BY ELDER W. H. LITTLEJOHN.
(Battle Creek, Mich.)
In Dan. 8:13, 14 is found a most remarkable prediction. It reads as follows: “Then I heard one saint speaking, and another saint said unto that certain saint which spake, How long shall be the vision concerning the daily sacrifice, and the transgression of desolation, to give both the sanctuary and the host to be trodden under-foot? And he said unto me, Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the sanctuary be cleansed.” It will be observed that in this passage is recorded a question which one angel propounded to another angel in the hearing of the prophet. The question itself is simple and direct, and relates to the period during which the church of God was to be subjected to oppression from certain hostile powers. For some unexplained reason, the answer to the question propounded, if given at all, was given to Daniel instead of the angel who uttered the interrogatory.
We can readily perceive that there may be good reasons why the angel addressed, should make his reply to the prophet, but it would look very much like discourtesy on the part of one angel toward another, had the one appealed to, refused or neglected to respond either directly or indirectly to his questioner. As Daniel represented the church in all ages, and as the conversation that took place was especially designed for the enlightenment of that church, it was in the highest degree proper that the instruction given should be addressed to Daniel personally.
Taking it for granted, therefore, that our text does really contain an answer to the question relating to the duration of the time during which the saints were to be trodden under-foot, we are shut up to the conclusion that the answer sought for, is found in these words: “Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the sanctuary be cleansed.”
To the casual reader, it might be difficult to discover in this language an answer to the angel’s question. I fancy that I hear him say, “It is true there is an allusion to time in the passage, but the 2300 days spoken of are said to reach to the cleansing of the sanctuary, which event, whatever it may be, certainly can in no wise be connected with the persecution of the people of God.” Such, we say, would be the view that the average reader would take of the subject.
But before accepting that view as conclusive, it would be well to examine it a little more critically. If the premises are correct, the conclusion is sound. If not, the conclusion may be faulty. The premise is that the cleansing of the sanctuary could have no connection with the oppression of the saints. The conclusion is that the sentence in which it stands, could not have been designed as an answer to the question propounded in reference to that oppression. Before adopting such a conclusion, it would be well, to inquire of the one offering it, whether he is quite sure that he understands exactly what is meant by the term “cleansing of the sanctuary.” Unless he differs widely from the average reader, we would risk nothing in venturing the assertion that the subject is one to which he has never given any thought; or at least, one that he does not comprehend. Possibly, therefore, investigation might reverse his premise, and consequently, his conclusion. In other words, if it can be shown that in connection with the cleansing of the sanctuary, events will transpire of such a nature that they might properly mark the termination of the long and bloody period of persecution through which the saints were to pass, then a reference to that work would furnish an answer to the angel’s question, both intelligible and pertinent.
What, then, we inquire, does the cleansing of the sanctuary signify? To answer this question intelligently, one must first understand what the term “sanctuary” is applied to in the Scriptures. The first mention of it is found in Ex. 25:1–8. In these verses Moses is instructed that the people should make for the Lord a sanctuary that he might “dwell among them.” The sanctuary, therefore, is nothing more nor less than a dwelling place for God. In Heb. 9:1–5, Paul describes the sanctuary of the first covenant; i. e., the sanctuary with which Daniel was familiar and therefore the one to which allusion was no doubt made by the angel. Should it be suggested that the tabernacle of Moses had given place before Daniel’s time to the temple of Solomon, it is sufficient to reply that they were substantially one and the same thing, though varying somewhat in external form. The furniture of both was practically identical, since both contained an ark, a candle-stick, a golden altar, a censer, a table of show-bread, and the tables of the covenant on which were written the ten commandments.
Thus much by way of defining the term “sanctuary.” The next inquiry should relate to what is meant by the “cleansing of the sanctuary.” The writings of Moses will, we think, furnish the desired information. From them we learn that on every day in the year, except the last one, the victims were slain, and their blood brought by the priests into the first apartment of the sanctuary, and sprinkled in front of the veil that separated that apartment from the most holy place, where the ark was situated that contained the law of God that the sinner had broken.
