THE AMERICAN SABBATH UNION NOT UNITED

3%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Dec 23, 1890

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 67, No. 50.

Read the full edition

THE AMERICAN SABBATH UNION NOT UNITED.

A Stormy Meeting of the Friends of Sunday Laws.
Last week there appeared in the Review a report of the second annual session of the National Religious Liberty Association, which was held in Battle Creek, Mich., Dec. 4-7, 1890. About the same time, the second annual session of the American Sabbath Union was being held in Philadelphia. As the two organizations occupy somewhat the same field, though governed by an antithesis of principles, and formed for what may be interpreted as opposite ends,—one standing for religious freedom, the other for religious enslavement,—they very naturally are associated together, and consequently a report this week of the annual session of the latter organization may not be without interest to our readers. We accordingly present some matter we have in hand.
The American Sabbath Union, as doubtless most of our readers are aware, was organized in New York, in Colonel Elliott F. Shepard’s parlor, Dec. 8 and 9, 1888, at which time Mr. Shepard was chosen president, which position he has held ever since. Mr. Crafts, however, was the originator of the Union, and though not made chief executive of it, was given, for the first year, the honorable position of Field Secretary. Some difficulty, it appears, arose during the year, between Mr. Crafts and the Union, and as a result the office of Field Secretary was abolished at the first annual session held a year ago, Mr. Crafts being appointed to a more humble position. This he refused to accept, and severed all official connection with the Union, starting out in the work in which he had engaged the previous year (that of lecturing), upon his own responsibility. Strange to say, he, however, continued to organize local unions under the general Union. His relation to the Sabbath Union is thus expressed in his own words, in the Christian Statesman of Nov. 26, 1890:—
“Although not at present an officer of the Union, but an independent lecturer working for its auxiliaries in various districts, States, and cities, I am greatly interested, as founder of the Union, that it should not be confounded by any mistakes, but rather perfected.”
From this it may be inferred that Mr. Crafts was not satisfied with the past management of the Union, and that he had some expectations of becoming an officer of it again. That these inferences are well grounded, we present the following from the Philadelphia Call of Dec. 10, 1890, from which the reader may gain some idea of how mellifluously things passed off at the last annual meeting of the American Sabbath Union:—
“Crafts—Shepard—Origin of Their Differences Explained by Philadelphians—The Breeze in the American Sabbath Union Over President Shepard’s Election—His Resignation Will Not be Accepted if Offered.
“When Rev. Wilbur F. Crafts reached into the meeting of the American Sabbath Union, and, with no gentle grasp, hauled out by the neck the dove-like spirit of harmony, he started a little difficulty which has injured the aforesaid dove-like spirit pretty severely.
“Not only are its plumes disarranged and its tail dragged, but its pinions also have been so vigorously twisted in the fray, that they are as yet unable to flap together in the peaceful benison so essential to a really and truly Sabbath union.”

MR. CRAFTS’S CHARGES.

“Rev. Mr. Crafts, in a circular, declared last evening that Colonel Elliott F. Shepard, editor of the New York Mail and Express, and President of the Union, had used the organization to boom his paper; that he had employed Tammany methods to secure the re-election that was accorded him late yesterday afternoon, and that the Union in the South was going to the everlasting canines because of the prominent part played by the colonel in all the proceedings.
“Notwithstanding Mr. Crafts’s charges, and the gallant manner in which he led the opposing forces in the meeting yesterday afternoon, Colonel Shepard scored an unquestionable victory. He departed for New York, in his private car, early this morning.
“The interest in the strife continues strong to-day in religious circles, although conqueror and conquered have alike dispersed to their respective homes. At the offices of the Philadelphia Sabbath Union, which seems to be stanch in the support of Colonel Shepard, Mr. Crafts’s record was given in a spirit of candor modified by a yearning toward the merciful.
“There were present in the office to-day, Rev. T. A. Fernley, D. D., the corresponding secretary of the local union, and Rev. J. H. Knowles, D. D., of New York. It was the latter who was accused by Mr. Crafts, of successfully electioneering for Colonel Shepard. Dr. Fernley made the statements regarding Mr. Crafts, and Dr. Knowles softened them with the waters of Christian charity.”

MR. CRAFTS’S MOTIVES.

