TWO OR ONE?

6%

Seventh-day Adventist Publishing Association · Battle Creek, Mich. · Nov 10, 1891

FromReview and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 44.

Read the full edition

TWO OR ONE?

BY E. H. BRADLEY.
A YOUNG man who was a close observer of things, and a reasoner as well as an earnest believer in Christ, wrote several important questions to his mother, who wrote the following answers, which may set other sons and daughters to thinking too. It is better every way, that honest questions should be asked and honestly answered, while there is time to correct popular and widespread mistakes, than to learn the mistakes when they have become fatal, and cannot be rectified.
The letter from the son to his mother contained these queries and remarks:—
I have been thinking about something lately; if you have time, you can think it over.
Are there two kinds of salvation? or when one is saved, is it altogether a complete salvation? If a person is converted and afterward sins, and while sinning, dies, does he perish? According to Ezekiel, he does seem to. If this is as we understand it, the fact of being once converted, is no guarantee of eternal life.
Of course I remember that Christ said that if we were not born again, we could not see the kingdom of heaven, and you notice he says, unless we are born of water, and of the Spirit,—two distinct things,—we should not enter into the kingdom of heaven.
So it would seem as if simply being born again, was not sufficient to effect eternal life. Now, the question is, does “born of God,” mean two distinct things? And can we be unborn, after being born? If not, what does this mean, he that “is born of God doth not commit sin”?
People have been and are committing sin, who have ostensibly been born of God; but John says that a person born of God cannot, and hence never does, backslide; that is why I draw the inference that we usually interpret “born of God,” wrong. God is a spirit; the spirit, in fact; therefore, what is born of God must be spirit too; for whatsoever is born of the flesh, is flesh, etc., and that which is spirit cannot sin; yet Christians (?) sin, therefore they are not born of God. But what are they, then? Time is evidently no element in our salvation. How long? is not the question, but How long shall it be safe for us to sin without repenting again? or how long shall we live in righteousness before we may sin with impunity? There is no duration of time in God’s plan of saving us individually. The only mention of time in this regard is the present. “Now is the accepted time,” so that our life must be a succession of “nows.”
Again: as our life refers to now, so God’s punishment or reward must be all present (no past, or future, therefore, eternally), so of what use is it that we have been “converted” if we sin? do we not crucify Christ afresh? Whom does Christ intercede for now? Is it unbelievers, or believers who sin, or believers who do not sin, but live holy?
Obviously, it must be believers who sin, because unbelievers have not as yet partaken of the Sacrifice for their own sin; they have not entered the outer court and offered on the brazen altar, much less have they entered by proxy the priest’s court, and had incense offered for them. As for the third class, if they do not commit sin, they have no need, surely, of a Mediator, but are indeed and in truth sons of God. Yet Christ does mediate, therefore mediation is necessary. For whom?—For a class not otherwise provided for, but certainly existent and allowed for. So from this it seems as if holiness were more a great privilege than an essential. You notice, I say, it seems. It is a strange question, and not, I think, an unnecessary one—Is salvation all there is? I think not; I think there is a difference between sufficiency and affluence.
Again: there is to be a reward for works; but if we live by the Spirit, so that we do not commit sin, how can there be any difference between the works of one and another? All are done to the glory of God, and he is no respecter of persons, therefore the reward must be the same. I admit that the word “reward” does not always mean in a good sense. It seems to mean “recompense” or “deserts.” I am not affirming anything as my own, in this letter; these are merely ideas, and they should be met as such.
The mother who received that letter felt that these were ideas worth answering, and in the midst of other pressing duties, and in the absence of possible quiet concentration of thought, she answered after the following fashion, admitting that a cursory reply could not be made to answer fully any one of the questions, or to examine fully any one idea thus thrown out for inspection:—
1. “Are there two kinds of salvation?”—No; Christ Jesus was called Jesus, because he came to save his people from their sins. Matt. 1:21. Acts 4:12 plainly declares there is no other salvation, and in Acts 10:43, we are told that “whosoever believeth in Him shall receive remission of sins.” This makes the one salvation open to all who believe; and that all who thus believe “shall receive,” as plainly teaches that each pardoned believer will know he is forgiven, or it would not be true to say, such a believer “shall receive remission.” A remission sought after, and granted on conditions fulfilled, would not be worth having, if the seeker did not know it was granted. Therefore, we must know we have it, if we receive the thing we have sought, and fulfilled the condition laid down by the Giver. There are so many passages on this witness within the believer that it is difficult to choose the best. (Take 1 John 5:10: Gal. 4:6; Rom. 8:16, and search out more.)
2. “When one is saved, is it altogether a complete salvation?”—Yes, if the gift received is kept. The conditions upon which the gift of eternal life is bestowed, are (1) that repentance shall be the first step toward it (Mark 1:15, second clause; Acts 2:38); then (2) baptism in the name of Jesus, for the remission of sins, as prelude to (3) “ye shall receive the gift of the Holy Ghost.” Verse 39 declares that this promise is to every one of you; “to your children, and to all that are afar off.” Three thousand received this pardon and full salvation as the immediate result of Peter’s sermon that day. We have no report of the “many other words” which he spoke. In Acts 3:19 is a command to repent, promise of remission or blotting-out record of past sins, to be followed by times of refreshing from the presence of the Lord. (See also Luke 24:47; Acts 13:38, 39; 1 John 2:12.)
3. “If a person is converted, and afterward sins, and while sinning dies, does he perish?” (a) A converted person—a pardoned sinner—becomes a child of God; and we have reason to believe that at conversion, when repentance and remission of sins take place, there is joy in heaven. (See Luke 15:7; 5:32; 10:30, and other passages.) (b) “And afterward sins.” He needs repentance and pardon again, as at the first; and if he dies without repentance and pardon, his name will be blotted out of the book of life, if Christ means what he says in Rev. 3:5. That warning was not given to unrepentant, unpardoned sinners, to outsiders, to unbelievers, but to those whose conversion had entitled them to have their names recorded in the book of life, but, who having received the gift of adoption, had neglected and dishonored it, so were at any time liable to forfeit eternal life. By reading Rev. 3:19, we see that repentance was enjoined on other saints, who had grown careless, proud, and ceased to “overcome,” and thus being overcome of evil, were threatened with expulsion. Verse 16. They could not be spued out if they had not been in. John says: “Whosoever abideth in him sinneth not.” 1 John 3:6. (See also verse 8.) It seems that he spoke of those who had been adopted (pardoned), and had again changed their allegiance by listening to their former father, and so forfeited their adoption. John 8:34 has a plain word as to the mastership over those who commit sin. If professors of religion live in sin, under whatever name, Christ gives the test which has a right to apply. Matt. 7:20. In John 15, under the figure of the vine branches, Christ teaches plainly how sinners may be grafted on, or into, himself, and if they continue to let the sap of the vine—his Spirit—maintain the new life, they will bear fruit, that is, become more and more Christ-like. (Read Gal. 5:22, 23; Eph. 5:9; Col. 3:12; James 3:17, to see what these fruits are.)
If they cease to bear fruit,—Christ-like life, deeds, and words,—that is evidence that they are strangling the new life, and if they do not yield to the pruning, “purging” of the Master, and allow the evil tendency to be removed by complete submission to his will, so as to bear more and more perfect fruit, i. e., become more Christ-like in their lives, the Grafter will cut these branches off. (See John 15:6.) If that does not mean withering the divine (eternal) life, and destruction of the grafted-in branches, what does it mean? Therefore, ultimate, complete, eternal life depends upon the “abiding,” “the continuing in well-doing,” obedience all the time.
(Concluded next week.)