THE LAW UNTIL JOHN

13%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 13, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 2.

Read the full edition

THE LAW UNTIL JOHN

Ans.—The statement in Chronicles is the most formal and minute statement we have on the subject, and would naturally, therefore, be assumed to be the correct statement. This makes David to be the seventh son of Jesse; and 1 Sam. 16:11 asserts that David was the youngest; and therefore Jesse had but seven sons. How, then, does it happen that the passages in Samuel ascribe to Jesse eight sons? The difficulty might easily arise from 1 Sam. 16:10: “Again, Jesse made seven of his sons to pass before Samuel.” The letter used in the Hebrew for the number six, is ו, vau; that for seven, is ז, zayin. The latter might, by a little careless copying, be mistaken for the former, making it read that Jesse “made seven of his sons to pass before Samuel,” whereas it should read, “Jesse made six of his sons to pass before Samuel.” Then David, the youngest, mentioned in the next verse, would make the seven. The error of seven instead of six being established in verse 10, of chapter 16, of course the 12th verse of the next chapter would be made to conform to it, attributing eight sons to Jesse instead of seven. It is therefore suggested in “Barrett’s Synopsis of Criticism,” that the word “seven” in 1 Sam. 16:10 is a wrong reading; that it should be “six”; and that 1 Sam. 17:12 should accordingly read “seven” instead of “eight.” This would make the statements in Samuel correspond to that in Chronicles, and seems the most plausible solution of the discrepancy.

THE LAW UNTIL JOHN.

Please give through the REVIEW an explanation of Luke 16:16. First-day Adventists try to use it to prove that the law of God has been done away.
G. N. C.
Ans.—The text reads: “The law and the prophets were until John: since that time the kingdom of God is preached, and every man presseth into it.” Opponents of the law seem to find it very convenient to stop with verse 16. Why do they not read the next verse, which is on the same subject? “And it is easier for heaven and earth to pass, than one tittle of the law to fail.” The word “fail” here means “to become null and void.” The easier of two things will, of course, take place first. Therefore the heaven and the earth will pass away before a single tittle of the law will become null and void. But the heaven and the earth have not yet passed away; hence the law in every jot and tittle is still in force.
This much they could learn, were they so disposed, from verse 17. But the verse before (verse 16) does not contain the first particle of proof of what they want to find in it. The verb “were,” it will be seen, is supplied. The only verb expressed in the text is the verb “is preached.” This, therefore, is the verb to be used in both members of the sentence. Leaving out the supplied word, we have: “The law and the prophets, until John; since that time the kingdom of God is preached.” In the first member of this sentence a verb is, of course, to be supplied. What verb shall it be?—There can be just one without doing violence to the construction of the sentence, and that is the verb which is already expressed in the second member of the sentence; namely, the verb “is preached.” We must put it in the past tense and plural form to correspond to the rest of the sentence; and then we have: “The law and the prophets were preached until John; since that time the kingdom of God is preached.” Now, what does the text assert?—Simply this: that until John the people had the preaching of the law and the prophets only: but that since that time they have the preaching of the kingdom of God in addition to that of the law and the prophets. This must be so; for even our opponents will not claim that the prophets (either prophets themselves or the fulfilments of prophecy) ceased when John appeared; for some of the most important prophecies have been fulfilling since John’s day; and the most important of all (for us) are yet future. If the text spoke of the law only, our friends could make a little better showing; but “the prophets” spoil their argument. And then, as if for the very purpose of anticipating their objection to the law. Christ virtually says in the very next verse: “But I would have you understand that heaven and earth will pass away before one tittle of the law will become null and void.”
There is still another particular in which those who argue for the abolition of the law are glaringly inconsistent on this passage. They take their stand at John, and proclaim the law done away there, because they think they can use this text to prove it. Then almost immediately they will pass right down to Christ, and claim that the law was done away in him, and nailed to the cross. But the law has not been done away twice. If it was done away when John appeared, it was not done away by Christ on the cross. But if it was done away by Christ on the cross, it was not done away at the time of John, and they must give up Luke 16:16. Time and again we have pressed them to decide which point they would take, but have never been able to induce them to commit themselves. Now we advise any Sabbath-keeper who has this class of persons to meet, to give them no quarter whatever on this point. Force them to take one position or the other, as they are in all consistency bound to do. If they take John, they must give up the cross; and if they take the cross, they must give up John. In either case they must surrender half of their position; which ought to convince them that they occupy unscriptural ground.