, according to their different modes of travel, upon their journey, the sailors leaving in the evening, and Paul, the footman, the following morning. And they were all off on their journey all the day-time of that famous first-day, and certainly held no meeting with the disciples at Troas on that part of the day. They thus showed by their actions at least, that they regarded it as secular time. Yet the editor of the Free Methodist very wisely affirms that that was their regular day for rest and worship, and that “the language plainly teaches this.” Such assertions are supposable only on the ground that a person has no other stock in trade.

A word more as to “the language.” The one who writes as above quoted, professes to be a scholar. He therefore must know that in this he is asserting that which is not only untrue, but which any ordinary reader of the Greek is able to expose. He knows that the construction of the sentence is not, for instance, like this: “Now the first day of the week having come, when the disciples met together to break bread,” etc. He knows that Luke employs simply a noun and its participle, thus: “And upon the first day of the week, the disciples having come together to break bread,” etc. This is exactly the construction that would be used to indicate an incidental meeting, and thus shows that this was a meeting of that nature. And plainly the only reason for making special mention of that was to record the wonderful miracle of the healing of Eutychus; for that is the only incident which is especially remarkable that is introduced.

The editor next undertakes to dispose of the great fact that there are so many instances noted in which Paul and other apostles held meetings on the Sabbath; as Acts 13:42; 16:13; 17:2; 18:4; etc. To do this he says, “Read carefully these passages, and you will find that it was not to a Christian congregation that he preached,” and in the next paragraph he adds: “You cannot find a single record of the meeting together on the seventh day of the week, of a company of Christian believers for worship.”

Wonderful, isn’t it? To whom was Paul sent to preach?—To an unbelieving world, Jews and Gentiles both. When he first entered a place, there were no Christians there till he had made some converts. While he doubtless held meetings every day, as evangelists do at the present time, he did hold meetings, and made special mention of the fact, on that day which he and all others understood to be the Sabbath, the day of rest and worship. But now we are told—“Oh! well, that was not his day of worship; for remember that he was not preaching to Christians!” Strange basis on which to build an argument, to say that he was not preaching to Christians, in places where there were no Christians. Suppose a missionary should be sent to the Indians, and then some one should attempt to base an argument on the fact that we could not find one instance where he preached to a congregation of white men!

But it was not always the case that Paul preached to the Jews exclusively. The editor of the Free Methodist seems to find it very convenient to overlook verse 44 of Acts 13, where Paul preached at the call of the Gentiles, and held his meeting, too, on the Sabbath, almost the whole city, all Christians, certainly, if there were any there, coming out to hear him.

But granting a moment, for the sake of the argument, all that our opponents claim,—that all the meetings recorded as occurring on the Sabbath, were held only with the Jews,—what then? How does that help the matter for them? For if the first-day sabbath had then been ordained as a binding Christian institution, and the apostles were sent forth to teach Christian doctrine and establish Christian institutions among the Jews, was it not their duty to teach them this first-day sabbath also? And would they not have been remiss in their duty if they had not done so? But where did they ever say one word about it? Where is the record of it? And yet Paul expressly says, “I kept back nothing that was profitable unto you;” and again, “I have not shunned to declare unto you all the counsel of God.” Acts 20:20, 27. He taught the people publicly, as the book of Acts and his epistles show, concerning every Christian duty and Christian institution; but he said not a word concerning the first day, only that we may use it as a secular day (1 Cor. 16:2), and left not one act of example as to how to keep it (at least the daylight part of it), except a twenty-mile foot journey from Troas to Assos. Acts 20:7-14. Where, then, does it come in as a sabbath?—Nowhere in the Scriptures. How, then, has it come into the Christian world at all? Ans.—Through the gate-way of apostasy, tradition, heathenism, and the man of sin.

But it may be asked, Does Paul enforce the Sabbath as a Christian institution?—Most assuredly he does; for first he affirms in the most positive manner the immutability and the everlastingly binding obligation of the law of which the Sabbath is an inseparable part (Rom. 3:31); and, secondly, he has given us, through Luke, in the Acts, the apostolic example of always calling the seventh day “the Sabbath,” and always devoting it to the uses which belong to the Sabbath. So even if the early Church or the apostles themselves kept that day, inasmuch as they have said nothing about it, but while keeping “back nothing that was profitable,” have kept that all back from the record, that testimony brands it at once as something of no worth.

The fact is, the apostles did not know anything of a first-day sabbath; they did not teach it nor keep it, and men in the 19th century cannot make it stick to them. They might just as well undertake to prove that the people of the United States are cannibals.

