Under the direction of, and in accordance with, the advice of the Conference committee, I went to Worthington to defend the truth from the attacks of a Disciple minister from Ruthven, Iowa. We held a twelve nights’ discussion on the Sabbath, law, and Sunday questions. Almost his whole argument was a verbatim rehash of positions taken by certain opposers of our views. It would take too much space to give even an outline of the arguments pro and con, so I will mention only a few points:—
The Lord’s day of Rev. 1:10 was his stronghold for Sunday sacredness. He relied upon the fathers of the Catholic Church that Sunday is the Lord’s day. We replied that the fathers are unreliable. Dr. Adam Clarke said: “Their authority with me is nothing.” Luther said: “To explain the Scriptures by the fathers, is like straining milk through a coal sack.” Alexander Campbell testified: “Nop. 125 buffoonery that passed through a monk’s brain, but that can be proved by the fathers.” Dr. Dobbs testifies that “a man can find anything he wants in the fathers;” and that “the fathers are Heaven’s best gift to the man that has a cause to sustain and no other way to sustain it.” Bower says: “We should treat tradition as a notorious and known liar.”
Our brother knows all this, and yet he goes to tradition—a notorious liar—to prove Sunday sacredness. Why?—Because Sunday sacredness is a cheat and a fraud, and only lying testimony can be found to sustain it. He does not believe the fathers himself. The same fathers upon whom he relies to teach Sunday sacredness, teach also the sacrifice of the mass. Does he believe that?—No; he says that it is a popish lie, and nothing else. They also teach offerings for the dead, infant baptism, the sign of the cross, etc. He says the fathers lie when they teach these things, and he says truly. How, then, does he know they tell the truth when they speak for Sunday? He does not know it. Witnesses that tell so many lies cannot be trusted, especially in matters that pertain to our salvation.
Again: it was nearly 200 years after Christ, before even one witness can be found to call the Sunday the Lord’s day; and that is by no means certain. His name was Tertullian. He classes Sunday observance with making offerings for the dead, and the sign of the cross, and says, “If you ask for Scripture injunction for these rules, you will find none. It will be told you, Tradition is their originator, custom their strengthener, and faith their observer.” So even according to his own witness, he has nothing more than tradition for Sunday observance; and Christ calls those hypocrites who reject God’s commandment that they may keep their own tradition. Our brother stands in that case exactly. He rejects God’s fourth commandment that he may keep a Catholic tradition. Tertullian seems to be his chief reliance to prove Sunday sacredness. Let us hear him again: “We devote the day [Sunday] partly to mirth and recreation, and not to devotion altogether.” What does recreation mean?—It means fishing on Sunday; for fishing is recreation; so also is hunting, dancing, and base-ball. Our brother must not find fault with boys when they thus take a little recreation on Sunday; for that is the way they kept Sunday holy (?) in Tertullian’s day.
This was too much for him, and he cried out, “Did Tertullian say base-ball?”—He said recreation, and hunting, fishing, dancing, and base-ball are recreation. Our brother could find nothing in the Scriptures to prove Sunday sacredness, and so he appealed to the fathers, and found that Sunday was partly devoted to mirth and recreation. Queer sacredness this! Even his own witness testifies against him. His argument on the word Kuriakee was that that being a new word, it must refer to a new institution. We answered by saying that new terms were used in reference to God and to Christ, but that does not prove we have a new God or a new Saviour. We showed that Kurios, the word from which Kuriakee was derived, is used with reference to both the Father and the Son; also it was used with reference to the Sabbath, but never with reference to Sunday. In Matt. 12: 8 Christ claims to be Lord (Kurios) of the Sabbath day. He never claimed to be Lord (Kurios) of the first day of the week. Again, we showed that when the four Gospels were written, the new term “Lord’s day” was not applied to the first day of the week. In the year A. D. 59, Luke says the meeting at Troas occurred on the first day of the week. Evidently he knew nothing of the new term that should be applied to Sunday. Also Paul, in 1 Corinthians 16, uses the same old term, “first day of the week.” It is evident that up to that time, A. D. 59, he had no knowledge whatever of this new term (Lord’s day) that should be applied to Sunday.
