An article with this heading appeared some years ago, designed to raise prejudice against Seventh-day Adventists, and thus hedge up their way and break down their work. It was, of course, copied by some religious papers who are more than pleased if they can find something about the Adventists to hold up to public scorn. As the document was five sixths falsehood, and the remainder foolishness, we concluded to let it pass unnoticed.
It now appears, however, that some are so wonderfully pleased over the idea that S. D. Adventists have made some mistakes which they can ridicule, that they are having said article printed on separate slips, and sent out, contrary to law, through their papers for a wider distribution. They thus sometimes fall into the hands of those who, being friendly, but unacquainted with our history, write in to know what it means. For this reason we notice it. The whole document reads as follows:—
“When a prophet speaketh in the name of the Lord, if the thing follow not, nor come to pass, that is the thing which the Lord hath not spoken, but the prophet hath spoken it presumptuously: thou shalt not be afraid of him.” Deut. 18 : 22.
“The numerous mistakes which the Adventists have made, show that the Lord has not led them:—
“1. They set the time for the end of the world in 1843, and failed.
“2. They set it again in 1844, and failed again.
“3. Elder White set it again in 1845, and failed.
“4. They preached then that this earth was the sanctuary. This they now own was a mistake.
“5. They held then that probation for sinners was past. This they have now given up.
“6. For ten years Seventh-day Adventists began the Sabbath at 6 P. M., instead of at sunset as now.
“7. They kept their children out of school then because time was so short! Now those children have grandchildren in school!
“8. They gave away their crops and goods in ’44 because they would need them no longer.
“9. They opposed a church name; now they adopt one.
“10. They opposed church organization; now they believe in it.
“11. For years they would not plant trees. Time was too short. Now they wish they had.
“12. By a vision from Mrs. White, the women put on the short dress with pants. It was a shameful thing, and they had to abandon it.
“13. For fifty years they have been expecting the end of the world to come inside of five years, and it has not come yet.
“They have been wholly disappointed in everything they have predicted. It is just going to be, but never is. These simple facts should convince all that the Lord has not led them.”
The article, we have said, was aimed at Seventh-day Adventists, and was designed to convey the impression that it all applied to them; but either through the author’s rambling, rickety style of writing, or through a wicked intent to deceive, it is so worded that when its falsehood as applied to Seventh-day Adventists is exposed, a runway is all prepared into which to dodge. What “Adventists,” in general, have or have not done, is really no concern of the article; for the intent is to focus attention upon S. D. Adventists, who are the objects of attack. For the same reason it is no concern of ours;p. 281 and we shall answer it only from the standpoint of Seventh-day Adventists, which is all with which we have to do.
First, When we deny charge number one, and say that Seventh-day Adventists did not set the time for the end of the world in 1843, the author may say, indeed, I only said “Adventists,” not Seventh-day Adventists. But we shall treat it according to its intent, not according to its deceptive phraseology. And so we brand number one as a falsehood. There were no Seventh-day Adventists in 1843.
Second, We say the same of the second: there were no Seventh-day Adventists, in the present acceptation of the term, before the passing of the time in 1844.
Third, As to the third, Elder White was a Seventh-day Adventist in 1845; but he set no time. Falsehood No. 3.
Fourth, “They preached,” etc. Who? Adventists of the Elder White class?—No. When? In 1845 or later? None of his class. As applied to S. D. Adventists, it is false, for they never preached that the earth was the sanctuary; and as applied to Adventists of the 1844 class, it is false; for they never gave up that view as a mistake.
Fifth, The fifth, if it means S. D. Adventists, and sinners in general, is also false. So the first five so-called mistakes turn out to be falsehoods. But suppose all these five were true; what of it? Is it anything against a people, when they discover an error, to give it up and turn to the truth?
