The advocates of the Sunday law are seeking to improve every opportunity to create public sentiment in favor of their cause. Numerous articles have appeared in the Canadian papers in behalf of this move, dealing principally with the question as it relates to railroads, canals, and other works of a public character. Yet the proposed Sunday bill is comparatively very lenient in regard to those works, and extremely stringent in prohibiting work of a private nature, allowing railroad companies to do about as much business as they would be likely to want to do, and forbidding every kind of “ordinary employment” of private individuals.
The readers of the REVIEW will remember the letter from Rabbi Friedlander in a recent issue. Our entire correspondence was afterward published in the Montreal Star, a leading paper of Canada. This called out a criticism upon our letters, by a minister of one of the popular churches of Montreal. To this both Mr. Friedlander and myself wrote replies. We give these articles as condensed from the Star:—
John Nichols, in the Star of Jan. 28, commenting on the correspondence above referred to, expresses some surprise in that Mr. Friedlander and I had innocently raised a ghost, and were now making elaborate preparations for laying it. He admits that the Presbyterian General Assembly and the Lord’s Day Alliance are seeking legislation which shall secure a better observance of the Lord’s day, but denies that the laws which they call for would compel either Jew or seventh-day Christian to observe the first day of the week under the penalty of heavy fines. Thus, in substance, he continues: Neither of the above-mentioned organizations has ever sought, nor do now seek, laws which shall deprive either Jew or Adventist of his Sabbath or seventh day. The Presbyterians will always respect the religious convictions of the Hebrews upon this question, and would assist in their defense should they be assailed. No parliament would ever pass such a law. I have no time now to deal with Mr. Friedlander’s “incomprehensible enigma;” viz., what he calls our “Sunday Sabbath.” Believing that Jehovah requires a seventh of our time for rest and worship, we consider that we fulfill the divine injunction by observing the first day of the week as truly as Mr. Friedlander by observing the seventh. For him to demand identity of time the world over for the Sabbath day, is to demand an impossibility. He is keeping his Sabbath at this moment, but are his friends at the antipodes doing so? Would Messrs. Owen and Friedlander, going from this point in opposite directions, be keeping the same day when they met here again? Even a school-boy would answer No. We seek no union of Church and State. We simply ask the government to pass such laws as shall prevent men from desecrating God’s day, and committing wrongs against their fellow-creatures. Our railway companies, saloons, etc., etc., are exercising their liberty just now with a vengeance; but what about the liberties of their employees? Has any master a right to make his servant a slave in this manner?
Mr. Friedlander, replying to Mr. Nichols, in a letter to the Star, Jan. 31, stated the following in substance: I regret that in all the specious arguments of Mr. Nichols’s letter, hardly one sentence affects the main question at issue. Mr. Owen complains that the proposed Sunday laws would compel all Jews and seventh-day observers to keep Sunday under penalty of heavy fines. Mr. Nichols, in his vain endeavor to deny it, evades the question entirely, and puts it down black on white that the Jew and Adventist “will not be deprived of their Sabbath!” Has perversion ever assumed a more virtuous face? Mr. Owen speaks of Sunday, Mr. Nichols of Saturday. The former is apprehensive of being compelled to keep Sunday in addition to Saturday; the latter, with an air of incomparable simplicity, settles the matter by assuring both (Jew and Adventist) that they will not be molested in their observance of Saturday. It is a pity that Mr. Nichols “had no time,” as he states, “to deal with Mr. Friedlander’s incomprehensible enigma, the Sunday Sabbath.” Yet having no time, he devotes considerable space, and tries hard to explain that very “enigma,” but fails utterly. His circumnavigation logic, with his “school-boy” to boot, is as stale as the hills, and has nothing to do with the Sabbath; and if it had, would it not affect Sunday as well as Saturday? He says that I can produce no proof that they are seeking an alliance of Church and State. Now, if the government is to enforce religious laws framed by the Church, or vice versa, what else would you call it but a union of Church and State? “We are only asking the government,” says Mr. Nichols, “to pass such laws as shall prevent men from desecrating God’s day.” (God’s day! Which day is that—which day is it not?) “Whenever in the history of this world, government has assumed the religious functions,—the care of souls,—there has been trouble; there has been persecution.” Besides this, it is a provable fact that no man has ever become religious by legislative enactments. Neither Church nor State has any right to arrogate to itself in matters of belief, any further right than the right to teach, any further power than the power to convince, any further weapon than the weapon of reason.
My reply to Mr. Nichols’s letter is briefly this: That the proposed Sunday law is only a ghost, we will not deny; for we believe there are too many liberal-minded men in Canada to allow it to assume a bodily form among the laws of our fair dominion. However, we did not raise that “ghost.” It is the offspring of an alliance which has been formed to enforce its religious convictions upon free-born Canadian citizens. Its first appearance in Parliament was March 5, 6, 1890. It then vanished; but its return is expected soon. The secretary of the Lord’s Day Alliance wrote me that Mr. Charlton would reintroduce the bill of last session, upon this point, at the earliest date. Some of the characteristic features of the bill are, 1. It defines Lord’s day to be the first day of the week. 2. Whoever on the Lord’s day shall do any work other than works of necessity and charity, shall be deemed guilty of misdemeanor. 3. Any person convicted of such misdemeanor shall, for each offense, be fined from one to fifty dollars, with costs of proceedings and conviction. 4. In default of payment of fines and costs, the offender shall be committed to the common gaol. 5. The only class exempt are the people called Indians. Would not this compel Jews and seventh-day Christians to observe the first day of the week under penalty of heavy fines?
But Mr. Nichols is very liberal. He says we will not be deprived of our Saturday Sabbath. Suppose that the members of Parliament were induced to enact a law enforcing upon all classes the sabbatic observance of the seventh day. How quickly would Mr. Nichols and ten thousand others rise up in opposition to such legislation, saying, “That law infringes upon our rights.” Oh, no; not at all, Mr. Nichols, you will be allowed to keep the first day! We will “always respect your religious convictions.” We are simply going to fine or imprison you if you refuse to keep Saturday! Would such laws be just and liberal?—No, indeed! But if (as Mr. Nichols says) God requires only a “seventh” of our time, what right has the State to require another seventh after a man has fulfilled God’s requirements by keeping the seventh day “as truly as” the one who keeps the first day? Does Mr. Nichols, after defining God’s plan, propose to make improvements on it? “Shall mortal man be more just than God? shall a man be more pure than his Maker?” If Parliament may decide one religious question, and enforce its decision by a civil enactment, may it not decide every religious controversy? Let men be free to choose or refuse in regard to religious matters. Then let the Church rouse to her work, relying not on the power of civil law, but upon the power of God. Let her take the “sword of the Spirit, which is the word of God,” and “reprove, rebuke, exhort, with all long-suffering and doctrine.” R. S. OWEN.