IN THE QUESTION CHAIR

14%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Mar 31, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 13.

Read the full edition

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

The “Testimonies.”

J. M. VAN KIRK, Ruthven, Iowa, asks:—
“1. Does the Seventh-day Adventist Church believe the so-called ‘Testimonies’ and writings of Mrs. E. G. White to be revelations from God? 2. If the foregoing question be answered in the affirmative, then I inquire: Upon what grounds do you accept her writings to be revelations from God? 3. Has Mrs. E. G. White ever performed any miracle in support of her claims?”
Answer.—(1.) The Seventh-day Adventist Church regard the “Testimonies” and writings of sister White as having come through one of the “gifts of the Spirit” (1 Cor. 12:1, 4, etc.; Eph. 4:8, 11), which were especially “set” in the church (1 Cor. 12:28), and were to continue to the end. Acts 2:17–20; 1 Cor. 1:6, 7. Among these gifts is the “spirit of prophecy,” the operation of which is to bring a person so fully under the influence of the Holy Spirit, that to such person are given, through “open vision” (1 Sam. 3:1) or some equivalent operation, views of the spiritual world, revelations of the spiritual condition of the church or individuals, of present and future dangers and duties, and of things to come. John 16:13. This feature of the gifts, if we rightly apprehend certain prophecies, was to become especially prominent in the days which immediately precede the second advent of Christ. 1 Thess. 5:1–4, 19–23; Rev. 12:17; 19:10. When one meets some manifestation of this kind which he believes to be a genuine operation of the Spirit of God, we leave any one to judge how far he must receive what comes in this manner to be a revelation from God.
(2.) The second question is quite fully answered in the foregoing. We believe the writings of sister White to be a revelation from God, because we believe them to be one of the gifts above referred to. And we believe them to be one of the gifts, because they bear all the marks and characteristics which are set forth in the Scriptures by which a work of this kind is shown to be genuine. When Paul, in 1 Thess. 5:19, 20, says, “Quench not the Spirit,” and “Despise not prophesyings,” he adds, “Prove all things” (that is, test all which claims to be the gift of prophecy by the work of the Spirit), and “hold fast that which is good,” rejecting, of course, all manifestations which are false and bad, as we see them illustrated in Mormonism and modern Spiritualism, because these, although they show marks of the preternatural, all lead away from God and the Bible, and thus reveal their true character. (See Deut. 13:1–3.)
(3.) This question strikes us as betraying quite a misapprehension of the subject of the “gifts.” Spiritual gifts do not appeal to the evidence of miracles in their support; for one of the gifts themselves is the “working of miracles.” In other words, the gifts are their own evidence. Suppose one has “the gift of healing” (1 Cor. 12:9), and God works through such an one to relieve a sufferer from infirmity and disease; would it not be a strange demand for some one then to ask him to work a miracle to prove that he had healed the person? The healing would be its own evidence. So when one claims to have had revelations through the Spirit of God, the working of a miracle would not establish his claims, for there are false miracles; but we must judge of it by other evidences. We do not find that either Daniel or John ever worked a miracle to prove that any vision which they claimed to have, was genuine. In the case of the gift of prophecy, we look first at the character and position of the one who makes the claim; secondly, at the tendency of what is taught, that is, whether it leads to truth and purity, and the cultivation of the heavenly graces, or away from these things and away from God; and, thirdly, whether there is anything in what is already revealed, or in facts themselves, to contradict what is set forth. And if in all these respects it bears the test, then we believe it is to be received.