As briefly stated last week, this trial is in the past. To those of our brethren who are familiar with the early history of the case, it will be remembered that Bro. King was indicted in his county court, for quietly plowing corn on a retired part of his farm, on Sunday, and was fined $75.00 and costs for his offense.
By the advice and help of the National Religious Liberty Association, of which Bro. King is a member, he appealed his case to the Supreme Court of the State, which affirmed the decision of the lower court.
On the refusal of Bro. King to pay the fine assessed, he was placed in jail, but was released on a writ of habeas corpus, which was made returnable in the United States District Court at Memphis, Tenn., the second Monday in January, 1891. In the meantime, the Religious Liberty Association secured the services of Hon. Don M. Dickinson, of Detroit, Mich., to assist in the case, with the design of carrying it, if possible, to the Supreme Court of the United States, there to test the constitutionality of Sunday laws in the various States of the Union.
Monday, at 10 A. M., the day for which the trial was set, Bro. King and his counsel were in the court room ready to have the trial proceed, when it was found that the State’s attorney was not present, neither had the writ in the case been returned. Judge Hammond asked what should be done in the case, when Mr. Dickinson replied that the defendant did not wish to embarrass the court by pressing the case, and was therefore willing to have it continued. The case was then put off till Tuesday at 10 A. M., and in the meantime telegrams were sent to the governor of the State and the State’s attorney, notifying them that the case was being held for their appearance.
When the case was called again, Tuesday morning, the counsel for the prosecution was still absent. Mr. Dickinson again stated that in order to show due courtesy to the State, he would consent to another day’s delay. The case was called a third time, on Wednesday morning, when the judge stated that now it must proceed, as all the courtesy due the State had already been extended. The judge then called upon counsel for the defense to proceed with the case as he thought best, when the sheriff appointed a Mr. Collier, an eminent lawyer of that State, to represent the prosecution. The Protestant Pastors’ Association then employed Judge Smith to assist Mr. Collier, thus securing as strong a combination as possible under the circumstances, in favor of the prosecution.
The first step in the proceeding was a presentation by Col. T. E. Richardson, of the records of the case in both the county and supreme courts. These revealed the grounds on which the defendant was brought into the case, and also the inflammatory speech of the State’s attorney, by which he evidently influenced the jury to find a verdict against Bro. King in his first trial. The acceptance of this evidence by the court was, of course, greatly in favor of the defendant. Mr. Dickinson occupied the entirep. 60 afternoon of that day and the forenoon of the next in an eloquent and learned argument, wherein he clearly showed from the Fourteenth Amendment to the United States Constitution, that Bro. King had been unlawfully restrained of his liberty. This was followed with speeches by counsel for the State, and Col. Richardson closed the argument.
The Memphis Scimitar, referring to this effort, said:—
Those who remained to hear the closing speech of Col. T. E. Richardson, of Dyersburg, were handsomely rewarded. It was a magnificent rhetorical effort, and the gentleman, in fiery eloquence, knowledge and skillful handling of his subject, with his power of vituperation and ridicule, exceeded in effect on his hearers that of Hon. Don M. Dickinson, though that gentleman’s argument was in a different line, and was more of an exposition and application of the law and the authorities rather than an attempt at eloquence.
Prefacing his remarks with the statement that he was himself a Christian, and an observer of the Christian Sabbath, but yet a contender for Religious Liberty, he attacked the intolerance existing in his own camp, so to speak, thereby strengthening his cause. He did not confine himself to the question of whether or not his client had been convicted under due process of law, but in the most learned manner branched off into a general disquisition on Sabbath laws and religious intolerance, and showed a vast amount of research and information on the subject. He went back to the days when Christianity was in its infancy, quoted the early Christian fathers in support of the theory that the seventh day was observed as the Sabbath for centuries after the birth of Christ, showed how the first day was adopted and became the Sabbath, fixed by law in the reign of the first Christian emperor and renegade, Constantine, and defied any one to produce the slightest divine authority for the innovation. It was true, he said, that the majority of Christians had accepted it, but there remained sects, such as the Adventists, who chose to accept the teachings of the word as their guide in preference to the laws of man, however sanctioned by time and custom. To deprive these people of their right of conscience was an outrage, a violation of the Constitution of the United States, and particularly of Tennessee, in which State during the unprecedented religious revival in the early part of the century, what was known as “sectarian equality” was so earnestly contested for.
The speech of Col. Richardson was a surprise to those who did not know his abilities, and was warmly complimented.
The judge reserved his decision in the case, but it will probably be given to the world in a few days. This will be awaited with much anxiety, as it will doubtless have great effect on the operation of Sunday laws everywhere in the United States. The case has, therefore, justly excited much interest throughout the country. Judge Hammond said frequently during the trial, that it was an exceedingly important one. The people and press were friendly to the defense all the way through. A note from Col. Richardson, dated Jan. 17, says: “I am sanguine of a decision in our favor. In that case I feel confident that the Protestant Pastors’ Association will, in case the State fails to do so, take the case to the Supreme Court.” We hope to be able to announce the decision of the court next week. J. O. C.