ETERNAL LIFE

5%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Sep 16, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 36.

Read the full edition

ETERNAL LIFE.

The editor of the Evangelical Messenger, Cleveland, Ohio, has been freeing his mind on this subject. This is all right. Those who think they have light should let that light shine. But if the light that is in them turns out to be darkness, their efforts are not so valuable as they would otherwise be.
In the very opening of his article, traces of the misapprehension under which he labors are distinctly visible. He says:—
“Seventh-day Adventists or Millerites, Berean Baptists, and other small sects teach the doctrine of conditional immortality. They assert that when our first parents fell into sin, the race lost the attribute of immortality, and that very day the human spirit became mortal.”
We, of course, can speak only for S. D. Adventists; but in their behalf we must correct the foregoing misstatement of their views. We do not teach that in “that very day the human spirit became mortal.” There is an old dogma, springing from a not very creditable source (Gen. 3:4), which has been so thoroughly taught in the religious world, both pagan and Christian, that, like blood-poisoning, it has become thoroughly diffused through the whole “body theologic,” and tends to becloud and confuse the mind almost hopelessly on the great question of the nature and the destiny of man; and that is, that something about man called “soul” and “spirit” is an independent entity, a man within a man, one mortal, the other immortal, a dual being, two parts, to be treated of separately, and separately disposed of. It is impossible to engineer such a being through all the fields of Scripture testimony, and keep everything consistent and harmonious; for the Bible treats man as a unit, and finds no place for the imaginary part which a wrong theology has brought in.
Man is represented as a unit when created, an indivisible whole. He was not complete, not alive, till all had been brought together. His body was made of the dust. Into that body God breathed the breath of life, not a separate being, nor anything immortal, for all fowl, cattle, beast, and creeping thing have the same (Gen. 7:21, 22); and then man became a living soul, not the recipient of a soul then implanted; he was himself the living soul, the result of God’s creative work. There was no part of him then immortal which “became mortal” when he sinned. But the whole man then passed under the sentence of death, which, had not the plan of redemption through Christ supervened, with him would have ended all. We would be glad to dwell more at length upon this branch of the subject; but limitations of time and space forbid, and we pass to another of the Messenger’s assertions:—
“The advocates of conditional immortality point with special emphasis to the fact that the Scriptures nowhere directly teach or assert the inherent immortality of the human soul. This is true. Neither do the Scriptures categorically assert the existence of God; but does that form a valid argument in favor of atheism?”
The article then goes on to assert that the immortality of the soul is assumed or taken for granted, and that the existence of God is also assumed in the Scriptures, and draws at considerable length a parallel between these supposed facts. We congratulate the editor of the Messenger on his confession of this great truth that “the Scriptures nowhere directly teach or assert the inherent immortality of the human soul.” His assertion that the Scriptures take it for granted that the soul is immortal, has not in it one syllable of truth; and his assertion that the Scriptures do not assert the existence of God, but take that for granted in the same way, is simply astonishing. “In the beginning God created the heaven and the earth.” “I am that I am.” “He that cometh to God must believe that he is.” Gen. 1:1; Ex. 3:14; Heb. 11:6; etc. Do not a multitude of such texts clearly enough assert the existence of God?
But we suspect our friend did not mean merely the existence of God, but his endless existence or immortality. Granted that this is his meaning, his argument is equally lame; for the Scriptures do expressly assert the immortality of God: “Now unto the King eternal, immortal, invisible,” etc. 1 Tim. 1:17. “The blessed and only Potentate, the King of kings and Lord of lords; who only hath immortality.” Chap. 6:15, 16. Find us one text which says that when we speak of the soul we “must believe” that it is immortal, or one which affirms that it is “immortal” or has “immortality,” and it is enough. But no such text can be found. It is a very easy way to try to get over this by saying that it is taken for granted; but it is fatally defective; for so far from assuming the immortality of the soul, the Bible expressly denies it. It says that God only has immortality, and then positively affirms that “the soul that sinneth, it shall die.” Eze. 18:20. If men would cease “assuming” so much, and go by “the law and the testimony,” there would be in the theological world, if not more truth, certainly a great deal less error.
But our author thinks the immortality of the soul must be assumed (since it is not revealed) as otherwise “the plan of salvation as revealed in the Bible, is without reason.” “The inherent value of the soul,” he says, “is derived chiefly from its immortality. ‘Take that away,’ he continues, ‘and upon what ground is it worth saving at all, especially at such infinite cost? The cross of Christ is the irrefutable proof of human immortality.’”
