AdventAI

GROUNDLESS ANSWERS.

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 45., November 18, 1890

WE are requested to notice briefly the following question and answer, which appeared in the Zion’s Watchman of Oct. 4.

Question.— What grounds have we for observing the first instead of the seventh day of the week as the Sabbath? W. A. KIRLEY.

Answer.— We have many times answered this question. We presume those who ask the question from time to time have not seen the former answers. To our present inquirer we answer that Jesus is Lord of the Sabbath also. While there is no explicit command in regard to the law of the Sabbath, we cannot suppose that he who came to fulfill all law would suffer his apostles and the pentecostal church to commence a work of saving the world by breaking one of his commandments. A house divided against itself must fall. The work of redemption is a greater work than that of creation. And as creation was commemorated by a Sabbath of rest, so it is eminently proper the work of redemption should have a memorial day.

If the observance of the first day of the week was a violation of the commandment of the Sabbath, how are we to account for the Holy Spirit striking Ananias and Sapphira dead for the violation of the commandment in regard to covetousness, while the violators of the former were spared? We do not put this forward as an argument in favor of the first day of the week, but simply to show that a sin so general against the law of the Sabbath would not have escaped the judgments of God.

1. Yes; Jesus is Lord of the Sabbath. But the Sabbath is the seventh day, and not the first. Jesus never claimed he was Lord of Sunday.

2. While there is no explicit command in regard to the law of the Sabbath, and no need of one, there is an explicit command in regard to the Sabbath. It reads, “Remember the Sabbath day, to keep it holy. . . . The seventh day is the Sabbath.”

3. Christ had no occasion to suffer his apostles and the pentecostal church to commence the work of saving the world by breaking one of his commandments, for they began their work in no such way. There is no Bible proof whatever that they either disregarded the Sabbath of the fourth commandment, or observed Sunday as a sabbath.

4. The work of redemption is a work of creation.—a manifestation of God’s creative power. God in the beginning created man in his own image, a moral being, pure, innocent, and upright. Man fell. By redemption God restores him to his primeval condition of innocence and rectitude. But it requires almighty power to do this. It is nothing less than a work of creation. Thus Paul speaks of “the new man, which is renewed in knowledge after the image of him that created him;” of the brethren as God’s “workmanship, created in Christ Jesus,” “created in righteousness.” Who, then, has authority to say this is more than creation? How can it be said to be greater than creation, when it is a creation, a work requiring creative power, itself?

5. God himself ordained a memorial day in honor of creation, and had it been so “eminently proper” that redemption should have one, he no doubt would have ordained one in honor of that; but the fact that he has not, is good reason for believing it is not so proper, and places those who have instituted and are upholding one, in the light of attempting to instruct the Almighty. It may be well also, in this connection, to bear in mind the fact that redemption, the work of re-creation, is not yet completed. With the apostle Peter, “we, according to his promise, [still] look for new heavens and a new earth,” and with Paul are “waiting for the adoption, to wit, the redemption of our body,” and “the redemption of the purchased possession.”

6. What is said about Ananias and Sapphira is wholly gratuitous. It is based upon the assumption that the Christians in the days of the apostles generally disregarded the Sabbath of the fourth commandment and observed the first day of the week in its stead, which should be proved before it is made the basis of an argument. It is, has been, and ever will be, nothing more than an assumption.

With these observations we dismiss the matter.

W. A. C.