We have now examined all parts of the article that make any pretense to argument, and have seen how much the arguments are worth. We can only wonder that men can imagine that with such reasoning they can arrest the progress of the truth. With every conscientious student it will only help it. And the steady and rapid advancement of the Sabbath cause, right in the midst of the torrent of this kind of opposition, should tend to lift the scales from their eyes. Yet this Free Methodist editor exhorts his readers not to be afraid of the “Quaker guns” of these “seventh-day-of-the-week people,” and he imagines that through a circulation of his tracts, some of them “will open their eyes” (we think that is true), and “come to the truth”! (But they will not find that on his side of the house.) Then he says: “They will rejoice in the happiness which they find in the sanctifying power of the Holy Ghost above that which they found in the observance of days.”

But if God has enjoined upon his people to observe a day, and we refuse to obey, we wonder how much “sanctifying power of the Holy Ghost” we shall be able to enjoy. This is a deception which attends the Free Methodist movement, and which we fear will, in many cases, lead to fatal results. They seek for a state of feeling, which they think is the “sanctifying power of the Holy Ghost,” and this they make more important than obedience to God! It is strange that men can so deceive themselves; but so it is. They are strenuous for Sunday-keeping, as much so as we are for the keeping of the seventh day; but we wonder if keeping Sunday is not just as much “the observance of days,” as keeping the seventh day. It seems impossible for these men to give a discourse or write an article on this subject without unconsciously betraying the insane prejudice, not to say hatred, which they cherish against that one day of the seven which God calls his “holy day,” and of which Christ declared himself to be the Lord. Isa. 58:13; Mark 2:28. But the day hastens on when all the traditions, perversions, sophisms, and every contrivance by which men seek to cover up the truth will be swept away; and God will reveal his truth by a light from heaven to which none can shut their eyes, and vindicate it by a power which none can resist. But then, alas! it will be too late for those who have trifled with it, and sought to evade it, to turn around and by obedience to it become sanctified through it, that they may be saved. John 17:17.p. 713

ELIJAH.

(Continued.)

His Translation to Heaven.

WHEN we consider the circumstances of the ten tribes, we see a surprising need of such institutions. Since they had revolted from the house of David, the people did not generally attend the temple services as before. Their kings feared to have them, lest they should return to their allegiance to the house of David. 1 Kings 12:26-28. For this reason the golden calves were set up. So we see there was a great lack of instruction until the prophets (and we believe Elijah was prominent in this) established a system where the sons of the prophets first received instruction themselves, and then instructed others. His ten years from his return from Sinai till his translation would be none too much for this. Elijah was thus a great organizer. He thus turned “the hearts of the fathers to the children,” instructing them in the ways of the Lord while first upon earth, as the prophet Malachi said he would again when he should return. Having fully prepared the way and established the means of reform upon a firm basis, the Lord saw fit to take his servant to himself.

“And it came to pass, when the Lord would take up Elijah into heaven by a whirlwind, that Elijah went with Elisha from Gilgal. And Elijah said unto Elisha, Tarry here, I pray thee, for the Lord hath sent me to Bethel. And Elisha said unto him, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soul liveth, I will not leave thee. So they went down to Bethel. And the sons of the prophets that were at Bethel came forth to Elisha, and said unto him, Knowest thou that the Lord will take away the master from thy head to-day? And he said, Yea, I know it; hold ye your peace.” 2 Kings 2:1-3. It will be noticed that not only did Elijah and Elisha understand the time had come for the former to be taken away from the earth, but the “sons of the prophets” also understood it well. We understand they were called by this title because they had looked up to these great prophets whom the Lord had specially endowed, as children to parents. They called them father or master. They had been under their constant instruction, and were therefore made acquainted with the fact that had been revealed to Elijah, that he should be taken up to heaven. They had in some way learned the very day this was to occur. To Elisha it was a matter of absorbing interest. From all the circumstances mentioned in their history, there must have been, it seems, the closest intimacy between them.

“And Elijah said unto him, Elisha, tarry here, I pray thee; for the Lord hath sent me to Jericho. And he said, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soul liveth, I will not leave thee. So they came to Jericho. And the sons of the prophets that were at Jericho came to Elisha, and said unto him, Knowest thou that the Lord will take away thy master from thy head to-day? And he answered, Yea, I know it; hold ye your peace. And Elijah said unto him, Tarry, I pray thee, here; for the Lord hath sent me to Jordan. And he said, As the Lord liveth, and as thy soul liveth, I will not leave thee. And they two went on. And fifty men of the sons of the prophets went, and stood to view [margin, in sight, or over against] afar off: and they two stood by Jordan. And Elijah took his mantle and wrapped it together, and smote the waters, and they were divided hither and thither, so that they two went over on dry ground.” Vs. 4-8.

