Professor H. C. Sheldon in the February number of the Andover Review, Boston, discusses, under this heading, the subject of papal infallibility, in a manner which not only pulverizes the absurd dogma, but also shows its blasphemous character. We have been wont to affirm that the prophecy of Dan. 7:11, concerning the “voice of the great words which the horn spake,” was strikingly fulfilled in the action of the great ecumenical council of 1870, which in the most deliberate and formal manner decreed the infallibility of the pope. Mr. Sheldon corroborates this view by declaring that act “the supreme sacrilege of the nineteenth century.” The article is worth reading carefully, and preserving, for the important facts which it contains:—
Long before the Vatican Council of 1869–70, the infallible authority of the church had been recognized as the foundation of the Romish system. At that council the foundation was narrowed to the compass of a single intellect and will, and the whole system was made to rest on the infallible authority of the pope.
According to the definition which was promulgated, the pope is infallible when he speaks ex cathedra on questions of faith and morals. His unique gift, it is to be observed, subsists under two limitations: first, in order that his utterance should have the stamp of infallibility, he must speak ex cathedra. This means simply that he must speak in his official capacity as head of the church, or with the design to impose his decisions upon the faithful. No further meaning can be properly attached to the phrase.
The second limitation—the specification that faith and morals are the proper sphere of infallibility—is far from being a radical limitation; in truth, it imposes scarcely any restriction. Faith and morals can be made to cover a very wide territory. Thus Cardinal Manning informs us that a scientific or philosophical proposition, which is necessary to guard the faith, is virtually itself a matter of faith, and so falls under the infallible decision of the pope. Now, since the pope, in virtue of his position as supreme governor, must be left to judge what is necessary to guard the faith, there is absolutely nothing, except his own discretion, to prevent his manipulating the whole subject of philosophy. In short, we speak with scientific exactness when we say that the existing constitution of the Romish Church, as embodied in the Vatican Decrees, makes the Romish pontiff, in point of authority, God upon earth. To appeal to God from any formal decision of the pope is, in the light of that constitution, a sinful rashness and affront to the divine ordinance, which has made the pope God’s infallible Vicegerent, and provided that all questions of faith and morals should be settled at his tribunal.
As regards this claim to infallibility, which has no support in Scripture: the Romanist, no less than the Protestant, must allow that a single contradiction in the formal or ex cathedra teaching of the popes would overthrow their infallibility. He must also admit that a single formal contradiction of scientific truth by an individual pope would be fatal to the dogma of infallibility. We pass, then, to the great test cases which fall under one or the other of these descriptions. Three are especially noteworthy.
The first is that of Pope Honorius, whose pontificate fell in the seventh century. It is a notorious fact that this Honorius was mixed up with the monothelite heresy, or the denial of a proper human will in Christ; that he wrote letters to Sergius, in which he distinctly approved the monothelite formula; that he was condemned, after his death, for thus supporting and advocating heresy.
That black sheet of anathemas against the heretical pope, flung out over the centuries, proves that the church of that age, as represented by ecumenical councils and popes, did not recognize any ex cathedra infallibility in the Roman pontiff.
The next great test case of papal infallibility appears in the action of the councils of Constance and Basel in conjunction with Martin V. and Eugenius IV., respectively. “The Council of Constance” set forth in explicit terms that it was lawfully assembled in the name of the Holy Ghost, and had its power immediately from Jesus Christ, to which “every person, of whatever rank and dignity, the pope himself included, is bound to yield obedience in those things which concern the faith, the extirpation of the aforesaid schism, and the general reformation of the church in its head and members.” We have here a declaration that an ecumenical council is superior to the pope in point of authority; and Pope Martin V., however unwillingly, approved and ratified whatever, in matters of faith, the council had done conciliariter, that is, in a regular session. A few years later, at the Council of Basel, this sentence was quoted as proving the superiority of the council over the pope; and what is more, Eugenius IV., as Bossuet contends, in subscribing to the Council of Basel, subscribed to the very decree which had been passed at Constance. In view of these facts, what judgment shall one pronounce on the decrees promulgated at the Vatican Council in behalf of the pope’s infallibility and unqualified supremacy? On one hand stands the decree of the council and the confirmatory sentence of the pope; on the other hand, and in direct contradiction of the foregoing, stands the decree of the pope and the consent of the council. It is pope and council contradicting pope and council—the church arrayed against itself.
The third great test case of papal infallibility is found in connection with the condemnation of scientific theories taught by Galileo and others. Galileo’s theory of the earth’s motion was declared in February, 1616, by the theologians who acted as qualificators for the Roman inquisition, to be philosophically absurd, formally heretical, and directly contradictory of many statements of Scripture. In the formula of abjuration, which was prescribed to Galileo, the same theory is characterized as false and repugnant to Scripture. In these proceedings the pope was undoubtedly the supreme director. Further, the “Index,” in which the works of Copernicus and Foscarini were prohibited, for teaching the movement of the earth and the fixity of the sun, had affixed to it a bull by Alexander VII., wherein each and every specification of said Index was declared to be confirmed by apostolic authority.
Now we submit that all apostolic authority which, by judicial process and by formal declarations, endeavored to manacle the church in the bonds of falsehood, was not in a high sense, apostolic, and that it is poor comedy to attempt to make it parade in the guise of infallibility.
Apart from the political bearing of the interference of a bogus god in the affairs of the nations, the dogma of papal infallibility must be regarded as a menace to Christian society. Its promulgation (viewed in itself rather than in the motives of its agents) was the supreme sacrilege of the nineteenth century,—a sacrilege against history, against the ethical standard of the New Testament, against human freedom.