Speculations as to the Papacy.
The advanced age of the pope, now nearly eighty-one, and the precarious condition of his health, are again bringing the question of the papal succession up for discussion, and especially by the Roman Catholics of Europe. While no cardinal is singled out by general consent as particularly eligible to the papacy, the consensus of progressive opinion in the church is that the next pontiff should be a man of practicable and modern ideas, and that relief should be found from the existing predominance of Italian influence in the Vatican. It is felt that the present strained relations between the Vatican and the Quirinal cannot be maintained forever; that the continued refusal of the papacy to accept the benefits and conditions of the law of guarantees, and the reiterated demands for the restoration of temporal power, must end in a situation dangerous, if not destructive, to the interests of the church. The present pontiff, it is urged, has done little to bring the papacy into accord with the new order in Europe, and especially in Italy; for although a far more astute statesman than his predecessor, Pius IX., the concessions gained in his contests with secular governments, have been yielded at the demand of the people rather than of himself. The abrogation by the Prussian Government of the Falk laws, for example, under which the appointment of priests and bishops was made subject to the approval of the State, was a concession to the feeling of the Roman Catholics of Prussia that their religious freedom was unwarrantably interfered with, and not to the pope either as sovereign or pontiff. In no way, indeed, has the pope proved modern or practicable, regarding himself, as did his predecessor, as the prisoner of the Vatican, and in his letters to the bishops and clergy contravening the whole spirit of the age by insisting that the source of power is not the people, but God as expressed through the church. Logically, of course, no power can exist save through the pope as the head of the church, the old claim of the papacy, opposed to all progress and the cause of constant interference on the part of the church with secular government everywhere. Whether, however, the attitude of the progressive element of the church in the premises is due most to a true perception of the situation or to personal ambitions and international jealousies cannot now be known, though the deep concern taken in the discussion in France and Italy indicates that it is not wholly disinterested. The French church is more independent than any other branch, owing, doubtless, to the strong national sentiment existing, and the fact that a large political group would like to see it severed wholly from Rome, and has, moreover, a greater number of cardinals than any other nationality save Italy. Naturally the French church desires the next pontiff to be a Frenchman, presumably Cardinal Lavigerie, the archbishop of Carthage, whose anti-slavery crusade has brought him into prominence, though the hostility of Italy to such a succession is well-nigh certain to defeat it. Indeed, it is stated that the Italian Government is endeavoring to demonstrate to the remaining members of the Triple Alliance, that in view of the hostile spirit which exists in Paris and the Vatican, they should use their influence to prevent the election of a pontiff unfavorable to official Italy and favorable to France. In view of these antagonisms, it is suggested that an American or an Englishman be chosen, though the probability is that the next conclave will be a repetition of that of 1878, and that the foreign and the more moderate of the Roman and Italian cardinals will combine for the election of a moderate and conciliatory pope. But it is useless to hope that any one that may be chosen will be able to free himself to any appreciable extent from Italian influence, the present pontiff being one of the ablest of Italians, and yet practically powerless to cope with it.—Interior, Feb. 5, 1891.