Ecclesiastics Heard From.
THE Independent is still anxious about the opening of the gates of the coming Columbian Exposition on Sundays. It has solicited the views of the leading ecclesiastics of the different churches of the country, and has received responses from ninety-seven which it publishes in its issue of April 23. As might be expected from those who are committed to the traditions and dogmas of popular theology, the great majority pronounce against having the gates open on Sunday. Where the surprise comes in, is in the fact that all do not so decide. But some of them speak in a way which will doubtless surprise their brethren.
Of six Roman Catholic archbishops, three are against opening, and three would open it afternoons; and of sixteen Roman Catholic bishops, four would close, eleven would open, and one is non-committal. Among the responding Protestant divines there is more confusion of sentiment in regard to the nature of Sunday, and why the Exposition should be closed on that day, and the effects which would follow.
We do not find any of the Catholics trying to muddle the fourth commandment of the decalogue into the Sunday institution; and one of them, Bishop J. L. Spalding, of Peoria, Ill., tells them plainly that Sunday is not the Sabbath. A few of the Protestants appeal directly to the Sabbath commandment, as the ground on which the Exposition should not be open on Sunday; but others sufficiently answer such a position. Thus J. J. Moore, D. D., Bishop of the African M. E. Zion Church, Salisbury, N. C., says: “I am emphatically in favor of the Exposition closing its gates on Sundays for the reasons that God sanctified the seventh day of the earth, or our Adamic world's beginning, or creation, and has set it apart thereby as a day of rest and religious devotion, and has commanded man to keep it holy.” From which he draws the conclusion that “they should preserve the sanctity of the Christian Sabbath [Sunday] for divine worship and rest.” But T. M. Clark, D. D., Bishop of the Protestant Episcopal church, Providence, R. I., says that many in the Episcopal Church would oppose the opening, “but not on the ground that it would be a violation of the fourth commandment, inasmuch as that prohibits work on the seventh [italics his] day of the week.” He thinks, however, that the “legal observance” of this day seems to have been set aside by St. Paul, and continues: “Neither would they base their objections on the assumption that the Sabbath has been transferred from the seventh to the first day of the week, . . . there not being any intimation of such a change in the New Testament, or any evidence to show that it was made in the early age of the Church, or that any one was ever authorized to do it, the word Sabbath not having been used to distinguish the Sunday, or Lord’s day, until a comparatively recent date.” Bishop C. Whitehead (Prot. Episcopal) Pittsburgh, Pa., thinks that on the whole, “more good than harm will be done by the opening of the gates of the Exposition on Sunday, after the hour of divine service, say at one P. M.” Bishop C. C. Grafton (same church), Fond du Lac, Wis., takes the Roman Catholic ground that the church changed the day. “She [the church] changed the day as given by God to Moses, from the seventh to the first day of the week.” At the same time he thinks the Exposition doors should be open Sunday after twelve o’clock, as, to use his own words, “it would only be in the interests of the saloons and theaters to keep them closed.” Others just as strongly argue that it would be in the interest of intemperance and immorality of every kind, to keep them open.
Chas. E. Cheney, D. D., Bishop of the Reformed Episcopal Church, Chicago, Ill., hits the “civil” Sunday plea, now so popular, a heavy blow between the eyes, when he says: “The moment that you take away from any man the plea that Sunday is a sacred day [italics his], on which labor becomes something offending his conscience, you take away from the laborer all defense against being required by the employer to work on that day.” The “civil” Sunday is simply a scheme to dodge the perplexing idea of “sacredness,” which cannot be shown from the Bible to pertain to Sunday in the least degree; but many, like Bishop Cheney, are not slow to see that without the idea of sacredness and some claims to bind the conscience, there is no hope for Sunday; and this is their embarrassment.
It is conceded that if the gates are open on Sunday, multitudes will throng the Exposition grounds. These, of course, will be persons who do not look upon Sunday in such a light as to consider it wrong for them to do so on that day. These are the only ones who would be affected by the closing. Now, how would it help the cause of morality among such, to be told that the managers do not think it proper for them to visit the Exposition on Sunday, and therefore they must stay out? They would be left to employ their time in some other way, but certainly not in any religious exercises. So it seems to us that the ministers who urge that the closing would be in the interest of the saloons, theaters, and beer gardens, have the best of the argument.