AdventAI

“WHAT IT IS, WE DO NOT KNOW.”

By W. A. C.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 11., March 17, 1891

Spiritualism appears to be attracting notable attention just now. That such individuals as Edward Everett Hale, of Boston, widely known as an author and preacher; Dr. Heber Newton, of All Souls Episcopal Church, New York; Rev. Edward A. Horton, of the Second Congregational Church, Boston; Rev. Minot J. Savage and Rev. T. Earnest Allen, noted Unitarian divines of Boston and Providence, R. I.; B. O. Flower, editor of the Boston Arena; and Mrs. Mary A. Livermore, well known as an advocate of women’s rights and other modern reforms, should enter into arrangements, sign a call, and issue a prospectus for the investigation of Modern Spiritualism, is significant. It shows that while Spiritualism has been considered by many as a thing of no importance, consisting simply of charlatanism and chicanery, there is still, in spite of all this, that about it which, to thinking, investigative minds, is not explainable in this way.

That Spiritualism has been gradually and stealthily gaining adherents among church-members, is, no doubt, one incentive which prompts to this proposed investigation. In the prospectus issued, the signers of the call for the formation of a “Psychic Investigation Association,” as it is called, say: “That Modern Spiritualism has votaries in all parts of our country, and that it has the power to influence the thought and action of those who believe its teachings, are indisputable facts.” But the fact that some of these individuals have themselves been having something to do with Spiritualism, and in their meddling have met with phenomena which they cannot explain, is undoubtedly a still stronger incentive for prying into this mysterious ism. While some may be like Mr. Horton, who says, “I am perfectly ignorant of so-called spiritualistic manifestations,” others are not thus ignorant. Rev. Minot J. Savage, in the Boston Globe of Feb. 11, says:—

“I have been quietly investigating psychic phenomena for the past fifteen years, . . . and here is what staggers me, I have been told things which neither the medium nor myself knew or could by any possibility have known. If there is any other theory than the spiritualistic one to explain facts of this sort, I don’t know what it is. I can’t explain certain experiences of this sort, except on the theory that I am dealing with some invisible intelligences.”

Rev. Mr. Allen, writing to the Banner of Light of Feb. 28, concerning the investigation, says:—

“The spiritualistic hypothesis seems to be the most natural explanation of experiences which I have had.”

It is worthy of note, however, that all are in a quandary as to what Spiritualism really is. None appear to have firmly fixed views upon the subject. The very fact of calling for the formation of an association to investigate it would, of course, indicate this. The Rev. Heber Newton, in the New York Herald of Feb. 10, well states the case when he says: “What it is, we do not know.” Like the puppies in the picture, standing around the tortoise, wondering who the strange visitor is that has recently arrived, these men appear curious and confused over the revival of ancient sorcery under the name of Modern Spiritualism. In the prospectus sent out, they ask, “Is the movement founded upon fact or delusion?”

And how do these gentlemen propose to obtain an answer to this question?—It is by “a scientific investigation of Spiritualism.” They hope to “exhaustively investigate Spiritualism” upon “the scientific method.” We sincerely hope that in some way they may arrive at the truth of the matter, and be led to see Spiritualism as it is. But why is it that such men, who profess to believe the word of God, when asked to “seek unto them that have familiar spirits, and unto wizards that peep and that mutter,”—why is it that they do not go “to the law and to the testimony”? Why is it that in “trying the spirits,” they do not rely on the sure word of prophecy? Why do they not read, and when they read believe, what the Spirit has spoken expressly, that “in the latter time some shall depart from the faith, giving heed to seducing spirits, and doctrines of devils,” 1 Tim. 4:1.

The question has suggested itself to us, What would these men in their investigation to ascertain whether Spiritualism is fact or fiction, should learn that it is fact,—that there is really something to it, as there certainly is,—would they mistake fact for truth? Not being guided in their investigation by the word of God, would they come to a correct conclusion as to its nature and origin? Would they not call it truth instead of fact? We greatly fear for them in this respect. In the New York Herald before mentioned, Mr. Newton says:—

“My attitude in regard to Spiritualism is well-known. . . . I certainly believe that back of all the chicanery that has been practiced under the name of Spiritualism, there are great truths—a plus of something other than fraud.” And then he adds, “What it is, we do not know.”

We are thankful to say to our readers, however, that to each of the above-named persons has been mailed a copy of the pamphlet entitled, “Modern Spiritualism,” and we trust that it may have some influence upon some, at least, of those engaged in this investigation. Several favorable replies have already been received. Mr. Allen says:—

“We thank you for the pamphlet upon ‘Spiritualism.’ We desire to consider everything bearing upon the subject.”

Mr. Horton replied:—

“I thank you for the courtesy of both [letter and pamphlet]. At the first opportunity I shall read the ‘Essay on Modern Spiritualism.’”

It is indeed time that men were learning what is the nature and origin of that doctrine, the manifestations of which are to be the overmastering delusions of the last days. The Bible student has no excuse for ignorance upon this subject. After carrying us down past the papal persecution in that notable prophecy found in the twenty-fourth chapter of Matthew, Christ says: “For there shall arise false christs, and false prophets, and shall show great signs and wonders; insomuch that, if it were possible, they shall deceive the very elect. Behold, I have told you before.” From the most casual glance at passing events, who cannot see that we have reached the time of false christs and wonder-workings? Truly we are amid the perils of the last days. Let us watch and be sober, holding up the light that others may see the pitfalls of Satan, and escape his snares. W. A. C.