“‘I will outline this whole matter,’ observed Dr. Fernley. ‘Mr. Crafts, who is not a D. D., was Field Secretary for the General Union a couple of years ago. When the Field Secretaryship was abolished, he was elected Secretary of Publications, and made Secretary also of the Third District, which includes Virginia, West Virginia, North Carolina, and the District of Columbia. His office was in Washington.
“‘He got into trouble with the Seventh-day Adventists out West, and in their official organ they gave him the lie. Mr. Crafts, over his signature as Secretary of the Sabbath Union, gave them as good as they sent. Now, the Sabbath Union is not opposed to the Adventists, and it declined to support him. It resolved to enforce the rule that everything printed in its name should be first approved by the Committee on Publication.’
“‘But,’ interjected Dr. Knowles, tempering the wind of critical history, ‘the committee was not appointed as a reflection on Mr. Crafts.’
“‘Oh, no; not in the least,’ Dr. Fernley assented. ‘But the Union refused to support him, so he resigned. The fight yesterday was over the question whether the government of the Union should remain in New York or go out West. Mr. Crafts joined forces with the Westerners, and led them on.’”
“‘How about the charges he makes that Colonel Shepard is making a good thing out of the printing, in the Mail and Express, of the organ of the Union, the Pearl of Days?’”

IT WAS A KINDNESS.

“‘The Colonel,’ responded Dr. Fernley, ‘undertook it as a kindness to the Union two years ago. The Pearl of Days occupies one column of the Mail and Express every Friday, which is sent to subscribers for $2.00 a year.’”
“‘Did he not bring over a number of supporters from New York in order to insure his election?’
“‘He merely proffered these gentlemen the hospitality of his private car. Wouldn’t you do it?’
“The reporter agreed to do so as soon as he became the possessor of the private car.
“‘And as for Dr. Knowles’s trying to pack the meeting in Colonel Shepard’s favor,’ concluded Dr. Fernley, ‘you see what he is—a thorough Christian gentleman.’”
“‘President Shepard declared his intention of resigning; has he done so?’
“‘No, sir; and if he does, it won’t be accepted. The managers want him, to a man.’”
“‘How will this affect Philadelphia?’
“‘Not at all. We will go on just as good as ever. Some might think this little family squabble would knock us into a cocked hat. But it won’t. Philadelphia is conservative, and is pledged to support neither the West nor the East.’”
Mr. Crafts had been laboring in the Western States,—California, Iowa, and others,—during the past season, organizing auxiliary unions for the purpose, it seems, of having a large number of delegates present who would be likely to support him, and thus enable him to get control of the Union. This appears to have been his plan, and accounts for his laboring for the Union while holding no official connection with it. But those in charge of affairs, to forestall this, appear to have appointed the meeting early in the week, in order to prevent the delegates from the West from attending, unless they traveled on Sunday, which, of course, Mr. Crafts had taught them not to do. Consequently, his supporters were in the minority, and he was ingloriously defeated. To make this result sure, Mr. Shepard ran his special car to the meeting, and thus brought along a number of his friends. Both men, it seems, endeavored to “pack the meeting” in their own interests.
Under such circumstances, it is not so surprising that a stormy time should be experienced, and unpleasant developments occur. A letter received from an individual who was present at the meeting, says:—
“The New York men secured the incorporation of the Union sometime in November, and had themselves proposed some amendments to the constitution, which they had printed; and had also selected their Board of Managers. This cut-and-dried program was all forced upon the Philadelphia meeting, much to the chagrin of Mr. Crafts and his friends. I never in my life saw more disorder in a meeting, or heard more cutting remarks than were made there. It seems that while there was no split so far as the organization was concerned, the Union is seriously divided, not upon principles, for they all seem to agree perfectly in the demand for Sunday laws, but upon the question of management. The West, and especially Western Pennsylvania, is very jealous of New York, and it seems to me that the coming year will not be a prosperous one for the American Sabbath Union.”
It thus appears from an abundance of evidence, that the second annual session of the American Sabbath Union was not one notable for its union and harmony. On the contrary, it seems that there was manifested a large degree of that spirit which in the early centuries characterized the aspirants after papal supremacy. And why not, when these men are engaged in a papal scheme to uphold a papal institution—the enforcement of Sunday observance by law! Why should not the stormy scenes of some of those early church councils be repeated, and the rôle of the fourth century be played over again? Like the prelates of those times, they demand laws for the protection and better observance of Sunday, but they are not agreed as to who shall be “head of the church.” Is it the bishop of Rome, the bishop of Alexandria, or the bishop of Constantinople? Is it Crafts or Col. Shepard?
In view of these proceedings and the methods employed by those men, the best we can say of the men is, that they remind us of two young popes. We think of the sorry day it will be for this country when such men wield the scepter of power.
As to the prosperity of the American Sabbath Union for the coming year, we cannot say; but of the ultimate success of the iniquitous scheme couched in it, we have not the slightest doubt. It will as surely succeed as it is sure that through the same means the papacy has cast her dark shadow over the nations of the earth. And we present these facts not only to show that the institutions and methods of this religio-political movement are the same as those in the fourth century, when Church and State were united, but to show that it is also characterized by the same ambitious spirit of self-exaltation which finally developed into that proud and wicked hierarchical system known as the papacy. Let the unwary beware. W. A. C.