AdventAI

AN OPEN LETTER.

By C. P. Whitford

From Review and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 33., August 26, 1890

BY C. P. WHITFORD.

(Moultrie, Fla.)

Dear Friend: In reply to my letter of recent date, you say, “Seventh-day Adventists are advocating unscriptural, absurd, and dangerous doctrines.” Then you proceed to tell us what those “dangerous doctrines” are. To use your own language, you say, “They are building on the law and not on Christ for salvation.” You then try to make it appear that they belittle the work of Christ, and virtually say he is not a full and complete Saviour. You express the greatest surprise that those who professedly take Christ as their Saviour, should keep the law as an assurance of their salvation. Then you admit that they do “professedly” accept of Christ as their Saviour. Thank you, my friend, for this admission.

I am most happy to inform you that Seventh-day Adventists ever have believed, and taught as widely as their facilities would allow, that the only hope of a future life lies in the fact that Jesus Christ came into the world to save sinners. They recognize no name through whom salvation can be obtained, save the name of Jesus. They believe that “God sent not his Son into the world to condemn the world; but that the world through him might be saved.” They believe and teach as strongly and earnestly as they know how, that “whosoever believeth in him shall not perish, but have everlasting life.”

How, then, did you come to entertain the idea that the Seventh-day Adventists “build their hopes of salvation on the keeping of the law, and not on Christ”? Surely you have never found such an “unscriptural, absurd, and dangerous doctrine” taught in any of their writings. I have been connected with this people twenty-two years, and have been associated with a number of their leading representative men, laboring in new fields; and I can say of a truth, I have yet to hear one word uttered even hinting in the direction that they expect to be saved through the keeping of the law.

Why is it, then, that Seventh-day Adventists are so shamefully misrepresented, both in public and private, on this question? Does it come about by that theology which declares that we are not “under the law,” but “under grace”? If to be under grace will allow individuals to willfully bear false witness against their neighbors, then the language of my heart would be, “Deliver me, dear Lord, from being ‘under grace.’”

You exhort me earnestly to turn away from the law, and have nothing more to do with it. After reading this exhortation, I opened my Bible, and turned to Prov. 28: 4, and there read as follows: “They that forsake the law praise the wicked.” I thought, Surely, it would not be well-pleasing to God for me to “praise the wicked.” How, then, can I “forsake the law”? Again I read, “But such as keep the law contend with them.” During my twenty-two years’ experience as a Seventh-day Adventist, I have met with opposition all the way along. What has been the matter? Am I not a Christian? Do I not love God? Do I not accept of Christ as my Saviour? Why, then, should I be exhorted to “turn away from the law,” especially when we hear Solomon saying, “He that turneth away his ear from hearing the law, even his prayer shall be abomination”? Surely no worse fate could befall any man than that God should turn with loathing from his entreaty. Again we hear the wise man saying, “He that keepeth the law, happy is he.” And why is the man who is loyal to the government of heaven happy? The answer may be found in Matt. 19: 17 and Rev. 22: 14.

You quote the words of Paul: “For by the deeds of the law shall no flesh be justified.” You think Paul teaches by this language that it is not needful that we obey the law. But his words convey no such thought. He simply states a fact; viz., that justification does not come through the keeping of the law, and nobody believes that it does. Justification comes through Christ, but nothing that Christ has ever done releases us from obligation to keep his Father’s law.

I have yet to learn where Paul, by word or example, gave license to disregard the law of God. On the contrary, I hear him saying, “The law is holy, and the commandment holy, and just, and good.” What is it good for if it is not to be obeyed? Solomon tells us that to fear God and keep his commandments is the whole duty of man. David says, “The law of the Lord is perfect, converting the soul.” Ps. 19: 7. John says the keeping of the law is the test of our love to God. 1 John 5: 3. James says, “For whosoever shall keep the whole law, and yet offend in one point, he is guilty of all.” James 2: 10.

It could not be otherwise; for since God is the author of the whole law, we dishonor him if we do not render obedience to the whole law. If we willfully refuse to keep one of the commandments, we show that we do not keep the other nine out of any special regard to the Law-giver, but because it is convenient or for our selfish interest to do so. We do therefore dishonor God by violating one of his commandments as truly as though we violated them all. I am well aware that the natural heart is not inclined to love the law of God or to obey its requirements. Paul says the natural heart is not subject to the law of God, neither indeed can be. But genuine faith in Christ converts the heart, works a change in its attitude toward the law, until it can say, as did Paul, “I delight in the law of God.” I would that I might hear you saying as did Paul, “For I delight in the law of God,” and exclaiming with David, “Great peace have they which love thy law.”

The individual who manifests enmity toward the law, has not submitted to the converting power of God. Did you ever consider that it is the keeping of the commandments which proves the sincerity of the professions of our love? John, the beloved disciple, says so. Here are his words: “This is the love of God, that we keep his commandments.” 1 John 5: 3. Says Jesus, “Not every one that saith unto me, Lord, Lord, shall enter into the kingdom of heaven; but he that doeth the will of my Father whichp. 516 is in heaven.” Matt. 7: 21. God’s will is most emphatically expressed in his law. Says the apostle, “Be ye doers of the word, and not hearers only, deceiving your own selves.” It is the doing, then, which testifies to the saving qualities of our faith. The law of God is the great standard of righteousness, and it will measure every man’s profession. It is a mirror which discovers the defects in our characters, and shows us the requirements of God. It is holy and just and good. Says the Saviour, “Blessed are they that do his [the Father’s] commandments, that they may have right to the tree of life, and may enter in through the gates into the city.”

My friend, there are many declarations of a similar character, all through the Bible. Did you ever stop to consider them? If not, I hope you will do so now. Please consider another fact; viz., that the transgression of the law cost the death of God’s dear Son. He died that you and I might live eternally in his kingdom. “Whosoever believeth in him shall not perish, but have everlasting life.”