To sum up as briefly as possible, this procedure signified that the transgressor wished to confess his sins and secure pardon for them through the blood of Christ, which blood was typified by the blood of the victim that the sinner had slain with his own hands, after confessing over it his sins. John 1:29; 1 John 1:7. We repeat that on all except the last day of the year this work went on in the first apartment of the sanctuary. On the last day of the year, which was called the day of atonement, the high priest alone entered the most holy place where he made an atonement for the sins of the people and cleansed the sanctuary, performing certain very solemn rites and sprinkling the blood of a bullock and of the Lord’s goat, so called, upon the mercy seat and in front of the ark, agreeably to the provisions of the Mosaic law. Lev. 16:31–34.
In the 9th chapter of Hebrews the apostle Paul enters into an extended discussion of this subject, and shows most conclusively that the services performed in the tabernacle of Moses were simply typical and incapable of actually cleansing from sin. Heb. 9:6–28. He also demonstrates the fact that the blood of Christ will do that which the blood of bulls and goats could not accomplish; i. e., purge the “conscience from dead works.” Putting these two facts together, the conclusion is reached that the high priest of the Mosaic ritual simply performed a service that symbolized a work that Christ, the antitype of the high priest, should do for his people at some future time.
To locate that time, it is only necessary to examine the type a little more fully. Remembering that the round of service in the tabernacle of Moses covers the whole year and was repeated each year, it is readily perceived that it was designed to typify a work that would be co-extensive with the history of the race, and that the day of atonement, or last day of the year, must have symbolized a service that Christ, our High Priest, will perform for his people in the very close of time. The nature of that service at once becomes apparent. It must necessarily be performed in connection with the judgment, as it represents the final and unconditional disposition of the sins of Christ’s people; a thing that cannot be accomplished until the close of probation. Acts 3:19–21.
Thus much by way of defining what is meant by cleansing the sanctuary. From the facts adduced, it is discernible that the cleansing of the sanctuary was but a symbol of the judgment. Such being the case, we shall do no violence to the sense, if, in the reply of the angel we substitute the word “judgment” in the place of the expression “cleansing of the sanctuary.” The passage would then read as follows: “Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the judgment take place.”
But says one, you have simply changed the form of expression without helping us to understand its connection with the termination of the persecution of the people of God, spoken of by the angel. I answer, Very true; but if you will follow us a little further, all will become plain. In a former prophecy, Daniel had been shown that the session of the judgment would be the signal for the final overthrow of the papacy. In Dan. 7:25, 26 we read, “And he shall speak great words against the Most High, and shall wear out the saints of the Most High, and think to change times and laws: and they shall be given into his hand until a time and times and the dividing of time. But the judgment shall sit, and they shall take away his dominion, to consume and to destroy it unto the end.” The “little horn” which the connection proves to be the power alluded to in these verses, is admitted by nearly all Protestant commentators to represent the pope of Rome. Here, therefore, is a brief outline of the bloody history of that apostate power. For 1260 years (“until a time and times and the dividing of time”) the saints were to be delivered into his hand. At the expiration of that period, they were to be taken out of his hand, and subsequently to that event his dominion was to be taken away and consumed to the end; i. e., he was to be utterly shorn of the authority which had so long enabled him to put to death the saints of God. While his dominion remained, he could terrify the church. Deprived of that dominion, he could no longer harm any one. But when was that dominion to be taken away? The text says at the time of the “judgment.” Putting these things together, the import of Dan. 8:13, 14 becomes obvious to all. The angel had inquired, how long the “daily” (paganism) and transgression of desolation (the papacy or the Roman power) should tread under-foot the sanctuary and the host. The answer in substance was, as we have seen, that the host, or church, should be trodden under-foot until the judgment should sit. This answer Daniel could not fail to comprehend when he recollected the fact that the cleansing of the sanctuaryp. 644 and the work of the judgment were the same, and that the “little horn” was to lose its dominion when the judgment should sit. Dan. 7:25, 26.
There was one thing in the connection, however, that the prophet did not comprehend then and there. That thing was the time of the commencement of the 2300 days which were to reach to the final complete deliverance of the saints in the taking away of the dominion of the papacy. Subsequently he was enlightened upon this point also. Now if it is possible to find the termination of the days in question, and if, when found, it can be made to appear that the dominion of the papacy was taken away to be consumed to the end, and that from that time to this the pope has been powerless to oppress the saints, then the exegesis offered above will be so fully confirmed that no man ought to doubt its accuracy. It does not come within the scope of this article to enter into an exhausted discussion of the teachings of the 8th chapter of Daniel as a whole, or even of any part of it. For such a discussion, the reader is referred to a work entitled “The Sanctuary and Its Cleansing,” published at the Review and Herald Office.
