The New York Christian Advocate of Oct. 1, mentions an incident which shows some confusion of sentiment in the Catholic Church, and how it can adapt itself to contradictions of its own theories when it suits its own interests to do so. If on the subject of heretics, marriage, and divorce, the church has a position, as it claims, clear and well defined, the “Archiepiscopal tribunal of Boston,” in the interest of their boasted unity, ought to have understood it, and so have saved itself the mortification of coming in conflict with the great head of the Church at Rome. The following is the case in question:—
“MARRIAGES BY PROTESTANT MINISTERS RECOGNIZED BY THE HOLY SEE.
“A decision was delivered in Rome on Aug. 16, of importance to many persons. William Grant of Bridgeport, Conn., got a divorce in the courts of that State, from his first wife. They had been married by a Methodist minister, but afterward Grant had joined the Church of Rome, to which his wife belonged. After getting his civil divorce, he applied for an ecclesiastical divorce, claiming that a Methodist marriage was not recognized by the church. In 1887 the local board declared the marriage valid. Grant appealed to the Archiepiscopal tribunal in Boston, which reversed the decision, and it was declared no marriage. The question was appealed to Rome, and there the highest authority declares the marriage binding, and divorce is refused. This places Grant in a peculiar position, as he has been for some years living with a second wife. As the Roman Catholic Church does not recognize the validity of the orders of Methodist ministers, this is equivalent to declaring that civil marriages are binding upon the consciences of Roman Catholics, and that a divorce obtained in the civil courts cannot relieve the Catholic from responsibility to his church; for Rome allows no divorce for any cause.”