AdventAI

ORIGIN AND HISTORY OF THE THIRD ANGEL'S MESSAGE—NO. 5.

By John Norton Loughborough

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 1., January 6, 1891

The tenth day of the seventh month, Jewish time (Oct. 22), 1844, had been set by processes of reasoning already described, as the day for the Lord to come. To that day attention had been turned, as it had not probably to any other day in all the world's chronology. Thousands had centered all their hopes upon it. The principle of interpretation adopted by the Adventists had shown itself to be true in other points; and so, it was argued, it must in this. And accordingly by thousands upon thousands every calculation and provision for continuance of life in this world after that date, was absolutely discarded; and both Church and world, in breathless anxiety, awaited the result.

When the time passed and the Lord did not come, the disappointment which fell upon the Adventists was more crushing than any that ever fell upon any other people. It was as much greater than that of the first disciples (Luke 19:37–40; 24:21), as the issue supposed to be involved in this, was greater than the one involved in that. They supposed that Christ was to set up a kingdom and reign as temporal king; these expected the kingdom of God in all its glory, and eternal life therein. The sudden collapse of their hopes was a disappointment beyond description—almost beyond endurance. Add to this the sarcastic shout of triumph which went up from the world, and the bitter reproaches of the enemies of their faith, and they felt that indeed the dregs of a full cup were wrung out to them.

And now appears the inherent power and vitality of the truth. Was not this enough to cause every one to give it all up at once, and renounce the whole movement? So some thought, and gave it up; but with multitudes of others it was not so. They had seen enough evidence of the workings of the Holy Spirit in connection with the movement, to know that the providence of the Lord God of Enoch and Elijah had been leading the way; that it was a work in which Heaven was interested; and it could not be given up. Sometime and some how they believed that all would be made plain.

They were right. God had led in the work. His Spirit had enlightened the minds of his servants to bring out rich truth from his word. Their principles of interpretation were sound; their reckoning and application of the prophetic periods, incontrovertible; and their view of the symbols of Daniel 2, 7, 8, and 9, and Revelation 2, 3, 6, 8, 9, 12, and 17, were substantially correct. The sanctuary of Dan. 8:14, the second symbol of Revelation 13, and the third message of Revelation 14 were reserved for further light, which to those who in a proper frame of mind waited for it, was not long in coming.

This second and greatest disappointment threw them back upon the study of the types with more earnestness than ever. The types seemed to be the only avenue left through which to look for an explanation of the situation. In The Voice of Truth of Nov. 7, 1844, Joseph Marsh said: “We cannot admit that our great High-priest did not on that very day [the tenth day of the seventh month] accomplish all that the type would justify us to expect. We now believe he did.”

Naturally, almost of necessity, the Adventists of that time came to the conclusion that their work for the world was done. Whether they felt so or not, it was, for the time being, virtually the fact. First they knew not in what way to try to work further for the world; and, secondly, every heart was steeled and every ear closed to whatever they might try to do for them. They had but to submit to circumstances. Naturally enough they looked for some scriptures applying to the situation.

They had recognized the parable of Matt. 25:1–13, as applying to the Advent movement in which they had been engaged; and in that parable they found a time when the bridegroom came and the door was shut. They began to see that the coming in that parable, was to the marriage; and the marriage was something to take place in heaven, not here on the earth. So as they had had the midnight cry, “Behold, the bridegroom cometh; go ye out to meet him,” they began to reason, Has not the bridegroom come to the marriage, and is not the door shut?

Soon Mr. O. R. L. Crozier brought out additional light on the subject of the sanctuary; namely, that the sanctuary was in heaven, and the cleansing of the sanctuary was the entrance of the High-priest into the most holy place, to make the atonement; but that while he was thus making the atonement, the door of the outer apartment was closed. And so the conclusion suggested by Joseph Marsh, that all had taken place which they were warranted from the type to expect, was confirmed; that is, that the bridegroom had come to the marriage,—that Christ, our great High-priest had entered into the most holy place to make the atonement and cleanse the sanctuary, which in a few days or weeks, at most, they supposed would be finished, and then the Lord would come for his people. And all this, it was thought, involved the idea that the door of mercy was closed.

But notwithstanding the error of the shut door, which under their circumstances it would have been difficult to avoid, a mighty stride had been made in the direction of further light, and toward a solution of their perplexing situation. The truth had fully dawned that there was a work to be done in heaven before the Lord would return to this earth; that the sanctuary was in heaven, and was to be cleansed there; that the cleansing of the sanctuary was the removing of sin by the blood of Christ, and not the burning of the earth in the fires of the last day; that the bridegroom had come to the marriage; and that the cleansing of the sanctuary was going forward.

In the midst of this evolution of new views, a few weeks after the passing of the time, and while many were making shipwreck of faith, sister White had her first vision. In it she was shown that “the midnight cry,” which they had just passed through, was a great light set up behind them, and was not to be rejected; that if kept in view, it would shed light on the pathway clear through to the end; but if rashly denied, darkness and ruin to such souls would follow. Now says the objector, “The visions taught the shut door, because the shut-door view was connected with that of the midnight cry; and the vision taught that the midnight cry was not to be given up.” The conclusion does not follow. It is a false charge. The vision said nothing about the shut door. But the midnight cry was a vital pillar of truth, and was not to be surrendered, though some errors had been connected with it. To give up the midnight cry was to give up the whole work, and make utter shipwreck of faith. And any candid reader can judge whether it were better to give up that truth on account of an error which men had attached to it, and so wholly apostatize, rather than hold fast to the truth, and wait patiently till the Lord should remove the error which men had connected with it. Every one will say the latter. And this they did; and the explanation and correction came in due time.