AdventAI

HE WITHDRAWS FROM THE CHRISTIAN CHURCH

By A. O. T.

From Review and Herald, Vol. 68, No. 45., November 17, 1891

The following open letter to the Duquoin Christian, or Disciple, church, written by a former evangelist in that denomination, is quite suggestive:—

Duquoin, Ill., Sept. 14, 1891.

To the Pastor and Officers of the Church of Christ, at Duquoin, Ill.

FRIENDS AND BRETHREN: I most respectfully address you this letter, hoping you will receive it in the same spirit of fraternal love in which it is written. And first, let me say, that during the past year of my evangelistic labors, I have become fully convinced that we differ so widely in regard to certain truths relating to spiritual things, which seem to me to be vital and all-important, the conclusion has forced itself upon me that my further continuance as an elder in the church would be unwise, imprudent, and fraught with evil results. And as regards these differences, as I now understand them, let the following suffice:—

1. I believe in the direct and immediate operation of the Holy Spirit in the conversion of a soul to God.

2. I believe there is a spiritual world in which the departed reside in a state of consciousness, and that any of these spirits, according to the conditions and laws governing them in their respective abodes, can revisit the earth and converse with mortals. [Italics ours.]

3. I believe in the direct personal administration of Christ and the angels, in the propaganda of the gospel among men.

4. I believe that the word and the church of God are eternal and unchangeable, and that the church to-day should be identical with the primitive church as founded by Christ and the apostles.

5. I believe that Christ regenerates and saves men to-day just as he did when he was here on earth; to wit, by coming in direct personal contact with them, mind to mind, soul to soul, and heart to heart, and thus imparting his spirit, power, and love to them.

6. This being the last and highest age,—the age of reason and the Holy Spirit,—I believe that more and more emphasis should be given to inward righteousness and the higher spiritual truths of the gospel, and less to the outward.

7. For example: such as, first, the direct and miraculous answer of God to prayer; second, the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, not merely through the words of written revelation, but direct, immediate, and personal; third, the outpouring of the divine Spirit or power of God upon them, as evidently as a rain-shower or a cloud-burst; and fourth, and above all, that the restoration of primitive Christianity will make the church of Christ to-day just what it was at the beginning.

Now, as the field is the world, and there is room for all; and furthermore, as I do not wish to sow dissensions and cause division among the Disciples (whom I honor highly), I am deeply impressed that the proper thing for me to do is to quietly and peacefully withdraw from the church. And to this end my wife and I most respectfully ask for honorable letters of dismissal.

Finally, let me assure you that I have no personal grievances, whatever; that no one could ask to be treated more generously and honorably than I have been; and, therefore, my most earnest prayer and desire are not to be less, but more, fraternal and cordial in the future than in the past.

Endeavoring to know the truth and obey it, we are, with high regards, very truly yours, A. J. FISHBACK, D. L. FISHBACK.

Mr. Fishback had strong spiritualistic tendencies when he joined the Disciple Church, yet he was accepted, and labored among them as a minister. But his devotion to Spiritualism has become so strong that he wants perfect freedom in that line. Considering his second proposition, however, it would seem that there is such a slight difference between him and the church from which he withdraws, that it is hardly sufficient to cause a separation. Mr. Fishback believes that the dead are conscious, and can visit their friends on earth, while his divorced church has the finely-drawn shade of difference that they are conscious, but cannot come back to their old associates here. The theory of the conscious state of the dead is the foundation on which Mr. Fishback and his Spiritualist friends stand, and since the believers in that theory have given him a basis for his doctrine, he should not thus cold-heartedly, without any provocation, withdraw from a church which believes the dead are still alive.

But our object in giving this open letter is to call attention to the strong religious convictions expressed by Mr. Fishback, many of which are quite in common with the general belief of Christians. He is quite well educated, thoroughly conversant with the Spiritualist movement, and knows about as much of its inward tendencies as any one. It is a matter of note that Spiritualism is represented in prophecy to be the master deception of the last days. And when it is thus seeking to advance its iniquitous pretensions, while attempting to cover the exterior with a guise of Christianity, it should cause us to see more clearly than ever the seducing tendencies of the movement. Spiritualism is now working quietly and mostly under cover, but it is soon to break out in the most marvelous deceptive wonders the world has ever seen. And while we have the opportunity, we should press the truth before the people and sound it in no uncertain tones, that the dead are wholly unconscious till Christ shall give them life, and hence it is impossible for them to visit us. And when there is an apparent manifestation of the return of the dead to this earth, it is only leading to a fulfilment of Rev. 16:13, 14, where the spirits of devils are represented as going to the “kings of the earth and of the whole world, to gather them to the battle of that great day of God Almighty.” A. O. T.