AdventAI

A TROUBLESOME QUESTION.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 7., February 17, 1891

The Sabbath was appointed by the Lord as a day of rest. To those who observe it, it is a rest, a blessing, a delight, and a joy. To those who will not keep it, it seems to be the greatest element of disturbance they have to wrestle with. This is the only conclusion that can be drawn from the continual stream of articles, tracts, pamphlets, and books, which is poured forth from the religious press, upon the country, to meet the “seventh-day heresy.”

A correspondent calls our attention to an article on the Sabbath question, in a first-day Adventist paper of Minneapolis, Minn., with a request that we publish it and answer it. We have not space for the article, nor for any extended answer, all the positions taken having many times been canvassed in the REVIEW. We will, however, state the views presented in a series of numbered propositions, with all the reply that is necessary to each.

1. “We observe the first day of the week because ‘the Son of man is Lord of the Sabbath.’”

By the Sabbath, of which he is Lord, our Saviour referred to the seventh day; and so they say that because he is Lord of the seventh day, they will keep the first day. This is a fair specimen of their reasoning, and affords a good idea of the dimensions of their logic.

2. “We do not know that our Saturday is the true seventh day.”

We do; for Christ, when on earth, knew which was the true seventh day, and kept it as the Sabbath; and there has been no confusion in chronology from that day to this.

3. “The observance of the Sabbath is not mentioned in the Bible, till Exodus 16.”

It is. Gen. 2:3 says that God sanctified the seventh day. “Sanctify” means to set apart to a religious use. The fourth commandment (Ex. 20:11) says this day was the “Sabbath day,” when thus sanctified. Gen. 2:3 is therefore the record of a Sabbath law, and that Adam kept it. Christ says, “The Sabbath was made for man.”

4. “The day was changed at the exode.”

This is one of the silliest claims ever set up. There is not a particle of any evidence of a change there.

5. “The day was fixed for the Israelites in the wilderness by the fall of the manna.”

The fall of the manna had nothing to do with fixing the day of the Sabbath. The “sixth day” of Ex. 16:5, 22, was the sixth day of the week, not the sixth day after the manna began to fall.

6. “The Israelites were on their journey the seventh day before the day they were told to keep as the Sabbath in Exodus 16; hence that was not the Sabbath; and therefore the Sabbath was there changed.”

Wholly an assumption. It is not known how long it was after they came into the wilderness of Sin (Ex. 16:1) before the manna began to fall.

7. “The Saturday Sabbath was a constituent part of the old covenant.”

It was no part of the old covenant. The moral law of God is the foundation of both covenants, but no part of those covenants, any more than the Constitution of the United States is a part of every State constitution or municipal law which is founded thereon.

8. “The disciples were taught to observe the first day by the Lord’s example in meeting with them on that day, and on no other of which the name is mentioned.”

There is only one first day mentioned in connection with Christ’s resurrection, and the forty days he remained with his disciples, before he ascended; and that was the day of his resurrection; and that had to be mentioned in making known the event of the resurrection. But on that day he only met with a few of the disciples individually. There is no evidence that he ever met with them once collectively on that day. The meeting of John 20:19, was when the evening had come; and the evening introduced a new day. This meeting was the same as that of Mark 16:14; but this was not until the two disciples had returned from Emmaus (verse 12, 13; Luke 24:13); and the day was “far spent,” or almost to its close, when they were at Emmaus, seven and a half miles away from Jerusalem. That first day was ended before they got back to Jerusalem to report to the eleven; and it was on the second day of the week, therefore, when Christ first met with his disciples collectively. How much “example” there is in this for keeping the first day as a Sabbath, when the disciples did not believe he was risen (Mark 16:14), and he gave them not one word of instruction in regard to the day, any sensible and candid reader can judge.

9. “Cannot the work of creation be commemorated on the first day of the week?”

No, sir; no more than when one’s birthday falls on Monday, he can celebrate it on the following Thursday.

10. “It is highly proper that we remember Christ’s finished redemptive work.”

But Christ’s redemptive work is not yet finished, and will not be till all his children are redeemed and placed in possession of the kingdom.

11. “Although there is no record of a positive command, we are not to infer that he [Christ] gave no instructions about the Sabbath. We would rather suppose he did.”

By this the writer means Sunday, of course, but we have just as much reason to “infer” that he also gave instruction about Good Friday and holy Thursday as about Sunday; so let us adopt the whole list of Romish festivals, and make a complete thing of it.

12. “His [Christ’s] instructions are exemplified for us in the recorded practice of the New Testament church, and in the teaching of its apostolic writers.”

Very good; but there is not the first recorded instance in which the New Testament church ever paid any attention whatever to the first day of the week, as a day of rest and worship, nor the first syllable of instruction from any apostolic writer, for them to do so.

And so endeth the Sunday chapter.