Mistake of the Adventists.
By William Brickey
We are often met with the objection that the Adventists made a mistake in 1844. We do not propose in this article to explain this mistake, for this has often been done in the Review and books, to our entire satisfaction; but we wish to suggest a few thoughts in connection therewith. It is no sign at all that a movement is not in the providence of God, because his people make a mistake. To err is human. God told Jonah to cry against the wicked city of Nineveh. Jonah 1:2. So far as the record shows, he did not preach repentance, yet God’s dealings with all nations showed that if they would repent, God would spare the city. Jer. 18:7-10. They did repent. God did spare the city, notwithstanding Jonah had said that yet forty days and it should be overthrown. Chap. 3:5-10. Jonah was greatly displeased because his prophecy was not fulfilled, yea, even wanted to die. This was a bitter experience. Just so it was with the Adventists in 1844. (See Rev. 10:10.) Was God displeased with the result of Jonah’s mistake? No more was he displeased with that of the Adventists, but simply said, “Thou must prophesy again.” Rev. 10:11. Moses knew from the word of God that the children of Israel would be delivered from Egyptian bondage. Gen. 15:13, 14. He also knew that God would deliver them by his hand. Acts 7:25. When he saw them so bitterly afflicted, he no doubt thought the time had come. He made a mistake. He slew the Egyptian, but he soon found that God was not in as big a hurry276 as he was. God would and did deliver them by Moses when he got ready. But Moses passed through a bitter disappointment, being obliged even to leave the country. Ex. 2:15. The disciples of Christ, with all the prophecies before them which are so plain to us now, thought then that the kingdom of God should immediately appear. Luke 19:11. They cut down palm branches, and spread down their garments to carpet his way to the throne, and cried, Hosanna to the King that cometh in the name of the Lord! Matt. 21:8, Luke 19:37-40. They thought Christ would immediately take his throne. Did their mistake prove that this demonstration was not approved of God? If they had not done it, the stones would have cried out. Luke 19:40. Why?—Because the prophet had said, more than 500 years before this, “Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion; shout, O daughter of Jerusalem: behold, thy King cometh unto thee: he is just, and having salvation; lowly, and riding upon an ass.” Zech. 9:9. But the good prophet did not say that Christ would set up his kingdom at that time. So the disciples had to suffer a bitter disappointment for their misunderstanding of the matter. In 1844 the Adventists were 1800 years nearer the setting up of the kingdom than the disciples were in their time. Which, then, made the greater mistake? Both were in the providence of God, designed to serve a good purpose in the experience of his people.