The following article, purporting to be a report of the discussion in Oil City, Pa., appeared in the World’s Crisis of July 1, under the heading “Discussion.” Fearing that some of our people may see it, and believe it to be true, we send the report to you for publication; also a remonstrance against it by forty-two people:—
April 27 there was a discussion in Oil City between Elder C. W. Stephens, of Alma, N. Y., and E. E. Franke, a Seventh-day Adventist. It lasted seven nights. Elder Stephens belongs to the Advent Christian Church. He handled the subject under discussion very ably, and left his opponent without much ground to stand on. The question debated was: “Resolved, That the seventh-day Sabbath has been abrogated, and the first day of the week, commonly called Sunday, has been set aside by divine authority as a day of rest and worship.” This Bro. S. proved beyond a doubt, and had a vote been taken, our Seventh-day man would hardly have had a friend in the congregation.
The days of the Seventh-day people are numbered in our city, as this discussion has aroused the people, and they have commenced to search the Scriptures, and they find that the first day of the week is the Lord’s day, and not the old Jewish law Sabbath. Bro. S. leaves Oil City with the good will of all the church people of all denominations for the able manner in which he handled the subject under discussion.
Yours in hope, R. G. Worden.
To this the citizens of Oil City respond as follows:—
We, the undersigned, having read a report of the discussion between E. E. Franke and C. W. Stephens, in the World’s Crisis of July 1, claiming the victory for C. W. Stephens, hereby brand the report as wholly false. The report was written by R. W. Worden, who fabricated the same because he was rejected as a member of the committee of judges, by Mr. Franke.
We would further say that E. E. Franke won the debate with ease (as also the hearty sympathy of nearly all his hearers), and left C. W. Stephens without an argument.
| W. B. Carr. | Miss I. V. Carr. |
|---|---|
| Miss J. L. Müller. | Peter Echreoz. |
| C. H. Combs. | D. W. M. Lane. |
| John Fuller. | L. E. Bush. |
| Chas. F. Bush. | Chas. Milliron. |
| Mrs. V. Milliron. | Matilda Ague. |
| Emma Mc Call. | George Mc Call. |
| R. A. Norden. | Mrs. Norden. |
| Mr. Amy. | P. C. Amy. |
| Mrs. Mays. | L. M. Stanton. |
| M. P. Amy. | Mrs. Carr. |
| Mrs. Rudisille. | Mrs. Begley. |
| Mrs. Bannon. | Julia Bannon. |
| Mr. Bannon. | Miss Lizzie Hallman. |
| Mrs. W. H. Porterfield. | Mrs. A. Coast. |
| F. Coast. | Mrs. A. M. Crum. |
| A. J. Brown. | S. Snyder. |
| John Snyder. | Mary Oram. |
| Kate Oram. | Uriah Taylor. |
| J. E. Taylor. | F. J. Downing. |
| F. Carr. | Mrs. Barbara Lee. |
It cannot be said that the above is written by S. D. Adventists alone, as eighteen are not S. D. Adventists at all. Some are strangers to Bro. Franke, and some are friends of Mr. Stephens, and have been members of his denomination. More names could have been secured had the effort been made. Stephens was badly beaten, and tried to shield himself by circulating false reports. J. L. Müller.