Yes, you say, and that is the reason why we have nothing more to do with that law. Will you give me your candid and prayerful attention while I try to show you the mistake under which you are laboring? John says, “Sin is the transgression of the law.” 1 John 3: 4. Paul makes the same statement in another form: “For where no law is, there is no transgression.” (Rom. 4: 15); and, “Sin is not imputed when there is no law.” Rom. 5: 13.

The law was broken by our first parents. It condemned them unto death. “The wages of sin is death.” They were sinners because they had broken the law. “Sin is the transgression of the law.” The wages of their transgression was death. There was no salvation for them in the law. There is nothing in the nature of law, either human or divine, to justify the transgressor. It always condemns. What shall be done to save lost man? How shall he escape from his prison-house, the grave? A plan of salvation was instituted by God and Christ in heaven. Christ consented to take upon himself man’s nature, and come to this dark world where sin had entered, and suffer temptation, be crucified, and go down into the grave just as low as man had gone. And what was all this condescension on the part of Christ for?—It was to satisfy the demands of the law for past offenses, and not, as is commonly supposed, for future acts of disobedience. Now man is once more free from that law. How did he obtain his freedom?—Through Christ. Christ, then, has now become man’s Saviour in that he has freed him from the bondage which the law held over him in death. The law could not save the transgressor, but the Son of God could, and he did.

Please notice another fact, viz., could that law which condemned our first parents to death have been set aside, and thus they have become free, it need not have cost the death of Christ to accomplish this work. If such a thing could have been possible, don’t you think God would have chosen to abolish his law, rather than permit his only Son to die to redeem man? To this question, I am quite sure you will answer most emphatically, Yes. Then can you not see that the law of God is still binding? Is it not plain that the death of Christ proves most conclusively the perpetuity of God’s law? The death of Christ in no way affected the law. It only changed the relation sustained between the law and its transgressors. Before the death of Christ, the law held Adam and Eve as its lawful subjects; but by virtue of the death of Christ, the law is satisfied, and man is free—not free to go on transgressing it in all time to come, but free from past offenses and their consequence; viz., death.

Let us suppose a case: Here is a man twenty-five years of age. He has been an open, willful transgressor of God’s law all these years. He now decides to renounce his sinful practices, obey the law of God, and thus become a Christian. Suppose he should reason in this way: Yes, I know I have broken the law of God, and consequently am a sinner; but I will hereafter keep the law so perfectly that all my past sins will be forgotten. Would anybody be foolish enough to believe he could do it? Would not every one say to the man, Why, it was your duty to be faithful to God all those twenty-five years that you were living in open rebellion to his law, and hence no future acts of obedience can atone for past transgressions? You cannot keep the law so perfectly in the future as to make up for the deficiencies of the past. What, then, must the poor man do?—Go to God, confessing his sins, seeking forgiveness through Christ, and God for Christ’s sake forgives the man of his transgressions. The Saviour has undertaken to atone for past sins, but not for future acts of disobedience. By the death of Christ the law was satisfied, and man set free. If we again transgress the law, we are brought just where we were before; viz., under the law. When we obtain pardon through Christ, then we are no more under the law but under grace, or in other words, in favor with God. I hear John saying, “If any man sin, we have an advocate with the Father, Jesus Christ the righteous.” Yes, Jesus is our advocate, and not our lawgiver, as you suppose. He advocates our cause with the Father because we are in trouble with the Father, having broken his law. He pleads his blood shed upon Calvary, for you and for me. I accept of this Jesus as my Saviour,—a full and perfect Saviour, too; and I in no way belittle his work by keeping the Father’s law. Thus do we hang our hopes of salvation upon Christ, and thus do we show that he came not to save men in their sins, but from their sins. Those who have genuine faith in the Son of God, will manifest by their lives of devotion, integrity, and loyalty to the law of God, the character of Christ’s mission and work. He gave himself for us that he might redeem us from all iniquity, and purify unto himself a peculiar people, zealous of good works. Many do not desire the inconvenience of denying self, or taking up the warfare against besetting sins, and of correcting the defects which mar their characters. They have persuaded themselves that Christ has relieved them from the duty of purifying themselves, even as he is pure.

Believe, only believe, is the burden of their instructions. Only believe, is echoed by thousands who catch upon the words parrot-fashion, and repeat them with no sense of their importance or significance. The apostle Paul realized what his words meant when he said, “For I am determined not to know anything among you, save Jesus Christ, and him crucified.” He knew that it meant the surrender of every power of his being to the service of God. It meant an entire renouncing of the world, the flesh, and the Devil. It meant that he must follow in the blood-stained path of the Man of Calvary, and walk even as he walked.

But how different is the faith which is presented to the world to-day, as essential to salvation. It has no vitality, no reality. It does not unite the believers as branches, to Christ, the living Vine. It is not the faith which works by love and purifies the soul. It is a formal, nominal acceptance of a popular story, and has about as much efficacy as the faith that accepted Abraham Lincoln as a good administrator of governmental affairs. Genuine faith will show definite results in the character of its possessor, and will exert a controlling influence over the thoughts of his heart, and the affairs of his life. It will lead its possessor to practice the principles laid down in God’s holy law.

And now, my friend, I must close this lengthy letter. I trust you will better understand the true relation of the law and the gospel, and never again charge upon Seventh-day Adventists that they “build their hopes of salvation upon the law, and not on Christ.” And wherever you have so taught, may it be not only a duty, but a privilege to correct false impressions. May God bless you in all your investigations, and may we at last meet and greet each other in the soon-coming kingdom, shall ever be my sincere wish and earnest prayer.