IN THE QUESTION CHAIR

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Aug 11, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 32.

Read the full edition

IN THE QUESTION CHAIR.

2 COR. 12 : 4. NOT LAWFUL TO UTTER.

What does Paul refer to in this scripture, which it is not lawful for a man to utter? T. H. B.
Answer.—See the margin: “not possible for a man to utter.” The words which he heard when he was caught up into the third heaven, he calls “unspeakable” words; that is, such things as no words known to human tongues could express.

TITUS 2 : 13. GOD AND CHRIST.

Is there any proof in Titus 2 : 13, that the “great God and our Saviour Jesus Christ” are one and the same person? Is Dr. Clarke’s idea correct that because the article is omitted before the last named, they must be the same? A. S. H.
Ans.—The literal reading of the text is, “Looking for that blessed hope, the appearing of the glory of the great God, and of our Saviour Jesus Christ;” and substantially so the New Version renders it. When Christ appears, he appears “in the glory of his Father.” Mark 8 : 38. Only the appearing of Christ is brought to view in Titus 2 : 13, and the glory of the great God, the Father, is spoken of as an inseparable accompaniment of such appearing. The text does not assert that the great God and Christ are one and the same person. Dr. Clarke’s argument that it must so be understood because the article is omitted before Christ, is not well taken. Meyer’s Commentary on Titus 2 : 13, speaking in reference to this question, says:—
“It cannot be decided on purely grammatical grounds, for ‘great God,’ and ‘our Saviour’ may be two attributes referring to ‘Jesus Christ’; still it may be also that ‘our Saviour Jesus Christ’ is a subject distinct from ‘great God,’ even though only one article is used.”
Further information is given in a foot-note, as follows:—
“Hoffman wrongly asserts that because ‘our Saviour’ stands before ‘Jesus Christ,’ and with ‘great God,’ under one and the same article, therefore ‘our’ must belong to ‘great God’ as much as to ‘Saviour,’ and ‘great’ to ‘Saviour’ as much as to ‘God,’ and both together to ‘Jesus Christ’ as predicate. There are instances enough of two distinct subjects standing under one article only, and we cannot see why these instances should not be quoted here. . . . The article before ‘great God’ may, according to New Testament usage, be also referred to ‘Saviour Jesus Christ,’ without making it necessary to assume a unity of subject.—Comp. Buttm. pp. 84 ff; Winer pp. 118 ff.”

ROM. 5 : 13. SIN UNTIL THE LAW.

What are we to understand by the expression in Rom. 5 : 13, “For until the law sin was in the world”? E. B. V. D.
Ans.—By the words “until the law,” the apostle doubtless covers the same time that he calls in the next verse, “from Adam to Moses.” His argument is that death entered into the world by sin; but sin was in the world from the time it came in through Adam till the time of Moses. Then it follows that all this time God had a law in the world: “for sin is the transgression of the law;” and “sin is not imputed when there is no law.” But Adam’s sin did more than to bring death upon himself; it entailed it as a result upon all his posterity; and so death reigned from Adam on, even over those who had not sinned on their own personal account as Adam did. The innocent as well as the guilty pass under the dominion of death; for we are taught by the marginal reading of the last clause of verse 12, that all men are accounted sinners in Adam, so far as to be made subject to death.
It will be noticed that verses 13–17, inclusive, are parenthetical. Connect verse 12 with verse 18: “And so death passed upon all men, for that all have sinned.” (Or as in the margin, “in whom”—Adam—all have sinned; that is, are so far accounted sinners as to come under the power of death, which comes by sin.) “Therefore, as by the offense of one judgment came upon all men to condemnation.” The one sin of Adam and Eve in eating of the forbidden fruit, opened the flood-gates of death upon the world. The guilty pair were immediately called to trial, and the sentence passed upon them in accordance with the penalty which was threatened in case of disobedience: “In the day that thou eatest thereof thou shalt surely die.” Gen. 2 : 17. So after the transgression, God pronounced the sentence, “Dust thou art, and unto dust shalt thou return.”
The formation of the plan of redemption provided for Adam a new period of probation before the penalty should be executed, and provided probation for all his posterity. But at the end of 930 years the penalty was executed upon him, and he died. But from the date of his sin he inherited a dying nature, and that alone he could transmit to his posterity. But Adam’s death had to do only with the sin of eating the forbidden fruit, and in his case was the penalty for that, and settled that account. But Adam has yet to answer in the resurrection for all the deeds of his life during all the period of probation granted him by the plan of redemption through Christ, from the date of his sentence to the day of his death, as all who have lived since Adam will have to give, in the resurrection, an account of their own personal deeds.
So, then, we have death coming into the world, in the beginning. But death shows the presence of sin; and sin shows the presence of law, and that the world was under moral law to God. And this state of things existed from Adam to Moses. Let no one therefore say that the moral law, the decalogue with its Sabbath commandment, first came into existence in the time of Moses; for the presence of sin and death through all the ages back of that shows that that law was in existence there. But by the phrase “until the law,” he does not mean that no sin has been in the world since the time of Moses, and that death has not reigned since. His object was only to clear the ground from Adam to Moses, as from that time on there is no room for cavil.