John wrote his gospel about two years after he wrote the Revelation, and yet called Sunday simply “first day of the week.” How is this, if the Spirit of God had directed him to call it by the new name of “Lord’s day”? Surely this new term for Sunday is a myth and nothing more. The Scriptures do not leave us in doubt as to which is the Lord’s day. The fourth commandment says, “The seventh day is the Sabbath of the Lord thy God.” God calls the Sabbath, “My holy day.” Isa. 58: 13. Christ says he is “Lord even of the Sabbath day.” Matt. 12: 8. John says he was in the Spirit on the Lord’s day. Then which day is the Lord’s day according to the Scriptures? There can be but one answer—The Sabbath is the Lord’s day.
In his efforts to prove the ten commandments were abolished, he was especially unfortunate. He admitted that nine of them were moral precepts that could not be done away. It was uphill work for him to show that the ten commandments were the old covenant, and were done away, because nine of them, he said, could not be done away. When he came to cast out the ten commandments as the bondwoman of Galatians 4, nine tenths of the old lady absolutely, according to his own showing, could not be cast out. And also on the ministration of death he had great trouble. Here, he says, is proof positive that the ten commandments are abolished. But yet he says nine of them are moral precepts, that can never be abolished or done away. The ministration of death is done away. He says that nine of the ten commandments cannot be done away; therefore, according to his own showing, the ten commandments cannot be the ministration of death.
In the discussion, it was clearly demonstrated that there is no unity among the advocates of Sunday sacredness. Our Disciple brother did not hesitate to repudiate the standard writers of his own denomination, when they did not agree with him. A rather amusing incident in this line was his repudiation of Vogel. We claimed that the fifty-sixth chapter of Isaiah refers to the gospel age, and, consequently, to both Jew and Gentile. He immediately took strong ground that it refers to the Jews and the Jewish age only; whereupon we read from Vogel, in his discussion with Waggoner, that Isa. 56: 1-8 refers to the gospel age, and includes both Jew and Gentile. He immediately repudiated Vogel, and cried out, “Who brought Peter Vogel into this discussion?” We thought best to enlighten him upon that point, so we showed that every argument he had advanced thus far in the discussion, was taken verbatim from Peter Vogel, even his little catch-words which he used so glibly; such as, “My brother’s man of straw,” “He will find in me a friend that sticketh closer than a brother,” and “Now I will proceed to give my brother’s argument a decent burial,” etc., which were read to him and the audience from Vogel. We showed that if Vogel was taken from his argument thus far, there would not be enough left to be visible to the naked eye. Yet he cried out, “Who brought Peter Vogel into this discussion?” Surely a man must be in a tight place to repudiate his own father! Without doubt, Peter Vogel was father to his argument on the Sabbath question.
He had great difficulty in proving Sunday sacredness. He could not tell when, where, nor how the Sunday was made sacred. He could find no sacred title whatever applied to it in the Scriptures, neither could he find where Christ, priest, prophet, or apostle observed it as a sacred day. He could find where a half pagan, half Catholic emperor commanded it to be observed by the townspeople, under the title of “The venerable day of the sun.” He could find where the pope put his blessing and sanctification upon it, where it was commanded and enforced by earthly governments and potentates, but nothing more. It is solely an institution of man, resting entirely upon the teachings and commandments of men; and Christ says, “In vain they do worship me, teaching for doctrines the commandments of men.” We urged him to show some divine reason for Sunday sacredness, but he could not find it. We called for the divine command for Sunday-keeping, but he failed to give it. We asked how he could prove it is a sin to work on Sunday, and he said, “By apostolic example;” but he entirely failed to find the example. Again, sin is not the transgression of an example; “sin is the transgression of the law” (1 John 3: 4), and “sin is not imputed when there is no law.” Rom. 5: 13. As there is no law against Sunday labor or recreation, there is no sin in laboring or recreating on that day. He could find no divine blessing for Sunday-keeping, neither could he find one divine word of displeasure against working on Sunday.
How different with the Sabbath. It comes to us with the highest sanctions known to Deity. God rested on the Sabbath. God blessed and sanctified the Sabbath. God commanded the Sabbath to be kept holy. God promises the greatest blessings upon those who will keep the Sabbath, and he threatens those who will not keep it. The patriarchs and prophets kept it. Christ kept it. The apostles kept it. The early church kept it till more than 300 years after Christ; and it will be kept by the remnant church of Rev. 14: 12, and also by the redeemed in the new earth. Isa. 66: 22, 23. It comes to us with the signature of Almighty God, while the Sunday has upon it the image and superscription of man. Let the people choose whom they will serve.
I understand that two young ladies took a stand for the truth during the discussion, and others acknowledged they were convinced of the truth; and all the brethren at Winona say that the discussion strengthened them in the faith.
W. B. HILL.