BY W. E. CORNELL.
(Des Moines, Iowa.)
A SHORT time ago Rev. H. E. Mott, pastor of the Second Presbyterian church at Dubuque, Iowa, preached a sermon on the closing of the World's Fair on Sunday, and during the discourse took occasion to express his opinion on the subject very emphatically. At its close he called for a rising vote of all who were in favor of the movement, when it is reported every person in the congregation arose except Senator Allison, whose name is familiar to the readers of the REVIEW, and who, indeed, is known everywhere as one of the most prominent members of the United States Senate. His action caused much comment in the religious and secular press, both pro and con. The Register, the leading Republican paper in the State, complimented his action, and declared that it must certainly meet the approbation of all fair-minded people. Rev. Mr. Crafts, who is now in the State, in the interest of his pet theory, took the editor to task for his position, among other things saying:—
You and some others seem to think that our official National Fair can be neutral on the Sabbath question only by taking the wrong side. Neutrality is impossible. The Fair must attack or respect the National Sabbath.
Rev. Mott continued his subject last Sunday, and while Senator Allison, was not, so far as known, present, the editor of the Dubuque Ledger was, and from his criticism appearing in the next issue of his paper, the following is extracted, which shows that he is not afraid to express his views on this subject. His statements will be read with interest:—
Rev. Mott undertook to discuss the subject of Sunday observance from the standpoint of both the citizen and the minister, but it was obvious to his hearers that the bulk of his argumentative force was expended on the side of the minister. This is only natural. The minister is invariably inclined to view secular questions rather narrowly,—to weigh evidence in the scales of partiality,—to discuss issues solely with reference to their bearing on orthodox or doctrinal matters. It is therefore not surprising that Rev. Mott, in attempting to debate the Sunday observance question, should fall into the common ecclesiastical error or weakness of viewing the evidence procurable through the lens of religious prejudice.
Sunday has for centuries been regarded as a day of rest and recreation by all civilized nations. That it is a day especially ordained for worship has always been a debatable question. As far as we know, there is no biblical authority for the assumption that on Sunday all men should turn their attention to religious worship. . . . The comparison Rev. Mott seeks to establish between Sunday and the legal holidays of this nation, is extremely odious. No one is compelled to observe the Fourth of July or Memorial Day if he sees fit not to do so. These are human institutions. That Sunday is a divine institution has yet to be fully established. Why, then, should laws be demanded compelling all men to observe Sunday according to the contracted idea of orthodoxy?
This question of Sunday observance can be best settled by leaving it alone! Its agitation can result in no good!