BY W. A. MC CUTCHEN.
(Peoria, Texas.)
It would seem to be a strange freak of the human mind to say that there had ever been a time when any of God’s created intelligences were not amenable to his moral law. To talk about moral beings not being subject to moral law is self-contradictory, and yet that is just what those people do who argue that the law was only given for, and binding upon, the Jews under the old covenant.
But let us examine this question a moment. Aside from the positive declarations of Scripture which show this theory to be erroneous, one can scarcely begin to reason on the subject without coming to the same conclusion. Let us see. “Sin is the transgression of the law” (1 John 3:4); hence those who transgress it are sinners. Christ came to call sinners to repentance. Mark 2:17. He did call the Gentiles. Therefore the Gentiles were sinners before Christ’s advent into the world. But as just stated, sinners are transgressors of the law. Only those can transgress a law who are amenable to it. “Where no law is, there is no transgression.” Rom. 4:15. Even where law exists, none except those who are amenable to it can transgress it. While citizens of the United States, we can neither obey nor break the laws of England, because we are not under their jurisdiction. But we can easily violate our own laws, and where we do it we are condemned by them. And the very fact that the law takes hold of us when we break it, shows that we are amenable to it. So it is and ever has been with God’s law. The fact that the Gentiles were sinners, or transgressors of the law, when Christ came, proves conclusively that they were amenable to that law whose transgression made them sinners; for they could not transgress a law to which they were not amenable. Putting the foregoing into the form of syllogisms, we have the following:—
Major: Christ “came not to call the righteous, but sinners to repentance.” Mark 2:17.
Minor: Gentiles were thus called.
Conclusion: Therefore the Gentiles were sinners.
But,—
Major: Sinners are transgressors of the law. 1 John 3:4.
Minor: Only those who are amenable to the law can transgress it.
Conclusion: Therefore the Gentiles, being sinners, or transgressors of the law, were amenable to the law.
From the foregoing reasoning it is seen that this conclusion is unavoidable. But we are not left to reason alone on this subject. The word of God speaks here; and where it speaks, let man be silent. Two or three passages as corroborative testimony will suffice. Paul, speaking of the condition of the Gentiles as compared with that of the Jews, in Romans 3, says in verse 9: “What then, are we better than they [the Jews]? No, in no wise; for we have before proved both Jews and Gentiles, that they are all under sin.” And how are people “proved” to be under sin?—“By the law is the knowledge of sin” (verse 20), and its transgression is sin, or brings under sin. Hence it was the transgression of the law that proved them sinners. But they could not be convicted of sin by a law which had no jurisdiction over them, and which they could not break. It follows, therefore, that they were and are amenable to God’s holy law. Consider, too, that the same thing is said of both the Jew and the Gentile. What is said of the one is said also of the other. So that if the law was over the Jew, and showed him to be a sinner, it was also over the Gentile, and showed him to be the same.
Verse 19 of this same chapter is also to the point here. It says: “Now we know that what things soever the law saith, it saith to them who are under the law: that every mouth may be stopped, and all the world may become guilty before God.”
These scriptures are absolutely decisive on this question. “Every mouth” and “all the world” certainly included the Gentiles under the old covenant; for “what things soever the law saith,” it said then, as well as now. Indeed, antinomians hold that that is the only time the law has ever said anything; for, according to their view, it has been dead ever since we came under the new covenant.
But if what the law did say was to the Gentiles as well as to the Jews, as shown by its stopping “every mouth” and condemning, or making guilty, “all the world,” cannot any one see that it did not pertain to, nor concern the Jews alone? And since it was not Jewish in its origin or jurisdiction, does it not follow inevitably that it did not pass away with the Jews—did not cease to be binding when the Jews ceased to be God’s peculiar people? If it was binding upon Gentiles while the Jews were God’s chosen people, certainly it is now, as can be abundantly proved, since the national distinction—“the middle wall of partition”—is broken down, and all are placed on a common level.
Let it ever be borne in mind, then, that there was nothing Jewish about the law. True, the Jews were made the custodians of God’s holy law for awhile, because they, as the children of Abraham, “the father of the faithful,” had maintained the worship of the true God, while all other nations had gone off into idolatry. This is the only reason why this honored distinction was conferred upon them. But because the law was formally delivered to them, that no more makes it Jewish than the formal delivery of a message from some great, wealthy philanthropist to the mayor of a city, who might be a German, would make that a German message or a German gift conveyed by the message. No, the gift is to the city, the whole people, but is delivered through the mayor.p. 20
So God’s law was for the whole world, extending over every moral creature, and was as broad as his moral government, though formally delivered to man through the Jews, for the reason stated above; and it ought not to be difficult for any one to see that God has had one great moral rule for all nations, running through all the ages from the beginning to the present; and one grand purpose in view; namely, to take out from among the nations of earth “a people for his name,” to inhabit the eternal regions of bliss which he has in reservation for the “faithful.” And this very word “faithful” suggests loyalty to God, and obedience to his law. The saved will have been persons of that kind. And certainly the Lord could not have one rule to govern one nation or generation, and something else for another. No, all are to be judged by the same rule, and that is God’s holy law. James 2:1–12; Rom. 2:12. May the Lord help us so to live, and to keep his law through the help of Christ, that it may not condemn us, but that it may stand as a witness of the “righteousness of God which is by faith of Jesus Christ.” Rom. 3:20–23.