AdventAI

THE SUNDAY LAW QUESTION IN DULUTH.

By E. Hilliard

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 32., August 11, 1891

For something over a week the city of Duluth has been considerably agitated over the playing of base-ball on Sundays. The games are played at Recreation Park, in the western suburbs of the city, some distance from any church, and in the afternoon, when there are no church services. This has been going on for some time without much being said, or any interference. Undoubtedly things would have continued the same had not Rev. W. F. Crafts visited the city, and organized a Sunday Rest League, which is composed of most of the denominations of the city. After this organization was effected, that which had previously been a disturbance to no one, suddenly became a public nuisance. Of course the ministers were the prime movers in creating the disturbance. One incentive which seems to prompt them to work for a compulsory Sunday law, is the little regard their members have for the observance of the day. This is evident from a statement made by E. O. Sharpe, pastor of the Christian church of this city, in his sermon Sunday, June 28. He said:—

Sunday should be observed in a true sense by a true Christian. Not only is it a holy day, but it is a civil rest day, and the place for all men and women is at home. Let all men rest. But unfortunately the trains are moving, the mails are being sent over the land, machinery is in motion, men are working incessantly, and we Christians are patronizing their employers.

In the same sermon, he scored the mayor of the city (who is a Methodist) in the following words:—

But the mayor will allow Sunday base-ball, on the ground that it won't do to be too strict. It is poor business to allow professional ball players to run their business for revenue at the expense of public morals; for all sports are the cause of derangement of public morals, and especially so on Sunday.

The playing of base-ball on Sunday deranges the morals, and we Christians attend these games and patronize Sunday-breaking institutions; therefore a law must be made to stop the games and close these institutions, so that Christians will not have their morals deranged. Not satisfied with reprimanding the mayor before his congregation, Mr. Sharpe, in company with one of his fellow pastors, visited his office Monday morning, and the following, taken from the Duluth daily News of July 7, is the result of their visit:—

Revs. E. O. Sharpe and Seline called upon Mayor Davis, and had a conference with him. The reverend gentlemen asked his honor what steps should be taken, and was referred to Judge Morris. There was no anger expressed on either side, and the conversation was not marked by any hard feelings. The mayor, however, did not give the “leaguers” any encouragement. . . . Mr. Sharpe then went to Judge Morris, who informed him that he would only fine the Sabbath-day breakers, but that they could go back and play again, and that he did not propose to be both prosecutor and judge in such a case, and referred Mr. Sharpe to the county attorney as the proper official to consult in the matter. The attorney was consulted in regard to enjoining the Sunday ball players; but that idea was abandoned, as they were informed that a criminal offense of that nature could not be proceeded against by equitable means, but the penal code is the only recourse. However, the members of the Rest Day League are not discouraged, but propose to press matters to a final victory or defeat.

An amusing incident in connection with the interview at the municipal court room was related to the News reporter. Judge Morris, just before the ministers arrived, was enthusiastically telling his associates of the many excellent points in Sunday’s game, and how he enjoyed it, and in a few minutes thereafter Rev. Sharpe informed the judge that he had very little admiration for a man who had no more self-respect than to attend a Sunday ball game. The judge took his lecture without wincing, but after the reverend gentlemen had gone, he ran his hand through his flowing locks, and his classical features took on that interesting expression they so often assume when he is listening to the testimony of a particularly amusing witness.

Dr. Ringland, of the First Presbyterian church, contended that Sabbath observance is not merely a religious question. “Beware,” said he, “of the specious pleas of those who would wish to establish a continental Sunday. The question of obedience to God is not to be argued. It behooves us to throw all lawful guards about the day.”

If such had power to enforce the law, the question would not be argued. The inquisition and dungeon would be the only arguments they would use. The doctor would throw “all lawful guards about the day,” to make men obey God; and then stoutly affirm that it is not religious legislation. He said: “Every State has laws regulating the observance of Sunday, which is recognized as a civil rest day.”

We think that the doctor must have forgotten that California has no Sunday law, and will compare favorably with any of her sister States which have one, as to orderly Sundays. In speaking of the necessity for a Sunday law, the doctor further said: “The world’s health, both here and hereafter, depends upon it. Respect for the Sabbath is the beginning of a true regard for eternal things.”

Of course, he was pleading for the law from a civil basis, with purely sanitary ends in view; but at the same time he argued that it would be “the beginning of a true regard for eternal things;” and then would not have us think for a moment that the law is to be enacted for the religious observance of the day, or especially in the interest of religion.

The clergy, after preaching faithfully against desecrating Sunday by base-ball playing, visiting the mayor, judge, and county attorney, and receiving no encouragement in regard to enforcing the law, decided to call a meeting of the newly organized Sunday Rest League, and discuss what measures to adopt to make these base boys realize the enormity of their sin. It was appointed at the First M. E. church, Sunday evening, July 12. The evening came, and also with it considerable rain; still the house, which has a seating capacity for about 600, was well filled, and extra seats were brought in. For some reason the ministers had but little to say. Dr. Maxwell, a physician in the city, and a member of the Christian Church, and Lawyer Briggs did the speaking. The question was premised upon a civil basis, but the conclusions all the way through were drawn from religious premises. There seemed to be considerable friction as to what constituted Bible proof for Sunday sanctity. Dr. Maxwell was opposed to calling Sunday the Sabbath, and was sorry that his brethren persisted in giving it that appellation. He argued that Sunday cannot be supported by the fourth commandment of the decalogue. He thought that commandment enjoined the observance of the seventh day in the Mosaic dispensation, but was abolished by Christ, and Sunday, the Lord’s day, the one upon which Christ arose and ascended to heaven, was instituted in its place; yet he failed to point out the text where Christ said so.

If our brother would study the Scriptures a little more closely, we hardly think he would want to state before an intelligent audience that Christ ascended on Sunday. He ascended forty days after his resurrection, which would be on Thursday. The fact that Christ arose on the first day of the week would, however, be just as good proof for Sunday-keeping as his ascension would be for Thursday-keeping, for he commanded the keeping of neither day.

Lawyer Briggs stated that he would read from the twentieth chapter of Genesis as a foundation for his sabbatical superstructure, and proceeded to read the fourth commandment of the moral law. Of course he meant the twentieth chapter of Exodus; but it was just as well, for he would have found just as much proof for Sunday in the twentieth chapter of Genesis as in the twentieth chapter of Exodus; for all who have read the commandment know that it enjoins the seventh, instead of the first day of the week. That which the first speaker abolished the second one took for his foundation. The difference between the two speakers was, one failed in the Old Testament and the other in the New, and both stood diametrically opposed. Notwithstanding the speakers could not agree as to what constituted Bible evidence for the sacredness of the day, they were most emphatically in favor of legal enactments to compel others to regard the day as holy time. Lawyer Briggs, in closing, made a most earnest appeal to the Protestant churches to join hands with the Catholics in the Sunday crusade. Petitions were circulated, asking the mayor to enforce the Sunday law, which were freely signed by many.

How apparent that events are shaping in fulfillment of Revelation 13! The agitation of the Sunday law question is creating public sentiment in its favor, and soon all that will be necessary for the formation of the image to the beast will be the combination of the various organizations now working for it. Let us seek a close connection with our Saviour, and, aided by his Spirit of meekness, be enabled to meet the strong opposition in the right manner, and thus help spread the last message of mercy to the world.

Duluth, Minn. E. HILLIARD.