We cannot understand such reasoning. The great prize set before the world through Christ is immortality; and Paul says that those who by patient continuance in well doing seek for it, will obtain it. Rom. 2:7. Those who do not seek for it, will not obtain it. That we might obtain this, Christ died. And so we read: “For God so loved the world, that he gave his only begotten Son, that whosoever believeth in him should not perish, but have everlasting life.” John 3:16. And when Christ came to his own and they received him not, he uttered this lamentation: “Ye will not come to me, that ye might have life.” Chap. 5:40. The value of man is, not that he is by nature immortal, but that he may become immortal; and without the sacrifice of Christ he would inevitably lose this precious boon.
Another assertion is this: “Death, never means the opposite of existence, but the termination of life.” Not to be captious over the use of the word “existence,” we can say that this is all we claim. Death terminates life; but it is through life that conscious ness exists, and all the physical, mental, and moral powers are exercised. These all terminate in death.
“The dead know not anything.” Eccl. 9:5. (That which knows in life does not know anything in death.) They have no knowledge or wisdom, plan no device, and do no work. Verse 10. Their thoughts have perished. Ps. 146:4. As conscious, intelligent beings (not as matter) they cease to exist. Such is death. And when at last the wicked, Satan himself and all his followers, experience in the lake of fire, the second death (Rev. 20:14), all these functions of life with them will cease forever.
He quotes 1 Cor. 15:22: “As in Adam all die, even so in Christ shall all be made alive,” and says, “The advocates of conditional immortality have much trouble with this passage.” Not a bit of it. This is one of the plainest and simplest passages in all the Scriptures. Through the sin of Adam the sentence of death passed upon the whole human race, and all, high and low, rich and poor, the gray-haired sinner and the innocent babe, alike suffer it. And had not the plan of redemption through Christ supervened, this would have been the sum of their existence. But this plan gave Adam another chance, and all his posterity a chance for themselves, independent of Adam’s sin. It will be seen at once that to carry this out, all must be released from the death they now die in Adam, that their own deeds may come into account, and they be judged for them. Thus as in Adam all, irrespective of character, die, so in Christ all, irrespective of character, are made alive, or are raised from the dead. This much is done in general for the whole family of man, by the plan of redemption, just as the sacrifice is provided for all. And to this alone such passages as Rom. 5:18, 19, apply. Then all men being placed beyond the physical results of Adam’s transgression, stand upon their own merits, are judged by their own actions; and their destiny is determined by their own characters—those who are Christ’s pass into life eternal; while those who would not have him to reign over them (Luke 19:27), would not come to him that they might have life, pass into the second death and perish. Thus all is easy, natural, consistent, and just.
He says: “Extinction or absorption in Nirvana is paganism, not Christianity.” It might be perhaps, if we applied it to the righteous; but we do not, for the Bible does not. And the wicked are not absorbed back into Nirvana, but destroyed.
On “the breath of life,” he quotes Dr. Rankin as saying; “And this breath of life, this breath of God, can no man tame, can no man cabin, crib, or confine. It is the very life of God.” Let our friends go a little slow here: for, as we have seen (Gen. 7:21, 22), all beasts, birds, and creeping things have this breath of life. We think it will stagger them a little to have to confess that every bug and beetle has in it “the very life of God.”
With one reference to his remarks on eternal life, we close. He says: “Eternal life means more than continued conscious, sentient existence. We have that without Christ—in hell. (See Luke 16:23, and Rev. 14:11.)” How can any student of the Bible possibly speak in this way, when John says explicitly: “And this is the record, that God hath given to us eternal life, and this life is [not now in us, but] in his Son. He that hath the Son hath life; and he that hath not the Son of God hath not life.” 1 John 5:11, 12. Yet the editor of the Messenger, either carelessly or audaciously, affirms that we do have life (conscious, sentient existence) without Christ—in hell. Either he or John has not told the truth; but we prefer to side with John. His testimony is not to be nullified by Luke 16:19–31, which is merely a parable and not a literal narration; nor by Rev. 14:11, which is a figure borrowed from Isa. 34:6–10, where it is applied to Idumea, a portion of this earth. It outrages all logic to mash the figures of the Bible into its literal language. Let all figures be interpreted by the literal, not the literal by the figures.
He then endeavors to justify his remark by saying, “But eternal life means perfect life.” In this he would convey the impression that what is meant by “eternal,” is “perfection.” But this is not true. “Eternal” refers to duration only, not to character. The life eternal will, of course, be a perfect life; it will be a holy, happy life; but these characteristics are not expressed by the word “eternal.” That refers to the length of the life only; and any life (conscious existence), be it happy or wretched, in heaven or hell, that continues forever, is eternal life. No quibbling can hide or dislodge this fact. But such a life the Bible says the wicked do not have. And we believe its testimony.
O that men would clear their minds of the fog of pagan mythology and Romish corruptions and superstitions, and take the pure testimony of God’s word on these questions of eternal interest!