In the vision of the 8th of Daniel, there was something which at its close, the prophet did not comprehend. The thing in question must have been the starting point of the 2300 days, since everything else was satisfactorily explained. In confirmation of this theory, the reader’s attention is called to Dan. 9:22–27. There the angel who had been sent to give Daniel “skill and understanding” requests him to “understand the matter, and consider the vision.” This done he addressed him as follows: “Seventy weeks are determined upon thy people and upon thy holy city.” You will observe that the allusion is to the matter of time. The word translated “determined,” signifies “cut off,” in the original. Do you ask what the seventy weeks were cut off from? The answer is, there is nothing from which they could be cut off save the 2300 days of the previous chapter. In other words the passage teaches that the first seventy weeks of those days were devoted to the Jews as a people; the balance was to cover the Gentile period. The Jews were cast off in A. D. 34; and about that time Paul was converted and sent to preach to the Gentiles. Acts 9:1–17. Seventy weeks (490 years) measuring backward from A. D. 34, would reach to B. C. 457, marking that point as the commencement of the 2300 days (years). Twenty-three hundred years, measuring from B. C. 457, would reach to A. D. 1844, when, if the view here advocated is correct, the cleansing of the sanctuary, or the judgment, must have been entered upon.
Do you inquire what sanctuary there was in existence at that time, since both the tabernacle of Moses and the temple of Solomon had been destroyed long ages before? The reply is, God has a sanctuary, or temple, in heaven, which is the great antitype of the Jewish buildings. In proof of this position, consult the following texts: Ps. 11:4; 102:19; Heb. 8:1, 2; Rev. 15:5; Heb. 9:23, 24; 8:4, 5. In 1844, from the premises introduced, it is argued here that the investigative judgment, or the cleansing of the heavenly sanctuary, was entered upon by our great High Priest, the Lord Jesus Christ. To this proposition it is idle to oppose worldly wisdom. God knows his own times better than we do. In such things it is only safe to follow the teachings of his word. The angel said that at the end of the 2300 days, or 2300 years, since in the prophecies of Daniel a prophetic day stands for a literal year, the sanctuary should be cleansed. As there was no sanctuary save that in heaven which existed at the end of that period, that must have been the one to which he referred.
If the interpretation of a prophecy be absolutely correct, events will in process of time, confirm that interpretation. Though we believe that no solid argument from the Scripture standpoint can be forged against the explanation of Dan. 8: 13, 14, heretofore set forth, it would be very satisfactory could it be made to appear that it is confirmed by the facts of history. A few words on this point, and the subject will be left with the reader.
About 1844 there was an unusual development in Italy, of factions hostile to the pope and his rule. The populace clamored more and more for Italian unity. The pope was in the way of the realization of that scheme. In 1848 he was driven from Rome. Subsequently he returned to that city. Never after that did he sit firmly and easily upon his throne. In 1870 he called the Ecumenical Council, that uttered the decree of papal infallibility. In July of the same year the cannon of Victor Emmanuel thundered at the gates of Rome, and the pope was virtually made a prisoner in his own palace; his temporal power was revoked, and he was deprived of the territory of the papal states. In other words, his dominion was wholly taken away. To-day he dare not lay so much as his finger roughly upon the shoulder of the meanest peasant residing within the limits of his former domain. The thunders of the Vatican are not feared, because they are not attended as formerly, with the lightning of the temporal power in any part of the world.
Thus, candid reader, in two significant directions does history confirm the fact that the judgment is now in session, first, by the blasphemous claims of the pope, which we all have heard in the matter of the papal infallibility dogma (Dan. 7:8–11); secondly, by the record of those startling events by which the pope has been gradually but surely bereft of his political power and influence. Dan. 7:25, 26. In the face of these facts, who will venture to deny that in Dan. 8:13, 14 there is found the question of an angel respecting the length of the persecution that the people of God were to suffer from papal Rome, and a clear and definite answer to the same in the words, “Unto two thousand and three hundred days; then shall the sanctuary be cleansed”?