Sixth, Beginning the Sabbath at six o’clock. Well, in starting out in so radical a reform, is it anything strange that all the light was not seen at once? Many truths have been discovered since the days of Luther, and many have moved out in the various reforms discarding error for truth. Now suppose some one should sit down and make a list of all these, and publish them to the world as the “Mistakes of the Reformers,” how would that look in the eyes of all candid people? As soon as S. D. Adventists learned from a closer examination of the Scriptures, that they were wrong in the matter of commencing the day, they immediately changed to the true time. Was there anything wrong in that? Why the Sabbath was first observed by this people from six o’clock to six, is easily explained. When the Sabbath truth found them, they were keeping days by Roman time, from midnight to midnight. The Bible says, “From even to even” the day is to be reckoned. The question then was, When is “even”? Elder Joseph Bates, who was the first to teach the Sabbath in the light of Rev. 14 : 9–12, had for years been a sea captain; and he used the same reckoning on land that he had used on board of his ships, that is, mean time, from six to six; and this reckoning consequently went for a time with the Sabbath reform. And this was a vast improvement over the Roman reckoning from midnight to midnight; for this was in accord with Bible time twice a year; but that, never. So much for the six o’clock matter.
Seventh, They kept children out of school, etc. Who are the “they” here referred to? Were they Seventh-day Adventists? But this people have never taken any action on keeping children out of school. Some individuals may have done this. But what right has any one to charge a denomination with the mistakes of individuals? But there are many now who think it not desirable to send their children to the public schools on account of the associations to which they would be exposed. It was so then. It was more a question of association than of shortness of time.
Eighth, “They gave away crops and goods in ’44.” Who are the “they” referred to here? Are they the same as those of No. 7? It must be so construed, but if so, it is utterly false; for, as we have shown, there were no S. D. Adventists previous to the passing of the time in 1844. This is a specimen of the shambling style of this kind of literature.
Ninth, A church name, etc. How could “they,” referring to a denomination, oppose a church name and adopt one? This is not true of S. D. Adventists. Here two classes are blunderingly or maliciously confounded. First-day Adventists opposed a church name. When the question of adopting a name came before S. D. Adventists, some individuals, as was natural, were opposed to it; but the question was discussed and carried successfully, and a name was adopted. The only action S. D. Adventists ever took on the subject of a name, was to adopt one.
Tenth, Organization. The circumstances here were precisely similar to those of No. 9; and it is answered in the same way. As applied to S. D. Adventists, both are false.
Eleventh, Planting trees. Some individuals may have felt and acted as stated; but what has the denomination, the “they,” to do with that? S. D. Adventists have taken no action on whether they should, or should not, “plant trees” (!).
Twelfth, The short dress. The light on dress reform, rightly used, would have been a blessing, as it was designed. But unfortunately there are almost always persons of narrow minds and ultra ideas, connected with such movements, who cannot be restrained from going to such extremes as to turn the whole movement into a travesty. This is all there was “shameful” about this matter. But this is not the first time a movement designed to be a blessing has been frustrated. The apostles at first had all things common. Acts 2 : 44, 45. But through the infirmities of human nature, that was soon found to be impracticable, and they had to give it up. Why does not the author of “Mistakes of Adventists,” go blurting around the country about the “mistakes of the apostles”?
Thirteenth, Expecting the Lord within five years for fifty years. S. D. Adventists have not yet existed fifty years. Does he mean them, or somebody else? But surely one must be hard pressed for a list of mistakes against a people to call it their mistake because they have not realized their hope so soon as they thought might be. As an illustration, suppose the author himself is waiting at the station for the train which is indefinitely delayed, and does not arrive for an hour. Yet he is expecting it every minute all the time. What a foolish man to make sixty mistakes in one hour!
Now look at the logic of this attack. Thirteen mistakes are attributed to Adventists; and if the charges were all true, instead of being mostly false, as seen above, yet from the writer’s point of view the Adventists have now come onto the right ground, that is, have corrected all these mistakes. But he now virtually says to the world, Don’t have anything to do with this people, because they have made mistakes in the past. True, they have corrected their mistakes, and have come out all right now, but nevertheless they have been wrong sometimes, therefore fight them, break them down, and destroy their work, by every means possible. Does not this betray very astute logic, and a very amiable spirit (?).
As stated in the beginning, we should not have noticed this compound of weakness and wickedness, but for the sake of some inquiring friends who were not acquainted with the facts in the case.