SLIGHTLY INCORRECT

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Jan 27, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 4.

Read the full edition

SLIGHTLY INCORRECT.

We cheerfully give place to the following communication from the editor of The Truth Seeker, which will explain itself. The paragraph about Ingersoll appeared in so many periodicals that its origin could not be determined, and we, consequently, published it without credit. But we do not wish to be a party to giving currency to any statements which do not have a solid basis of fact to rest upon:—
Editor Advent Review and Herald:—
I find the following in your journal of Jan. 13:—
“All of Ingersoll’s predictions are likely to be as far astray as the one referred to in the following. Rev. Dr. McCabe, Missionary Secretary of the Methodist Episcopal Church in the United States, sent him the following message a few days ago:—
“Ten years ago you made the following prediction: ‘Ten years from this time two theaters will be built for one church.’ The time is up. The Methodists are now building four churches every day—one every six hours. Please venture upon another prediction for the year 1900.”
About all the religious papers I have seen have printed the foregoing alleged message to Colonel Ingersoll, but none that I have seen has had the manly honesty to print the letter Colonel Ingersoll wrote to the Chicago Inter-Ocean about the message, as follows:—
“A clipping was shown me to-day from your paper, in which it is stated:—
“1. That ten years ago I made a prediction that ten years from that time two theaters would be built for one church; and—
“2. That Chaplain McCabe had written me a letter calling my attention to the prediction, and stating that the Methodists were building four churches a day.
“There are two mistakes in this article: first, I never made the prediction; and, second, I never received any letter from Chaplain McCabe on the subject. With these exceptions the article is correct.
“R. G. INGERSOLL.”
I hope your journal will be more honest than the journals of the other Christian sects have been.
Of course you will at once perceive that your own remark upon the alleged prediction is pointless.
Yours truly,
E. M. McDONALD,
Editor of The Truth Seeker.
28 Lafayette Place, New York.