AdventAI

ST. MATTHIAS'S, PLYMOUTH.

By James Buss

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 1., January 6, 1891

Sir: Having some years since attended a service at St. Matthias’s, during a visit to the “great naval port of the West,” I have naturally been interested and grieved to read in your recent issue of changes in the direction of Rome, which seem to have been made during the present year.

I should be surprised if the substitution of a service of ritual for one of gospel preaching had not led to discord among the good people of St. Matthias’s; and, as is shown by the letter of “Sidesman,” the cause of the disunion and discord is to be placed at the door of those who have brought in the elements of suspicion, among which I may specially mention “Hymns Ancient and Modern.”

As “Sidesman” jubilantly says in his epistle of almost a column’s length, that though “the Rev. James Ormiston’s tract (Church Association series, No. 21, I presume) has been supplied to some members of the congregation, it has not prevented a hearty adoption and appreciation of ‘Hymns Ancient and Modern,’ I am led to think that this gentleman either knows nothing of the contents of that mischievous book; or, if he does, that he must have become thoroughly inoculated with the poison therein contained, and as a result would now move heaven and earth to clear out the bone and sinew of churchmen from St. Matthias’s, so that the Neos of less solid substance may have untrammeled sway thereat. But will the veterans of that church submit to have everything of a Protestant character obliterated, even though the advocates for such effacement be championed by such an one as “Sidesman”?

In conclusion, I will venture to assert that when the people realize the heresies which this hymnal sets forth as Church of England doctrines, they will throw it from them as a book steeped with loathsome and soul-destroying poison. These are,—

  1. Baptismal regeneration.
  2. That the communion-table is wrongfully termed altar.
  3. That the praise due to Christ is given to apostles and martyrs.
  4. That fasting and works are put in place of penitence and faith.
  5. That prayers for the dead are sanctioned.
  6. That Scripture is perverted.
  7. That additions are made to Scripture.
  8. That the Virgin Mary is unduly exalted.
  9. That the wood of the cross is invoked.
  10. That the thorns, nails, and lance are also impiously invoked.
  11. That the Real Presence in the Lord’s supper is taught.
  12. That the doctrine of transubstantiation is enforced.
  13. That the consequent Sacrifice of the Mass and,—
  14. Adoration of elements follow.

—James Buss, in English Paper.