Here we see again the knowledge of the fact of Elijah’s ascension among the “sons of the prophets” at another city, and their deep interest in it. They approached Elisha, speaking of it, but seem not to have felt free to speak of it to Elijah. Perhaps something in his appearance and presence forbade. It is of some interest to note the journey made by them. They started from Gilgal. According to the best authorities, there were at least two cities by that name in Elijah’s time. One was near Jericho, the first station of the Israelites after crossing the Jordan. The other was eight miles north of Bethel, in the high hill country, between 3,000 and 4,000 feet above the Jordan. It must have been this Gilgal from which Elijah started in the morning of his translation; for the record says they “went down to Bethel,” which would not be true of the Gilgal in the Jordan Valley, some thousands of feet below it. So a journey of eight miles brought them to Bethel. This was one of the famous cities of Palestine existing in Abraham’s time, who visited it. Gen. 12:8. In the fields near by, Jacob slept, with a stone for a pillow, and saw the ladder reaching to heaven, and angels ascending and descending thereon. He afterward dwelt there. Samuel afterward judged Israel at that place, and there one of the golden calves was created by Jeroboam, to lead Israel astray. It is only a small village now, with a few Moslem hovels. Here Elijah and Elisha passed, meeting the sons of the prophets who told the latter he should lose his master to-day; and he said he knew it, and told them to hold their peace. It must have been some fifteen or twenty miles from Bethel to Jericho, the place next mentioned, to which the two prophets traveled on foot. We may view them in imagination walking and communing on this long journey, the last they would ever take in this sinful world, the close of ten years’ of constant, happy association,—the master and his disciple, servant, and successor. How much we would like to learn of the particulars of that association that day! Doubtless farewell instructions were given and important suggestions made. They would likely discourse of the expected event about to take place. Elisha would closely catch every word uttered by Elijah. The translation from earth to heaven would be a joyful close to Elijah’s life of care and perplexity. He had once before “requested for himself that he might die.” Now he was to be the second recorded example of being taken alive into the presence of his God, whom he had served so faithfully. But to Elisha, who was to be left behind, the expected event would be sad. The burdens and responsibilities would now drop upon him. The one to whom he had looked for counsel and direction would be no more with him. The master would encourage, no doubt, the devoted disciple all he could.

At last they came to Jericho, the first city on the west side of Jordan which the Israelites captured under Joshua. Here God wrought a wonderful miracle after the people had marched around it seven days in succession. The walls all fell down flat, overturned by angelic hands. The city had lain desolate for centuries, but had been recently rebuilt. It lay some five miles distant from the river Jordan. It was afterward a famous city. King Herod died in it, and it is often mentioned in the New Testament.

The two prophets did not tarry at this place, but pushed on and came to the Jordan, which opened a passage to them when Elijah struck it with his sheep-skin mantle. There they stood. Fifty of the “sons of the prophets” viewed from a high point “afar off,” the two prophets, to see what would happen.

“And it came to pass, when they were gone over, that Elijah said unto Elisha, Ask what I shall do for thee, before I be taken away from thee. And Elisha said, I pray thee, let a double portion of thy spirit be upon me. And he said, Thou hast asked a hard thing: nevertheless, if thou see me when I am taken from thee, it shall be so unto thee; but if not, it shall not be so. And it came to pass, as they still went on, and talked, that, behold, there appeared a chariot of fire, and horses of fire, and parted them both asunder; and Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven. And Elisha saw it, and he cried, My father, my father, the chariot of Israel, and the horsemen thereof! And he saw him no more.” 2 Kings 2:9-12. And so this grand life of earthly effort for God and his people closed. Like Enoch of old, “He was not, for God took him.” No earthly pencil can picture adequately such a scene as that. The heavenly chariot and steeds of fire—what can poor mortals grasp of their nature and appearance? Who can pass judgment upon the nature of that change which instantaneously took place in the man Elijah? The record says, “Elijah went up by a whirlwind into heaven.” He did not drop the mortal body, though he did his mantle; but that body, changed, glorified, made immortal like unto the angels, went up in the fiery chariot. There is something real, tangible, about this scene. And it is of surprising interest to us, since he is a type of the living when Christ shall come. Just as literally will they be caught up; yea, and the dead saints in their graves, with their real bodies. They will not be dissipated into mist, vapor, or attenuated nothingness, but will be real bodies just as Enoch’s, Elijah’s and Christ’s were, glorified and made immortal like theirs.

And so Elijah passed into heaven without tasting death,—a grand fact demonstrating the real nature of the reward promised to the faithful. Shall we, dear reader, ever take passage upward in those fiery chariots? Shall we meet this grand old patriarch, and hear him speak of his life in glory through all these thousands of years now past? May this indeed be our happy privilege. We will speak hereafter of other circumstances mentioned in the record. G. I. B.

(To be continued.)